9 Actors Who Could Perfectly Revive Brooklyn Nine-Nine

by

Through its eight-season span, Brooklyn Nine-Nine demonstrated unquestionably that police comedies can be both cleverly written and emotionally resonant, while still maintaining an absurd sense of humor. Ranging from awkward social situations to intricate heists, the 99th Precinct has tackled it all. With its witty dialogue and exceptional cast, each scene was imbued with a unique blend of complexity, richness, chaos, and brilliance, resonating deeply with viewers, leaving them eager for more.

Brooklyn Nine-Nine wasn’t solely about crime-solving; it was a series that delved into friendships, recurring humorous elements, and profound life insights disguised within superior comedy. The audience became enamored with the growth of the makeshift family at the precinct, Rosa Diaz’s no-nonsense demeanor, Terry Jeffords’ endearing yet somewhat dimwitted nature, and the endearing immaturity of Jake Peralta.

To this day, even following the end of its run, B99 is still frequently revisited, quoted, and cherished. A significant factor in its appeal was the exceptional talent of its cast. It’s hard to envision anyone else taking their places, but the original actors have since moved forward to other ventures.

Although no definite plans for a reboot have been announced yet, here’s our list of 10 actors who could undoubtedly shine in a potential revival of the popular series “Brooklyn Nine-Nine”.

9
Rosa Diaz – Jenna Ortega

In an effortlessly cool portrayal by Stephanie Beatriz, the character of Rosa Diaz resides at the 99th precinct as an enigma. Always dressed in leather and armed with a knife, she is impossible to decipher, earning both respect and fear from criminals. She embodies the saying “don’t judge a book by its cover.” Whether it’s intimidating rookie officers or revealing rare glimpses of her vulnerabilities, Rosa flourishes in chaos, keeping secrets, and delivering chilling one-liners with uncanny accuracy. Her friendship with Boyle is strangely loyal and seems almost historic.

The skills of Jenna Ortega perfectly suit this challenging yet endearing role. Known for her tough performances in films like “X” and “Scream,” she has proven herself capable of playing characters that thrive in perilous, high-pressure situations. Ortega’s comedic timing in Netflix’s “Wednesday” showcases her ability to deliver witty deadpan humor with an edge. However, the character of Rosa will have a more contemporary feel. She’ll still ride a bike, but she’ll amplify her mysterious side, make her sarcasm sharper, and her unpredictability even more intriguing and captivating.

8
Gina Linetti – Awkwafina

As a dedicated film enthusiast, I can’t help but admire the brilliant Gina Linetti from the Nine-Nine squad. Much like the lively 100 emoji embodied in human form, Gina is one of the series’ geniuses, portrayed by the iconic Chelsea Peretti. She’s renowned for her sharp wit, self-assured demeanor, snappy comebacks, and an unyielding sense of self-worth that leaves a lasting impression. Though she holds the title of civilian administrator at the precinct, Gina consistently pushes past the limitations of her job description to chase her dreams. From one moment teasing Jake to the next launching a social media dynasty, Gina’s spirit is nothing short of captivating.

It’s no laughing matter to be the smartest person in any room, but if we were to cast someone as Gina who could balance comedy and depth, it would be none other than Awkwafina. She possesses the wit to match Peretti’s quick-witted delivery, but she’d also elevate Gina to new heights of hilarity and intelligence. Her performances in movies like Crazy Rich Asians, The Farewell, and her voice roles demonstrate her ability to handle a larger-than-life persona while still showing emotion. In essence, Awkwafina would make Gina even more eccentric yet more complex at the same time.

7
Terry Jeffords – Winston Duke

Characterized by actor Terry Crews, the tough-yet-affectionate character known as Terry Jeffords from the Nine-Nine series embodies a family man with a heart as expansive as his muscles and an unbridled love for yogurt. He skillfully blends raw strength with a near-innocent excitement towards his team, while his gruff exterior conceals a compassionate spirit deeply committed to safeguarding the people of Brooklyn. His strong bond with his squad, combined with his apprehension of paperwork and affection for his favorite treats, make him endearing. Notably, he’s known for his over-the-top reactions to his daughters’ school projects and fierce defense of his preferred snack.

Terry effortlessly smashes doors apart, but what truly endears him is his genuine emotional depth. This is why Winston Duke, with his impressive performances in films like Black Panther and Us, seems ideal for portraying the character in a remake. The actor, known for showcasing his acting prowess, would slide into Terry’s worn-out boots as if it were second nature. He’d undoubtedly infuse Terry with a unique twist – less boisterous energy, but still retaining a charming demeanor and a deep emotional heart.

6
Charles Boyle – Lewis Pullman

As a die-hard fan of Brooklyn Nine-Nine, I’ve always found myself drawn to the character, Charles Boyle, who was once brilliantly portrayed by Joe Lo Truglio. This guy is like a human golden retriever, a perfect blend of adorable and overly excited. His devotion towards Jake is nothing short of heroic, while his enthusiasm for offbeat culinary adventures is second to none. Even in the most absurd situations, Boyle manages to infuse an optimism that makes everything seem charming.

You see, Boyle has a knack for getting himself into messes, but he’s also got the smarts to find his way out of them. His zest for life and unyielding positivity is truly inspiring. I can’t wait to see what new adventures await Charles Boyle in the next season!

Considering Lewis Pullman’s versatile acting skills demonstrated in movies like “Bad Times at the El Royale” and “Top Gun: Maverick,” he could convincingly portray a character who consistently supports the Nine-Nine. His performance as Charles Boyle would be a blend of humor and heartfelt sincerity. The warmth of his screen presence, coupled with his knack for physical comedy, would undeniably give Boyle a fresh, more grounded feel.

5
Captain Holt – Colman Domingo

Captain Raymond Holt, previously portrayed by the late Andre Braugher, stands as a central figure in the Brooklyn Nine-Nine cast. This stern, no-nonsense, and brilliant officer with an unexpectedly humorous flair for delivery, Holt reveals a surprising amount of depth and warmth. His ability to deliver cutting remarks while maintaining a stoic expression is what makes him one of television’s most distinctive and amusing characters. From his reluctant appreciation of Jake to his unwavering loyalty towards the squad, Holt has shown that he was never merely the stern boss, but someone who, in an unusual manner, demonstrated care and concern for those around him.

In reflection of Holt’s legendary rivalry with Wuntch, the actor who springs to mind as an excellent fit to breathe new life into the role is Colman Domingo. Known for his strong presence and leadership in series like Fear the Walking Dead and Euphoria, it’s his recent portrayal in the Tina Fey-co-created The Four Seasons that demonstrates his versatility, capable of subtle humor as well. As Holt, Domingo would maintain an aura of polished authority while infusing a touch of dramatic flair to enrich the character.

4
Kevin Cozner – Dan Levy

In a delightfully charming performance by Marc Evan Jackson, the character Kevin Cozner, who is not just Captain Holt’s spouse but also the show’s administrative backbone in an unexpectedly fulfilling and delicate manner, is portrayed. A distinguished professor of classics, he exhibits sharp wit and an uncanny calmness, creating a perfect balance with Captain Holt’s character. His reserved behavior stands in stark contrast to the turmoil of the 99th precinct, making each scene he appears in a memorable gem.

It appears that selecting Dan Levy for the reboot is an insightful decision. His performances in Schitt’s Creek demonstrate his skill at blending intelligent wit with endearing awkward moments. Additionally, Levy excels at delivering sharp comments while maintaining a composed and articulate demeanor, making him seem perfectly suited for the role of Kevin. However, envision Levy infusing some extra quirky vitality into the character, transforming Kevin into a more unpredictable figure.

3
Scully & Hitchcock – Paul Walter Hauser & Danny McBride

These endearing, albeit somewhat inept, pairing of Scully and Hitchcock has captured the hearts of many viewers due to their slovenly ways and deeply enigmatic bond. They are undoubtedly the most tenacious figures within the precinct, often delivering unexpected glimpses of wisdom. Portrayed by Joel McKinnon Miller and Dirk Blocker, these two characters exhibit a unique blend of incompetence and genius, though they only demonstrate this prowess when motivated. Their shared passion for food is legendary, and let us not forget that their presence on the show transcends mere comic relief.

In a hypothetical reboot, Paul Walter Hauser and Danny McBride could be our top picks for playing Scully and Hitchcock respectively. Hauser, famous for shows like “Cobra Kai” and “Black Bird,” has a unique knack for breathing equal measures of cluelessness and warmth into his characters. His understated humor would add the right amount of wisdom to the role. On the other hand, McBride, known for series such as “Eastbound & Down” and “The Righteous Gemstones,” has excelled in portraying complex characters. His interpretation of Hitchcock could take the character to new levels of depth and humor.

2
Amy Santiago – Rachel Zegler

In the bustling environment of the Nine-Nine police precinct, it’s Amy Santiago, more than any other officer, who consistently manages to stay one step ahead. The character portrayed by Melissa Fumero is a diligent, rule-abiding detective with an endearing love for orderliness, organization, and academic challenges that quickly endeared her to viewers. Amy’s unyielding determination to prove herself, particularly towards Captain Holt, often results in comedic situations. Yet, amidst her persistent attempts to outdo Jake or perfect a filing system, Amy also conceals a spirit of adventure.

In this role, Rachel Zegler is an outstanding fit. Her standout debut in West Side Story may not be typical for the genre, but she possesses a strong passion, unwavering determination, and undeniable beauty – traits that mirror Amy’s character. Moreover, Zegler has shown her versatility by portraying complex, emotionally layered characters. Additionally, her recent appearances in action-packed films such as Shazam! Fury of the Gods and The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes suggest that she would bring a desirable physical presence to Amy.

1
Jake Peralta – Logan Lerman

The main character on Nine-Nine, played by Andy Samberg as Kale Peralta, is both the unconventional glue holding together this quirky police squad and the most reckless and juvenile among them. This impulsive detective, with his penchant for crime-solving and love for pop culture tidbits (like Die Hard, Taylor Swift), as well as immature behavior, often avoids responsibilities but manages to deliver results. Jake’s relationship with Captain Holt and his ongoing, complex, and seemingly endless attempts to gain his approval are a significant source of humor in the series, highlighting his status as one of Brooklyn’s top detectives.

Logan Lerman could offer a unique take on the character Jake, presenting a more serious yet endearing portrayal without losing his charm or commitment. His good looks would undeniably make audiences want to support him. Lerman has previously embodied complex heroes in films like Percy Jackson and Hunters, demonstrating versatility across various genres. In The Perks of Being a Wallflower, he skillfully added a touch of humor and relatability to Charlie, suggesting that he could effortlessly capture Jake’s intelligent yet mischievous character.

Read More

2025-06-01 00:03