2 Years Later, Star Trek Is Still Ignoring the Most Obvious Choice for Its Next TV Show

by

Though it had a difficult beginning, with some viewers criticizing its complicated plots and writing, Picard ultimately gave the Next Generation crew the satisfying conclusion they deserved. However, the finale felt less like an ending and more like a fresh start. The last episode of Picard Season 3 didn’t just tie up the Next Generation story nicely; it also set the stage for a completely new adventure. We were introduced to a brand-new Enterprise – the Enterprise-G – with Seven of Nine as the captain and Raffi as first officer, along with a promising new crew, all ready for stories that could appeal to a new generation of fans.

As a huge Star Trek fan, I wasn’t at all surprised when people started buzzing about a continuation of Picard. Terry Matalas, the showrunner, began hinting at Legacy – a series that would focus on a new generation of Starfleet officers, like Jack Crusher and the LaForge daughters, in the aftermath of the Dominion War and the Borg threat. The idea really resonated with fans, and we immediately started campaigning to make it happen. An online petition quickly gained over 65,000 signatures, and then the amazing “Letters 4 Legacy” campaign took off. We all wanted to show Paramount just how much we wanted this series, so we flooded them with physical letters – a good old-fashioned fan push to get their attention!

We’ve seen similar fan campaigns successfully save shows before, so it’s a strategy that deserves attention. Despite enthusiasm from fans and the cast, and the continued growth of Star Trek with shows like Strange New Worlds and upcoming projects like Starfleet Academy, we’re still no closer to seeing this happen after more than two years.

Why Star Trek Needs Legacy

Given the current success of the Star Trek franchise, the lack of a Legacy series is becoming more noticeable. Fans are clearly eager for it, and the concept feels stronger than other potential new shows like Star Trek: United or Star Trek: Year One. The idea for Legacy seems well-defined – even though it hasn’t been officially approved, writer Nichelle Matalas apparently wrote a partial pilot script of around 30 pages on her own, hoping to get the chance to pitch it.

The show would center around the new crew of the USS Enterprise-G, previously known as the USS Titan, as they take on exciting new adventures under the leadership of Captain Seven of Nine and First Officer Raffi. It would also allow for the return of beloved characters from Deep Space Nine and Voyager. This mix of fresh faces and established favorites, acting as mentors, would explore the wider impact of past events on the Star Trek universe, creating a potentially compelling story.

As a long-time Trek fan, I’m really excited about the potential of Legacy. While I enjoy seeing the backstory with Strange New Worlds and think a show focused on Starfleet Academy could be great, Legacy feels like something truly special. It’s a chance to bridge the different eras of Star Trek, letting us continue following characters we already love – imagine finally seeing Seven of Nine as a captain! – while also introducing new faces for a new generation. Star Trek always shines when it moves forward, and Legacy could be the next The Next Generation, respecting what came before while boldly taking the universe in a new direction. It’s exactly what the franchise needs right now.

The planned series, Legacy, aimed for a storytelling style that blended ongoing, multi-episode stories with self-contained weekly adventures. It would have felt more similar in tone to Deep Space Nine and later seasons of The Next Generation than the lighter, more upbeat Strange New Worlds, potentially appealing to dedicated Star Trek fans. Instead of revisiting the past like SNW, Legacy would have built upon the existing Star Trek universe, resolving unanswered questions. The galaxy is still recovering from significant events, and the revelations about Changelings and Borg infiltration in Picard have fundamentally altered the Federation, the Klingon Empire, and the Romulans. The show would have explored these dramatic, unresolved storylines – something no other current Trek series is better suited to do. Ultimately, Legacy was intended to be the logical continuation of the Star Trek saga.

Interest Is High In Legacy, But Motion Is Limited

Despite not yet receiving official confirmation, the potential series Legacy continues to generate excitement thanks to passionate fans! Actors like Todd Stashwick (who played Captain Liam Shaw in season 3 of Picard) and Jeri Ryan (Seven of Nine) have voiced their interest in returning, and online discussions have kept hopes for the show alive.

Terry Matalas has repeatedly expressed his strong interest in continuing with the show and his love for Star Trek, even urging fans to keep asking Paramount to bring it back. However, he’s currently busy leading the new Marvel series Vision Quest, so another Trek project is likely some time off. While he isn’t contractually obligated to stay away from Star Trek and Vision Quest is in post-production, Disney and Marvel are unlikely to let someone with his skills move on quickly.

Even people at Paramount have said they know fans want to see Legacy, but they’ve also indicated it’s not a priority right now, often responding with something like, “We’ve heard the feedback—but the timing isn’t right.”

The recent merger between Skydance and Paramount has created some uncertainty about upcoming Star Trek series. While the new company insists Star Trek remains important, they’re likely reassessing the plans for Trek shows, considering both costs and how to attract new viewers. This is a sensible move given the evolving world of streaming television.

Thankfully, a new Legacy series isn’t urgently needed, and many fans are hoping it’s just on hold for now. Even two years later, Star Trek fans are still excited about Legacy, not because they’re stuck in the past, but because they want to see the story continue. With the current Star Trek shows doing well, Legacy feels like a natural and smart next step for the franchise, both creatively and for its future.

Given that Star Trek is about discovering new worlds and civilizations, a show called Legacy would be a great way to continue that tradition. Do you want to see Star Trek: Legacy happen? Share your thoughts in the comments and join the discussion on the ComicBook Forum!

Star Trek: Picard and Star Trek: Strange New Worlds are streaming now on Paramount+.

https://comicbook.com/movies/list/recasting-star-treks-original-enterprise-crew-for-a-new-movie-reboot-7-actors-whod-be-perfect/embed/#

Read More

2025-11-17 00:41