39 Years Later, ‘The Dark Knight Returns’ Comic Transforms Batman Forever

Batman is DC Comics’ most celebrated character, and one of the most renowned figures in popular culture overall. Ever since his introduction in 1939, Batman has graced comic books, movie serials, TV shows, films, animated productions, novels, video games, and virtually any other form of media you can imagine. One particularly impactful example of Batman media is the 1966 “Batman” TV series. This series transformed the brooding crime-fighter into a lighter, more kitschy and campy version of himself, a portrayal that stuck in many people’s minds for decades to follow.

In essence, most comic books tended to follow the rhythm set by “Batman ’66”, but 1986 marked a significant shift. After making waves with his exceptional work on “Daredevil”, writer and artist Frank Miller released a game-changing comic – “The Dark Knight Returns“. This four-part series, co-created with Klaus Janson and Lynn Varley, has become one of the most acclaimed comics in history for valid reasons.

The Dark Knight Returns Was a Return To Form for the Caped Crusader

1986 marked a significant milestone for the comics industry. “Watchmen,” penned by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons, left readers spellbound; “Crisis on Infinite Earths,” created by Marv Wolfman and George Perez, would fundamentally alter the DC Universe; “Maus,” by Art Spiegelman, pushed the boundaries of comic storytelling in a manner it had never been done before. Comic books were evolving to a level that was long overdue.

Frank Miller significantly contributed to the comic book renaissance, particularly through his work on the Daredevil series. For years, Daredevil was considered a secondary character, but Miller transformed him into a must-read. He achieved this by incorporating a realistic, noir-inspired style into the storyline, creating an authentic urban setting for the character. This approach proved successful and greatly enhanced Daredevil’s appeal. Miller’s Daredevil is a masterpiece; it harkens back to the pulpy origins of comic books and showcases Miller’s exceptional talent as a creator. Reading this series not only made fans appreciate Daredevil, but also admire Miller and develop a greater love for comics in general.

As a devoted cinema enthusiast, I’ve always been captivated by the Dark Knight, but even in the comic books at DC, Batman was still shrouded in the long shadow cast by the 1966 ‘Batman’ series. Don’t get me wrong; there were the Denny O’Neil/Neal Adams and Steve Englehart/Marshall Rogers runs in the ’70s that added depth to the character, but more often than not, he was portrayed like the old TV show. The spirit of ‘Batman’ ’66 seemed to have a firm grip on Batman, with darker, roots-based stories being the rare exceptions.

However, the mid-80s at DC Comics was a time of change, and Batman was poised to spearhead this transformation.

It was only logical to assign Miller to a Batman comic, given his impressive work at DC with the twelve-issue cyberpunk samurai comic “Ronin.” Although DC let him explore unconventional territory with the character, no one anticipated that he would craft a story set in Batman’s future. In this narrative, a middle-aged Bruce Wayne donned the cape and cowl once more to save Gotham City from its most dire state yet. This innovative concept catapulted “The Dark Knight Returns” into becoming one of the greatest comics ever made.

Instead of merely bringing the character back to his origins, Miller delved deeper and utilized the comic to dissect 1980s pop culture in its entirety. In essence, Miller used The Dark Knight Returns as a platform to express his views on the world of 1986. Certain sections of the series might leave younger readers puzzled, but they contribute to the book’s overall atmosphere. This is a comic with a message, and it becomes even more evident when Ronald Reagan appears, setting Superman and Batman on a collision course. Political commentary has always been a part of comics, but The Dark Knight Returns stands out for its sharpness.

In Frank Miller’s rendition, Batman is portrayed as rough and aggressive, a figure who no longer abides by traditional norms, as demonstrated in “The Dark Knight Returns” #2 during his confrontation with the Mutant gang. Yet, Miller’s Batman refrained from taking lives, adhering to his code even when applying it in a more ruthless manner. In “The Dark Knight Returns” #3, we see Batman pursuing the Joker, ready to end the Clown Prince of Crime, but ultimately choosing to spare him, remaining true to his identity. Despite being the most violent portrayal of the character and raising concerns about fascist leanings in Miller’s interpretation, Batman retained his honor, proving himself as the Caped Crusader. This version of Batman underscores that true heroes maintain their principles even when the world evolves, a message that remains relevant today.

In issue #4 of “The Dark Knight Returns,” what stands out most is its iconic status within the comic book world, and rightfully so. It’s the episode where Batman and Superman engage in their epic confrontation. This comic book is responsible for popularizing the concept of “prep time” – the idea that given enough preparation, Batman could best any adversary.

While it’s often overlooked that Superman was physically weakened prior to this battle, having just survived a nuclear blast and regenerating his strength, the legend itself is what matters. The image of an armored Batman squaring off against Superman, countering every attack thrown at him, showcases the character’s potential in a remarkable way.

Frank Miller captured the essence of Batman like few creators before him, and issue #4 of “The Dark Knight Returns” is a testament to that genius. Before this comic, nobody would have considered Batman capable of defeating Superman in combat; after it, such a scenario can no longer be dismissed.

The Dark Knight Returns Changed the Way People Looked at Batman Forever

1986 saw the perfect timing for “The Dark Knight Returns”; it was the first time comics were being recognized as a legitimate literary medium in popular culture. This comic flew off the shelves; people couldn’t wait to discover what was happening with Batman, who had become the talk of the town. The character evolved from the lighthearted Adam West version into something fresh, drawing heavily on earlier Batman stories. Post-“The Dark Knight Returns,” Miller’s classic influence can be found in almost every subsequent piece of Batman media.

In a sense, “The Dark Knight Returns” didn’t merely alter Batman; it was also a testament to the evolution of comics as a medium. Frank Miller crafted a tale that resonated with mature audiences, portraying Batman without sugarcoating his inherent darkness and violence. Similar to “Watchmen,” it wasn’t the graphic content that made “The Dark Knight Returns” mature; rather, it was the storytelling approach—Miller’s confidence in his readers, choosing not to oversimplify or hand-hold them. Although other works such as “Watchmen” and “Maus” often receive more acclaim and have stood the test of time, some argue that “The Dark Knight Returns,” published in 1986, is actually the most significant among the “Big Three.

For the first time, a major superhero received a mature portrayal through “The Dark Knight Returns.” Although Alan Moore’s “Swamp Thing” and Miller’s own “Daredevil” comics, as well as other works, had started this trend, they didn’t quite match up to Batman. After all, everyone recognized Batman – maturing him was a significant step because it attracted mainstream attention. And it succeeded. “The Dark Knight Returns” demonstrated that with the right creators, any superhero could be raised to a level of prestige. While “Watchmen” and “Maus” are undeniably exceptional works, “The Dark Knight Returns” revolutionized comics forever and earned its place in pop culture. It’s highly likely that we wouldn’t have witnessed the major superhero media of the last four decades without “The Dark Knight Returns,” as both Tim Burton’s “Batman” (1989) and Christopher Nolan’s “The Dark Knight Trilogy” might not have been possible.

You can find the graphic novel, “The Dark Knight Returns by Batman,” over at DC. If you’re interested in an animated version, you can rent it via home video services.

Read More

2025-02-04 01:41