Paranoid Gardens #1 Review: The Broken, the Beaten, and the Bizarre

Paranoid Gardens #1 Review: The Broken, the Beaten, and the Bizarre

As a long-time comic book reader and collector, I have seen my fair share of unique and captivating stories that have left indelible marks on my life. Gerard Way’s latest offering, “Paranoid Gardens,” is no exception. This Dark Horse Comics series arrived at a pivotal moment in my life, much like Way’s previous works, such as “The Umbrella Academy” and “Doom Patrol,” did years ago.


As a huge fan of Gerard Way’s music with My Chemical Romance and his comic books, I can’t help but feel like they enter my life at the most serendipitous moments. The first volume of “The Umbrella Academy,” co-created by Way and Gabriel B., became a sacred text among my adolescent friends and me. We passed around a tattered copy and were captivated by the bizarre family drama unfolding within its pages. Then, just before a pivotal time of change in my life, came the revival of “Doom Patrol,” co-written by Way and Nick Derington. This comic sparked an explosion of creativity and personal agency that still resonates with me today. I can only imagine how “Paranoid Gardens,” Dark Horse Comics’ newest project from Gerard Way and collaborators, will reflect the current chapter of my life. The potential is palpable, and I’m eagerly anticipating the journey.

At Paradise Gardens, a seemingly ordinary care center in #1 of “Paranoid Gardens,” reside a colorful cast of characters, including superheroes, extraterrestrials, and other peculiar beings. Loo, a doubtful orderly among them, starts questioning her place within this intriguing hierarchy and even her own recollections.

Paranoid Gardens defies simple categorization with its unique blend of elements in the first issue. Memory lapses, an unreliable superhero, humanoid monsters that are both grotesque and endearing, and a massive multimedia conspiracy come together in a way that initially seems disjointed and chaotic. However, Way and Shaun Simon’s script skillfully weaves these elements into a compelling narrative that leaves the reader curious rather than confused. The only potential weakness lies in Loo’s memory gaps, which are intriguingly presented but leave the reader feeling unsatisfied compared to other thought-provoking storylines.

The future will tell if “Paranoid Gardens” will gain the same level of acclaim as Way’s work on “The Umbrella Academy” and “The True Lives of the Fabulous Killjoys.” This intriguing comic series has ample room to grow and explore themes of aging, autonomy, and unease. Like many mainstream comics, it draws inspiration from various art forms and cultural references. Although the issue is limited in space, the creative team skillfully imbues each panel and odd scene with significant storytelling impact.

In simpler terms, the unique style of “Paranoid Gardens” is richly complex and full of surprises, often contradicting our perception of reality. The artwork by Chris Weston perfectly captures this intricacy, providing clarity to the human figures and maintaining a consistent sense of environment. This balance between realism and fantasy maximizes the impact of the bizarre elements in the comic. Dave Stewart’s vibrant colors encompass an extensive range of shades, with ordinary objects rendered in dull greens, grays, and browns. Nate Piekos’ bold, capitalized lettering emphasizes each line, while contributing to a sense of permanence that complements the diverse elements within “Paranoid Gardens” #1.

In theory, the diverse components of “Paranoid Gardens” #1 seem incongruous. However, Gerard Way and Shaun Simon’s creative script and Chris Weston’s hauntingly brilliant artwork come together to create an unmistakable feeling that this comic series will leave a lasting impression. Despite some minor aesthetic imperfections, the debut issue of “Paranoid Gardens” is a captivating and unusual slow-burner.

Published by Dark Horse Comics

On July 17, 2024

Written by Gerard Way and Shaun Simon

Art by Chris Weston

Colors by Dave Stewart

Letters by Nate Piekos

Cover by Chris Weston

Read More

2024-07-17 17:10