5 Star Wars Heroes Who Went From Great to Disappointing

by

In a galaxy at a great distance lies the home of some of the most memorable heroes ever created, including Luke Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi. These Star Wars champions strive to shield the vulnerable and safeguard those they hold dear. However, there are certain do-gooders within this vast franchise who fail to shine, often missing chances to make a lasting impact. Worse still is when characters initially show promise but then slip back and find themselves in unfortunate circumstances. Star Wars features numerous characters fitting this description, some of whom have become quite renowned.

A simpler approach to express this could be: Star Wars tends to harm its heroes’ prestige by overdoing it. Initially, these characters are impressive and offer much value, but once burdened with excessive responsibilities, they lose their footing and fail to regain their former strength.

1) Yoda

In the original trilogy, it’s Yoda who carries an impressive reputation. Obi-Wan shares stories about this enigmatic Jedi master capable of guiding me on the path of the Force. When I finally meet him, he appears eccentric, to say the least. However, as it turns out, his peculiar demeanor is merely a test. After some back-and-forth exchanges, Yoda emerges as the wise mentor that I desperately needed in my journey.

As I reappeared on the silver screen during the prequel era, I couldn’t help but feel like the same wise Jedi Master from the ’80s had returned. Yet, as Emperor Palpatine began weaving his intricate web of deceit, it dawned upon me that the Grand Master of the Jedi Order was not nearly as cunning as he seemed. In the prequels, I often found myself boasting grandiose words, yet my actions fell short, ultimately leading to the downfall of the noble Jedi and my own exile.

2) Mace Windu

Initially, Mace Windu, another Jedi from the Star Wars prequel era, gets off to an uneasy start in Star Wars: The Phantom Menace. However, subsequent films like Star Wars: Attack of the Clones and Star Wars: The Clone Wars significantly improve his reputation by depicting his abilities beyond the Jedi Council. These portrayals make it evident why Windu is respected enough to have Yoda’s attention, despite occasional stubbornness.

In “Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith,” Mace Windu’s valiant efforts are undone, reducing him to simply being a part of Palpatine’s plan. Despite having the Sith Lord cornered, his handling of Anakin Skywalker comes back to bite him when the young Jedi makes the fateful decision to join the Dark Side. Regrettably, if Windu doesn’t reappear in future Star Wars stories, his role ends up being a significant letdown.

3) Han Solo

Han Solo boasts one of the most memorable debuts across all Star Wars episodes, casually seated at the cantina on Tatooine when Luke Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi arrive in search of transportation. Their brief exchange paves the way for an engaging narrative that eventually transforms Han from a rogue smuggler into a key figure in the Rebellion, contributing significantly to the destruction of both Death Stars.

By the time Han reappears in “Star Wars: The Force Awakens”, he has resorted to his old habit of avoiding conflicts. Despite the significance of the struggle against the First Order, and the fact that his family is involved, he appears unwilling to engage, perhaps exacerbated by the loss of his son to the Dark Side.

4) Rey Skywalker

In the new Star Wars trilogy, Rey adapts swiftly to her leading role. Caught up in a struggle between the First Order and the Resistance, she demonstrates remarkable determination, going so far as to engage Kylo Ren in a lightsaber battle, despite lacking prior training. By the climax of Star Wars: The Last Jedi, Rey appears fully prepared to emerge as a hero of the caliber of Luke and Anakin.

Unfortunately, “Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker” can’t resist altering Rey’s background. When it is revealed that she belongs to Palpatine’s lineage, her character is weakened as she struggles with her real ancestry. This twist in the plot creates an awkward fit for the conclusion of her storyline in the sequels, and while adopting the “Skywalker” name is logical in some aspects, it seems more like a last-minute choice than a well-thought-out decision.

5) Sabine Wren

In the animated series, Star Wars Rebels, Sabine Wren becomes a valuable member of the Ghost’s crew and remains loyal from then on. She is a resolute Mandalorian, demonstrating teamwork and cooperation that sets her apart from others in her group. Her contributions to the Rebellion are crucial in their battle against the Empire. Yet, Star Wars often adds complexity, as Sabine undergoes changes when reappearing in Star Wars: Ahsoka.

In Ahsoka’s standalone series, we delve into her battles against the Imperial remnants, including Grand Admiral Thrawn. Following her last appearance, she’s been keeping herself occupied, mentoring Sabine in Force techniques. However, Sabine turns out to be a less-than-ideal student, and by the time they reconnect, Ahsoka appears significantly less mature than her Rebels days, even though she’s had experience fighting in the Galactic Civil War. Despite this, she still manages to perceive the broader perspective.

Read More

2025-05-26 22:12