5 Reasons Alien³ Works

As a long-time fan of the Ridley Scott’s Alien franchise, I must say that while each film has its own unique charm and terrifying moments, “Alien³” holds a special place in my heart. Growing up watching these films, the third installment stood out for me as it offered a more somber, introspective tone that resonated with my teenage self – a time when life was filled with uncertainty and fear of the unknown.

Despite now being widely recognized as one of the top directors in the industry today, David Fincher’s success wasn’t necessarily guaranteed given his difficult experience while directing Alien³. It’s amazing he didn’t come to expect all filmmaking to be such a challenging process, leading to subpar results. Without a doubt, Alien³ is clearly a product that suffered from compromise in its production.

It’s particularly notable when considering it in contrast to the two films that came before, each of which emerged from the unique perspectives and creative visions of two distinct directors. Originally, Vincent Ward was intended to direct the third film, but during pre-production, David Fincher took over, only for his vision to be modified by the studio as well. Despite all the turmoil behind the scenes, there are many aspects to admire in Alien³, especially given that there have been other controversial entries in the franchise (Prometheus, Alien: Covenant, Alien: Resurrection, the AVP movies), a pair of poorly received ones, and a critically acclaimed crowd-pleaser (Alien: Romulus) that have made it possible to evaluate it beyond simply comparing it to the two masterpieces that came before.

It’s Tonally Different the Same Way Aliens Was Tonally Different From Alien

One significant mistake “Alien³” could have made, but thankfully didn’t, was attempting to duplicate either the success of “Alien” or “Aliens” by simply repeating their storylines. While it shares some resemblance with Ridley Scott’s original film in terms of its space-bound haunted house feel and the singular presence of a xenomorph, it is essentially the polar opposite of James Cameron’s sequel. This contrast allows “Alien³” to effectively serve as a conclusion for the trilogy.

Instead of considering the Alien Quadrilogy as four distinct films, it would be more accurate to view it as a trilogy, with Alien: Resurrection being a less compelling and overly polished sequel to Aliens. The character portrayed by Sigourney Weaver in Alien: Resurrection is quite different from the Ellen Ripley audiences had grown fond of, lacking the warmth, compassion, and sacrificing spirit that defined the original character. This new version of Ripley fails to capture the essence of the beloved character we knew.

An Organic Way to Send Ellen Ripley Out

Significant conditions needed to be fulfilled for Sigourney Weaver to accept the role in “Alien³”. She had a strong affinity for the Ripley character, but was displeased with Fox’s editing of crucial scenes involving Ripley’s daughter in “Aliens”. Two key requirements were that the film should minimize gun usage and that her personally crafted character should meet an on-screen death by the movie’s conclusion.

Both circumstances were fulfilled, albeit in reverse order, which is unfortunate, especially with Resurrection since its sacrifice scene ranks high among studio film sacrifices. In line with her character, she plunged backward towards self-immolation instead of prolonging her life at the cost of Weyland-Yutani gaining control over a live xeno.

The Presence of Charles Dance

Leaving out the two AVP movies, the Xenomorph saga has consistently boasted exceptional acting ensembles. The third film was no exception, featuring stellar performances from Sigourney Weaver, who delivered a nuanced and realistic portrayal in her central role. This was complemented by a talented group of actors including Charles S. Dutton (known for Rudy), Brian Glover (An American Werewolf in London), Pete Postlethwaite (The Town), and Holt McCallany (Mindhunter). Together, these actors form an impressive lineup of Xenomorph adversaries, although not all make a lasting impact. Still, their performances help keep the film from becoming just another sci-fi slasher.

As a film enthusiast, it’s the actor portraying a character who exits the storyline prematurely that leaves the most lasting impact – take Charles Dance, formerly a prison inmate turned resident doctor as Jonathan Clemens. In every scene he graces, Dance raises the stakes, keeping viewers guessing about his character’s enigmatic past. His portrayal of empathy towards Ripley is so convincing that it feels real and heartfelt.

It Features Some of the Most Iconic Shots of the Xenomorph

After viewers have encountered a few xenomorphs in Ridley Scott’s “Aliens,” the initial fear factor has decreased due to their frequent appearances. The original film kept its terrifying adversary largely hidden, shrouded in darkness for most of its duration. However, in the sequel, they are more exposed and often destroyed. “Alien³” strikes a balance between these two approaches.

Although the computer-generated images (CGI) showing the xeno moving across ceilings have become noticeably dated, the scenes where practical effects were used to depict the creature are among its most compelling moments on screen. One such moment is when it emerges from a ventilation shaft, startling Murphy, who is later torn apart by spinning fan blades. Another memorable instance is the xeno looking up before being trapped in liquid metal. However, the scene that is arguably most iconic for the film and possibly the entire franchise is the close-up encounter between the xeno and Ripley immediately after it kills Dance’s character, Clemens.

The Score

In a different tone: The first two movies’ soundtracks reflect their individual film styles, with the first being more subdued and the second being grand. However, it’s the third movie, Alien³, that boasts the peak of the franchise’s musical scores. Although Elliot Goldenthal may not be as well-known as Jerry Goldsmith (Alien) or James Horner (Aliens), his work on Alien³ is exceptional. This was only his fifth film composition, following Cocaine Cowboys in 1979, Blank Generation in 1980, Pet Sematary in 1989, and the underappreciated Drugstore Cowboy.

The scene should focus on a long view of an inmate sprinting over Fiorina 161 (the planetoid where the prison resides), immediately following his discovery of Ripley’s downed spaceship. The music swells dramatically, capturing both the anticipation of imminent action and a hint of warning.

Alien: Romulus is now streaming on Hulu

Read More

2024-11-30 03:10