45 Harry Potter Fan Theories That Could Be True

Since the publication of the final book back in 2007 and the release of the concluding film, “The Deathly Hallows: Part 2,” in 2011, fans have come up with numerous theories. Some of these theories are quite imaginative, but a good number of them turn out to be surprisingly plausible. This ongoing debate among fans adds depth and richness to the enchanting universe created by J.K. Rowling.

Interpretations ignite viewers’ creativity and add layers of complexity to cherished tales, as some enthusiasts argue. They believe that every minute detail within Harry Potter, no matter how insignificant, was intentionally placed, suggesting untold backstories and subplots the series doesn’t overtly discuss, yet offering enough clues for readers to infer the missing pieces. Such theories are so convincing that a large number of people believe they are probably accurate.

Fenrir Greyback, Known for His Cruelty, Could Have Turned Draco

In “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” it is suggested that Draco Malfoy might be experiencing a tough period in his life. Some fans even propose an intriguing theory that he could have been bitten by Fenrir Greyback, a Death Eater known to transform others into werewolves. This hypothesis helps explain Draco’s fluctuating moods, his pale complexion, and erratic behavior.

The idea behind this theory stems from Draco’s unwell look during his sixth year at Hogwarts. It’s speculated that Voldemort may have commanded Fenrir to bite Draco as a form of retribution against the Malfoy family. Although this isn’t entirely implausible, it does lean toward the more extraordinary theories. Draco’s ill-looking state is attributed to the stress he was experiencing due to his attempt on Albus Dumbledore’s life.

Felix Felicis Gives Luck to Anyone Who Drinks It and Helped Harry’s Friends Survive in the Battle of the Astronomy Tower

Albus isn’t your typical hero, but he shows his kindness in a unique manner. Aberforth is often unassuming as he takes care of others without them realizing it. For instance, he keeps an eye on Harry from behind a two-way mirror and sends Dobby to save him. He also demonstrates deep concern for the boy by encouraging him to flee the country and avoid certain death at the hands of Lord Voldemort.

Given Aberforth’s history with illicit substances in his pub, it’s plausible that he slipped Felix Felicis into the drinks he served the Golden Trio when they visited the Hog’s Head Inn. Since Aberforth acknowledges his patrons often trade such items, it wouldn’t be unusual for him to possess some of this potion. Given their impending battle, he may have intentionally given them Felix Felicis to increase their chances of success. This theory aligns with certain occurrences at Hogwarts, like Harry discovering Rowena’s Diadem, Ron and Hermione uncovering the Chamber of Secrets, and the Golden Trio consistently avoiding spells targeted at them. Furthermore, this potion could have contributed to Harry surviving the Second Killing Curse.

But Who Would Want a Phone When They Have Magic?

At Hogwarts, where there are many wizards, conventional devices that rely on electricity often don’t function properly because magic can manipulate electricity. An exception to this rule is Colin Creevey’s camera, which operates at Hogwarts, suggesting it may run on a different kind of energy. Similarly, the Weasleys’ Ford Anglia car, though not functioning optimally in the Forbidden Forest, still requires electricity to operate.

In the magical world of Hogwarts, while many suppose that technology functions, wizards are unaware of how to manipulate it. Since they lack understanding of Muggle technology, it’s likely they wouldn’t even know how to turn on a electronic device. Although it’s possible that magical devices behave unpredictably within the Wizarding World, like the Ford Anglia spontaneously acting once it arrives at Hogwarts, it appears to have no connection with electricity.

Mary Poppins Is the Main Character of P. L. Travers’ Books & the Iconic Musical Adaptation of the Same Name

It’s intriguing to compare the Wizarding World to other fictional stories, and it’s no surprise that some fans have suggested Mary Poppins might have been a Hogwarts student. After all, J.K. Rowling often incorporates historical or culturally popular figures into her Harry Potter books, such as Nicolas Flamel and Merlin, so it’s plausible that Mary Poppins could be part of the magical world too, given her magical nature and quirky personality reminiscent of characters from Harry Potter.

Mary Poppins hails from Britain, a land where one might speculate she could have learned magic at Hogwarts. Her ability to teleport resembles the well-known technique of apparating. Moreover, she seems to be versed in various supernatural occurrences, and it appears that several members of her family share this magical talent.

Salazar Slytherin Bred a Basilisk at Hogwarts To Kill All Muggle-Borns

One of the oldest known practitioners of dark magic, Herpo the Foul, hails from Ancient Greece. As per J.K. Rowling and the “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them” films, he is recognized for crafting the Basilisk and Horcruxes. Moreover, he was widely known for his proficiency in Parseltongue.

It’s quite plausible that the person we know as Herpo could be one and the same as the founder of Slytherin house, considering his mastery over immortality. He might have disguised himself under a new identity millennia later. Another intriguing possibility is that Slytherin himself could be alive today, hiding beneath a different name and appearance, given the mystery surrounding the whereabouts of wizards after they leave Hogwarts. It’s an interesting thought that Salazar Slytherin might have intended to fulfill the role of the Chosen One who would reopen the Chamber of Secrets in future centuries.

The Basilisk Paralyzed Many Students While Controlled by Ginny

It is well-known that Ginny Weasley was the one who unlocked the Chamber of Secrets under the manipulative instruction of Tom Riddle. Riddle points out that through his diary, he gained access to Ginny’s heart, making it simpler for him to exert control over her. This essentially meant that Tom had intimate knowledge of Ginny and exploited this information to further his own ends.

In this scenario, some fans speculate that Ginny, who had feelings for Harry, may have influenced the choices leading to the paralysis of certain individuals. Among those paralyzed were Colin, Mrs. Norris, and Justin Finch-Fletchley – all of whom had impacted Harry during that school year. It’s plausible that Ginny sought revenge on people who negatively affected Harry, her crush.

Nearly Headless Nick, a ghost, was likely used by Ginny as an alternative to killing someone, since he couldn’t die again. Lastly, Tom Riddle purposely targeted Hermione to provoke Harry, and unfortunate Penelope happened to be with Hermione when the incident occurred.

Ron Used the Deluminator To Reunite with Harry and Hermione in Deathly Hallows

Fans have been pondering over what magical incantation Dumbledore used on the Deluminator, so that Ron could return to his friends if he ever got lost. In the Wizarding World, some individuals possess the power to render a specific word forbidden, enabling them to find out where someone who says that word is located. For instance, in Deathly Hallows, Voldemort employed such a word to track his adversaries.

It’s been suggested that Dumbledore placed a spell in the Deluminator linked to Ron’s name, allowing him to be summoned when Harry and Hermione discussed him. This hypothesis could account for why the Deluminator brought Ron along with his companions soon after they mentioned him. Given Dumbledore’s exceptional magical abilities, this scenario seems plausible and offers a straightforward means of reuniting Ron with his friends.

Snape’s Aesthetic Gives Vampire Vibes

Throughout the stories, Severus Snape appears to have a distinctly gothic or vampiric aesthetic. He’s known for his ghostly pale complexion, black eyes and hair, and a demeanor that’s often somber and grave. His wardrobe typically consists of dark-hued clothing, and he has a tendency to move with a flamboyant, theatrical flair when wearing his long, flowing robes. Some enthusiastic readers have speculated that these characteristics might hint at Snape being a real vampire or perhaps even a half-vampire, a theory that adds an intriguing twist to his enigmatic character.

In the world of Harry Potter, it is established that vampires are present and often discussed. A prime example is when Remus Lupin teaches a class about vampires following Snape’s lesson on werewolves, which might have been seen as a form of retaliation. Although this could be accurate, it doesn’t significantly alter Remus Lupin’s narrative within the Harry Potter series.

Lily Evans’s Genes Could Be Passed On

Given that Aunt Lily Evans was a witch, it is theoretically possible that Dudley’s offspring might possess magical abilities. Such a scenario would indeed be quite extraordinary, as it could foster better relationships between Muggles and the magical community, and expand Harry’s family circle.

In an interview, Rowling discussed this topic and expressed her belief that Vernon’s genes likely wouldn’t manifest any magic, which seems rather unlikely. Yet, if the Evans family genes carry magical abilities, even with Vernon’s narrow-minded perspective, it’s possible Dudley could have children with magical traits. Given Dudley’s growing empathy towards Harry at the end, it’s pleasant to imagine him as a compassionate father to his potential wizard offspring.

Maybe Every Founder Had a Pet at Hogwarts

Much like how Salazar Slytherin housed the colossal basilisk within Hogwarts’ hallowed halls, there’s a widespread belief that other founders might have had their unique companions as well. A popular theory revolves around Fawkes, the phoenix, being initially owned by Godric Gryffindor. Given its immortality and unwavering loyalty to the Gryffindor house, demonstrated through its battles alongside Dumbledore and Harry, it’s plausible that this could be true. Phoenixes are quite rare even in the magical realm, making it likely only a powerful wizard like Godric Gryffindor would have earned their trust. To top it off, its color scheme aligns perfectly with the house colors.

It’s unclear what type of pet Rowena Ravenclaw might have had, but some speculate that a Giant Squid could have been Helga Hufflepuff’s pet instead. This remarkable creature dwells in the lake at Hogwarts and is recognized for its friendly demeanor and playful nature. It even rescued Dennis Creevey when he fell into the lake during his first year journey to the castle. The Weasley twins, Fred and George, also enjoyed interacting with it, amusing themselves by tickling its tentacles. Given its gentle disposition, it’s plausible that such a creature could have been cared for by one of the kindest Hogwarts founders.

2025-04-30 03:10