10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

As someone who has spent countless hours immersed in the rich tapestry of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth, I can confidently say that each of these potential spin-offs holds a unique charm and promise for fans of the beloved universe.

As a die-hard fan of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Legendarium, I find “The Lord of the Rings: War of the Rohirrim” an exciting new take on this beloved universe. Unlike the previous trilogies based on “The Lord of the Rings” and “The Hobbit,” this anime delves into uncharted territory by drawing inspiration from the Appendices of “Return of the King.” It breathes life into the epic war between Helm Hammerhand of Rohan and the Dunlendings. Moreover, it presents a fresh character within the Legendarium: Hera, Helm’s daughter. The initial response to this animated film has been overwhelmingly positive, and its success could pave the way for more spinoffs focusing on lesser-known tales and characters from the expansive world of Middle-earth.

Already, Tolkien fans are getting The Hunt for Gollum in 2026, but Tolkien’s Legendarium is full of even more amazing moments, characters, and stories. The author, and his son Christopher, spent decades hammering out the history of Middle-Earth, with books like The Silmarillion, The Book of Lost Tales, and The Unfinished Tales of Numenor and Middle-Earth expanding on the histories set up in the “Tale of Years” appendix from Return of the King. There are many great tales that could be adapted as LotR spinoffs, whether they be animated or live-action.

The First Wars Against Melkor Would Make for Great Films

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

The book “The Silmarillion” narrates tales from the First Era, covering events from the birth of the cosmos by Eru Illuvatar to the conflict that concluded this epoch. Inside, you’ll encounter the first Dark Lord, Melkor Morgoth, and an excellent starting point for sequels would be the initial wars against Melkor. Melkor was the strongest among the Valar and instigated much discord in the music that eventually shaped the universe. Desiring to conquer Middle-earth, Melkor entered the world along with some of the other Valar and Maiar. Numerous battles were fought against him until the emergence of the Elves and his initial defeat during a war fought on their behalf, which earned the Elves Melkor’s eternal enmity. These wars offer tremendous potential for spinoffs, allowing fans to delve into the powers that shaped Middle-earth in its ancient past.

The Tale of Thingol and Melian Would Tell One of Middle-Earth’s Most Important Stories

Upon arising on Lake Cuivienen’s coast, the Elves were initially unnoticed by the Valar. But upon Orome’s discovery of them, the Valar extended an invitation for the Elves to join them in Valinor, initiating a lengthy trek across Middle-earth towards the Great Sea’s shores. During this journey, one of the Elven leaders, Elwe, chanced upon Melian, a Maiar, gracefully dancing and singing in a secluded glade. Overwhelmed by affection for each other, Elwe momentarily lost sight of his people, who continued their journey in search of him. Elwe, later known as Elu Thingol, wed Melian and together they established the stunning Elven kingdom of Doriath, which housed those Elves who declined Valinor’s invitation. Their tale forms a crucial part of Middle-earth’s history, and a spin-off narrating their love story could prove to be an enchanting epic about love and destiny.

The Tale of Feanor, the Creation of the Silmarils, and Melkor’s Taking of the Jewels Is a Fundamental Part of Middle-Earth’s History

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

The Rings of Power.” He was a prominent Elf, particularly skilled in craftsmanship, and his story plays a crucial role in events of the First Age. His father was Finwe, king of the Noldorin Elves. Feanor is renowned for capturing the light of two magical trees in three precious gems known as the Silmarils. These gems were pivotal artifacts during the First Age, leading to significant conflicts and shaping the history of Middle-earth in ways many fans are unaware of. A spinoff series focusing on these events could provide fans with a deeper understanding of a key historical event they might not have known about before.

The Story of Beren and Luthien Is the Greatest Epic of Middle-Earth

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

The tale of Thingol and Melian is the prologue to the greatest story in Middle-earth. Beren and Luthien’s tale, told both in The Silmarillion and the novel Beren and Luthien, is one of love, loss, and reunion beyond death, telling the story of a man who falls in love with the most beautiful woman in the history Middle-earth – i.e., the daughter of Thingol and Melian. What follows is a true epic, as the two star-crossed lovers embark on a series of quests to be together. It’s a story that has everything anyone could want, and also has deep meaning in Tolkien’s life, as he based Luthien on his wife Edith. Beren and Luthien’s tale is beautiful and bittersweet and deserves to be given an adaptation worthy of it.

The Nirnaeth Arnoediad Is the Greatest Battle in Middle-Earth History

The Elven war against Melkor Morgoth in Middle-earth featured five pivotal battles, six if you include the one fought by the Valar to end the conflict; among these, the fifth – dubbed Nirnaeth Arnoediad or “Unnumbered Tears” – stands out as a prime candidate for its own spinoff. This battle saw alliances between Elves, Men, and Dwarves joining forces in an attempt to crush Angband, a goal spurred on by Maedhros, son of Feanor, following the revelation that Morgoth and his forces could be defeated after Beren and Luthien demonstrated the Dark Lord’s vulnerability. However, Morgoth had his own sinister schemes in motion, with many of Maedhros’ human troops secretly under his control. The ensuing battle was so devastating that it dwarfs the intensity of battles like Helm’s Deep and Minas Tirith from The Two Towers and Return of the King. The Nirnaeth Arnoediad is more than just a gruesome conflict; it tells a heartrending tale that promises to make for an exceptional spinoff, filled with poignant moments that elevate it beyond mere battle scenes.

The Narn I Hin Hurin Tells the Story of Middle-Earth’s Saddest Family

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

Hurin and his brother Huor were inhabitants of Dor-Lomin and took part in the great battle called Nirnaeth Arnoediad. Sadly, Huor was killed during the conflict, while Hurin was captured by the powerful villain Morgoth. A tragic curse was cast upon Hurin’s family, forcing him to bear witness to their lives being unraveled. This tale, titled “The Tale of Húrin“, is featured as the chapter “Of Turambar’s Son, Turin” in both “The Silmarillion” and the novel “The Children of Húrin“. The story focuses on Turin, Hurin’s son, who was brought up by Thingol and Melian after the battle because his mother Morwen shared a bloodline with their relative Beren. Unfortunately, Turin’s life is filled with nothing but misery from the start. Everything he does seems to backfire, turning even the good into evil. The curse of Morgoth ultimately leads to the destruction of Turin, his mother Morwen, and his sister Nienor. Their stories are some of the most heartbreaking within the Legendarium, making them a compelling choice for an anime series adaptation that portrays the highs and lows of Turin’s life.

Tuor’s Life Is Completely Different From His Cousin Turin’s and Helps Bring the War Against Morgoth to an End

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

Tuor, son of Huor, lived a life vastly distinct from his cousin Turin. His tale spans from the coastlines of the Grand Ocean, where the divine figure Ulmo communicates with him, to the clandestine city of Gondolin, where he encounters Elvish princess Idril Celebrindor and safeguards the city as the final stronghold of liberty following the Nirnaeth Arnoediad and the weakening of Elvish dominion. Given the First Age’s propensity for sorrow, Gondolin eventually falls, but not before Tuor assists its inhabitants in their exodus. Tuor and Idril bear a son named Earendil, and Tuor subsequently embarks on a journey to Valinor to petition on behalf of Middle-earth’s people to the Valar.

In the story, if a man fails, he’s bestowed immortality as an exclusive privilege. Earendil marries Elwing, who is the granddaughter of Beren and Luthien. Unlike his father, Earendil succeeds in persuading the divine beings (Valar) to aid the common folk, leading to the War of Wrath that brings an end to the First Age. The life story of Tuor offers another captivating narrative suitable for a detailed adaptation, be it animated or live-action. Given its richness and depth, such an adaption would likely require multiple installments, with a well-executed version promising to be truly spectacular.

Aldarion and Erendis Tells the Tale of One of Numenor’s Great Kings and His Queen

In “The Rings of Power,” the kingdom of Numenor and its monarchy play a significant role. Among the array of imaginative fictional royal families, the kings and queens of Numenor stand out as particularly captivating. Their journey through power and religion spans over thousands of years during the Second Age, offering a compelling tale filled with intrigue. Of these notable Numenorean rulers, Aldarion and Erendis are prime candidates for a spin-off film.

In my tales, I am often referred to as the Mariner King, Aldarion, whose youthful passion for the vast, mysterious sea led me to Middle-earth, where I formed an alliance with High King Gil-Galad. It wasn’t until my hundredth year that I crossed paths with the enchanting Erendis, who found herself entangled in my insatiable love for the sea. The tale of our relationship is deeply tragic; as my unquenchable wanderlust and concern for Middle-earth’s people led to a gradual chill in our once-burning bond. There’s no joyous conclusion to be found here, which is fitting for the story of Numenor – a tale of a nation that, like my own love, was ultimately destroyed by its obsession with power and ambition. My love for Erendis mirrors the fate of our island home; consumed by my devotion to my endeavors, I neglected what truly mattered and watched my love crumble, serving as a grim foreshadowing of Numenor’s demise.

Cirion and Eorl’s Tale Is the Genesis of the Alliance of Gondor and Rohan

10 The Lord of the Rings Spinoffs We Need After The War of the Rohirrim

The film “The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim” narrates an epic tale centered around Rohan, a story that every fan of “LotR” should witness. Historically, the Rohirrim were not a settled people; they were a nomadic group residing north of the Anduin River. When Leod, father of Eorl, passed away, young Eorl assumed leadership over his tribe. In the year 2510 of the Third Age, Cirion, the steward of Gondor, sent a plea for aid to Eorl against the invasive Men of Rhun. True to their word, Eorl and his people responded, charging south towards a battlefield where the combined forces of Gondor clashed with the armies of Rhun and Orcs from the Misty Mountains.

The ensuing conflict was known as the Battle of Celebrant. It was a battle that Gondor managed to win, thanks to the arrival of Eorl and his followers who lent their support. This act of kindness resulted in Cirion granting the lands that would later become Rohan to Eorl’s people, and both parties swore oaths of loyalty to one another, pledging mutual aid during future battles. Such a tale would make an outstanding film, providing fans of LotR with insight into the formation of the alliance between Gondor and Rohan.

A Spinoff Set in Arnor Would Tell the Story of the Forgotten Kingdom of the Dunedain

It’s common knowledge among “Lord of the Rings” enthusiasts that they are familiar with Gondor, but those who have merely watched the films know very little about Arnor. Arnor was one of two kingdoms established by the Numenoreans when they arrived on Middle-earth under Elendil. Arnor held a more prominent position among these kingdoms, with Elendil himself as its ruler; Gondor, in contrast, was ruled by his sons Isildur and Anarion. However, due to Elendil’s demise on Mount Doom, Isildur succeeded him as High King of Arnor, while Anarion’s son became the king of Gondor.

Isildur never made it to Arnor because of the Ring, and the history of Arnor would become one of loss over the centuries it existed. Arnor only lasted until the year 861 of the Third Age, battling the forces of the Witch-King and his kingdom of Angmar as well as other enemies. The people of Arnor were the ancestors of Aragorn, so their story is one of the most important in the Legendarium. Arnor’s history would make for a great series, one that tells the story of its people and its wars. Its story is integral to the history of Middle-earth, and fans who have never read the books need to know more about it.

Read More

2024-12-16 02:41