15 Wild West Flicks Featuring Doc Holliday You Didn’t Know Existed!

by

John Henry “Doc” Holliday, born in 1851 and passing away in 1887, was initially a clever dentist who later transformed into a formidable gunslinger and gambler, known for his fiery temperament. His fame came from his exploits in the Wild West and his close bond with the lawman Wyatt Earp. Due to tuberculosis, Holliday found solace in gambling and sometimes practiced dentistry. He earned a reputation as an exceptional card player and a swift gunfighter.

Through his partnership with Earp, Doc Holliday found himself entangled in law enforcement disputes, such as the notorious shootout at the O.K. Corral in Tombstone, Arizona, in 1881. This fateful encounter between Earp, Holliday, and the Clanton-McLaury gang has gone down in history. Doc Holliday passed away in Colorado in 1887 at the age of 36. His captivating life tale has been the focus of numerous books and films, with the 1993 movie, featuring Val Kilmer as Doc Holliday, being one of the most notable. However, Doc’s life served as inspiration for a number of other movies, some even rivaling the legendary Tombstone itself.

.

Despite the Many Deviations from Fact, the Film Is Still an Enjoyable Watch

1943’s “The Outlaw” significantly deviates from historical truth by portraying an unusual love triangle between Doc Holliday (Walter Huston), Billy the Kid, and Rio McDonald, with Pat Garrett somehow thrown into the mix as well. This Howard Hughes/Howard Hawks production largely discards factual accuracy, jumbling timelines and relationships in order to create a romantic Western drama that leans more towards melodrama. However, it’s worth noting that this film earns its place at the bottom of many Western rankings due to its excessive deviations from the truth, even among other films featuring Doc Holliday.

Despite Huston’s impressive acting in Doc Holliday, it’s better known for kick-starting Jane Russell’s career and stirring up controversy with her promotional images than for its accurate portrayal of the legendary dentist. The film’s unusual soundtrack and historical discrepancies make it one of the more peculiar additions to the Doc Holliday movie series. Yet, these quirky decisions retain a charm that keeps it intriguing for fans of Doc Holliday.

This Remake Replaces Doc Boone With Doc Holliday

In 1986, a reimagining of the 1939 film titled “Stagecoach” was released, with Doc Boone being swapped for Doc Holliday in this adaptation. The narrative follows a motley crew embarking on a journey from Tonto, Arizona to Lordsburg. This diverse group includes Dallas, a former prostitute, the heavy-drinking dentist Doc Holliday (portrayed by Willie Nelson), the heavily pregnant Lucy Mallory, and Trevor Peacock, a whiskey salesman. Initially appearing as an ordinary collection of travelers, it gradually becomes apparent that each member harbors a hidden secret they’re trying to leave behind.

As the plane gets airborne, U.S. Cavalry Lieutenant Blanchard alerts that the Apaches, under the command of Geronimo, are launching an attack. This movie is the third retelling of the tale, following in the footsteps of John Ford’s 1939 classic, where John Wayne starred as the main character. However, this film, which includes Kris Kristofferson and Johnny Cash in its cast, doesn’t quite recreate the same enchantment as Ford’s movie. Still, it’s a good watch with an enjoyable twist.

Moreover, Doc Holliday Plays a Relatively Small Role

2012’s film titled “Wyatt Earp’s Revenge” features Val Kilmer reprising his role in the Earp family history, but this time as Wyatt Earp himself, instead of Doc Holliday, the character he famously portrayed in “Tombstone.” The movie presents a unique storytelling approach by having Earp’s memories unfold through a series of flashbacks to a journalist, rather than following a conventional linear narrative. Shawn Roberts takes on the role of the younger Wyatt Earp during these recollections.

Although Doc Holliday doesn’t have a lengthy role in the direct-to-DVD film, his presence is significant. Wilson Bethel delivers an impressive portrayal of Doc Holliday, one that stands out among other scenes. Despite Bethel’s strong acting and Val Kilmer’s notable performance as Wyatt Earp, the limited screen time for Doc Holliday and the movie’s modest budget place it lower in the Earp-Holliday series. Nevertheless, Wyatt Earp’s Revenge remains a decent addition to the collection.

However, Dennis Quaid’s Portrayal of Doc Holliday Is Worth Commending

1994’s film, Wyatt Earp, encountered misfortune with its timing, premiering soon after Tombstone and facing difficulties at the box office despite being a well-crafted movie. The dedication of the cast and crew in creating a quality production was never questioned. Notably, Dennis Quaid’s portrayal of Doc Holliday showcased a strong commitment to historical authenticity – he is said to have lost 42 pounds to convincingly depict Holliday’s frail appearance due to consumption.

In the film, Quaid presents a more restrained, historically accurate depiction of the well-known dentist-gunslinger compared to Val Kilmer’s charismatic role in “Tombstone”. The movie’s extended runtime and deliberate pace provide room for an in-depth examination of the Earp-Holliday friendship. Quaid plays a sickly, tormented Holliday who offers a grittily authentic portrayal of the character. This differs from the more lighthearted representations of Doc Holliday often seen in Westerns.

Doc Holliday Unsurprisingly Makes His Way Into the Action

1937’s “Law for Tombstone” showcases a string of robberies prompting a stagecoach company to seek a protector for their valuables. In this movie, Alamo Bowie, brilliantly played by Buck Jones, takes on the role of the protector. Alongside him, Harvey Clark portrays Doc Holliday. What sets this depiction apart is that it presents Holliday in an unusual situation – one different from the usual gunfights at the O.K. Corral, making it more intriguing.

Additionally, “Law for Tombstone” is equally captivating due to its stunning stunts. The movie showcases remarkable horseback riding and lassoing skills that will leave even veteran Western enthusiasts in awe. While the story primarily revolves around Bowie’s mission to protect the stagecoach line from outlaws, it’s important to note that Doc Holliday, as always, maintains a significant role.

While Doc Holliday Isn’t the Focus, He Still Makes an Impact

First published in 1976, “I Married Wyatt Earp” was initially believed to be an authentic memoir penned by Josephine Earp. However, it was later discovered that the author was actually Glenn Boyer, who had connections with the Earp family. Despite questions about its accuracy, the book was adapted into a movie. In 1983, NBC debuted a television film under the same title, which was based on the questionable memoir.

From my perspective as a fan, this movie is unique because it delves into the love story of Josie Marcus, an opera singer, and Wyatt Earp. Alongside their captivating romance, it brings to life several historical figures like Doc Holliday. This film’s fresh take on historical events sets it apart from other Western movies that focus on Doc Holliday. However, due to his limited screen time, the movie can only be ranked as high as #10, despite its overall quality.

Doc Holliday Helps Take Down a Dangerous Gang

As a movie enthusiast, I’d rephrase that as: “In ‘Tombstone: The Town Too Tough to Die,’ my perspective begins slightly differently from other portrayals. Instead of the usual build-up, it’s Wyatt Earp who witnesses an outlaw unintentionally taking a child’s life. This unfortunate accident doesn’t soften Wyatt’s resolve one bit. Driven by revenge, he decides to become a lawman, targeting not just the killer but his entire gang. His brothers and Doc Holliday stand alongside him in this righteous pursuit.

In the movie “Tombstone, the Town Too Tough to Die“, Kent Taylor brilliantly portrays the role of Doc Holliday. He effortlessly blends into this more light-hearted retelling of the gunfight at the O.K. Corral, infusing a lively spirit. This is further accentuated by the film’s choice to omit Doc Holliday’s illness from the narrative. The movie does take creative liberties with his character, but it offers an entertaining experience if one is open to historical inaccuracies.

The Nuanced Depiction of Doc Holliday Is Arguably the Most Compelling

In the 1954 novel “Masterson of Kansas,” Sheriff Bat Masterson is resolved to expose a band of cattlemen for plotting to falsely accuse Merrick of murder. Their ultimate goal was to seize control of the grasslands for their own livestock grazing. Masterson’s mission is to track down Clay Bennet, a key witness in the trial, to prevent potential conflict with Native American tribes over Merrick’s possible execution.

Masterson seeks the aid of Marshal Wyatt Earp and the notorious Doc Holliday, who has a history of conflict with him. Merrick’s daughter Amy manages to convince Holliday to join the pursuit despite the tension between these lawmen. Although the movie is called Masterson from Kansas, it’s James Griffith’s portrayal of Doc Holliday that steals the show. With a reserved, refined air, Griffith’s character radiates an unsettling allure that outshines Montgomery’s Masterson’s depiction.

However, This Doesn’t Change How Great the Portrayal Is

In the movie “Frontier Marshal,” the character known as Doc Holliday was originally named Doc Halliday to avoid potential legal issues with the Holliday family. Despite this name change, the character remains an iconic representation of Western folklore. In this film, Wyatt Earp and Doc Holliday form a friendship instead of engaging in a confrontation after Earp encounters some outlaws. This friendship is further developed when Doc’s love interest calls him to town, but instead of a standoff, they become allies.

Cesar Romero’s character, Doc Halliday, and Randolph Scott’s character, Wyatt Earp, share a strong dynamic as they team up to apprehend a band of outlaws. The thrilling action scenes perfectly balance with their entertaining banter. Additionally, Doc Halliday has a captivating romantic involvement with Sarah Allen, whom he grapples with feeling worthy enough for her affections. This aspect showcases a more vulnerable side of Doc Holliday that appeals to his fans.

This Offers a Unique Exploration of Violent Heroes

I recall watching the television film titled “Purgatory” or “Purgatory West of the Pecos,” which made its debut on TNT in 1999. In this intriguing story, a band of outlaws stumbles upon an unusually tranquil Western town, filled with individuals who appear to be long-deceased frontier legends such as Doc Holliday, Wild Bill Hickock, and Billy the Kid. Although one of my gang members recognized these figures, these legendary Western heroes were reluctant to validate their true identities.

In the story, Sonny uncovers the town’s hidden truth, triggering a thought-provoking examination of the ethical dimensions of the brutal actions that often characterize classic Western protagonists. As Sonny encounters individuals who are attempting to make amends for their past wrongdoings, Doc Holliday becomes involved in this discussion, offering valuable insights into his complex personality within the narrative of “Purgatory“. This exploration adds depth to the story and provides a unique perspective on the character of Doc Holliday.

Read More

2025-05-27 18:52