Why Johnny Bananas Thought He Wouldn’t Be Asked Back to The Challenge

Why Johnny Bananas Thought He Wouldn't Be Asked Back to The Challenge

As I delve into the vibrant world of reality TV, I find myself reminiscing about the good old days when it was all a bit more rugged and raw. Yet, here we are today, with a blend of TV elements that have evolved over time, much like a fine wine maturing in its barrel.


Initially, during the competition known as “The Challenge“, “Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio” was often seen as an easy target for victory, even in the finals hosted by “T.J. Lavin“. In simpler terms, he was someone who was expected to win easily or without much difficulty.

In a private chat with Francesca Amiker from TopMob News, Johnny shared his experience. He said, “I managed to last 24 hours during my initial season, which led me to believe I wouldn’t receive another invitation. However, it seems they found potential in me that I wasn’t aware of.”

Although Johnny might not have appeared particularly attractive during his only appearance on The Duel in 2006 – where he was defeated by fellow cast member Tyler Duckworth from The Real World: Key West in a watermelon lifting challenge and was the first one to be sent home, T.J. did express confidence in him by saying, “I’ll definitely see you again in the future.”

And the California native wasn’t about to be a quitter.

The 42-year-old pondered, “They offered me another chance, and I believe I seized that opportunity well.”

After almost two decades, he is undoubtedly one of MTV’s most successful contestants, accumulating a total of 68 daily challenge victories across various seasons such as The Island, The Ruins, Rivals, Battle of the Exes, Free Agents, Rivals III, Total Madness, and The Challenge 40: Battle of the Eras, which premieres on Wednesday, Aug. 14 at 8 p.m.

“After 18 seasons,” Johnny remarked as he joined Rachel Robinson, Leroy Garrett, and Olivia Kaiser for a preview discussion, “Here I am now.” This gathering was special because they would be competing alongside their contemporaries from the show, who also made their debut in Hall Brawls and Pole Wrestles during their era.

Johnny expressed that he had spent the most precious years of his life competing, enduring pain, and breaking a sweat across the planet. He wouldn’t give up those experiences for anything in the world.

Why Johnny Bananas Thought He Wouldn't Be Asked Back to The Challenge

And Johnny isn’t the only one stunned to still be sporting his Challenge jersey. 

In his first season, back in 2011 during Rivals, Leroy at the age of 39 recalled everyone saying, “This will be your final season,” to which he responded, “I’ve just arrived!” Now, several seasons later, we’re still competing.

Rachel also didn’t think she’d still be bunking with the coworkers she met as a teen. 

41 years old and here I am, returning for season 40, finding myself in better physical condition than I was at 19. Honestly, I never thought this would be the case for me. Moreover, none of us could have anticipated that the show would still be as massive as it is today, even surpassing its initial popularity back in the day.

Fortunately, the group of former participants from shows like Real World and Road Rules, along with stars from other reality programs such as Big Brother, Survivor, Love Island, and Ex on the Beach, persistently held onto their belief.

As a lifestyle expert, I might say: “Much like a band that experienced multiple resurgences throughout different decades – first becoming iconic in the ’80s, then adapting to the trends of the ’90s, and finding success again in the 2000s – I am constantly evolving and reinventing myself.”

Fans of the show “Challenge” have been passionately supporting their favorites for quite literally decades, unlike many reality stars who might jump at the opportunity to generate income by, say, melting an ice block with their body heat.

Johnny mentioned, “I’ve had supporters since my college days who have remained with me. Our audience is remarkably loyal – they’ve stayed with us all this time. That’s a significant factor in our show’s enduring success. We may not be the coolest or the most glamorous, but we are undeniably gritty. And that’s what keeps us going.”

Though not everyone is convinced the show has necessarily changed for the better. 

Why Johnny Bananas Thought He Wouldn't Be Asked Back to The Challenge

10 years away allowed Emily Schromm, who appeared on 2013’s Rivals II, to remark on the notable contrast between then and now. She commented that while it appears slightly more polished, there seems to be a greater emphasis on TV elements compared to before. She added that it was once a bit rougher, but not as much as it is now.

As an ardent admirer, I’d put it this way: She’s all about showing up and giving it her absolute best to prove herself. However, she understands that nowadays, people crave their own special moments. So, it’s not quite the same as before, but it’s a part of the game.

Why Johnny Bananas Thought He Wouldn't Be Asked Back to The Challenge

If you were to inquire from Tori Deal, she would confirm that the show, which she joined in 2017 following consecutive seasons on “Are You The One?”, has undergone various changes over the past ten years.

In my perspective, as a lifestyle advisor, I’ve noticed that many individuals are putting in their best efforts to garner significant attention online, as this often leads to monetization opportunities on social media platforms.

Then the online trolls decided they would like a word. 

Tori stated, “Nowadays, people are becoming more cautious about their public image since they don’t wish to be criticized harshly. This creates an intriguing dilemma: ‘Should I participate and entertain, or should I safeguard myself online to avoid being attacked on Twitter?'”

Despite the occasional jabs from long-time gamers like Johnny towards newcomers, who he acknowledges may not have been as thoroughly vetted as players were back in the early 2000s, he still thinks there are some fresh faces deserving of support.

He stated that some individuals they chose were clearly born for this role, and Olivia is undoubtedly one of them. He highlighted her impressive run to the finals during her debut season in late 2022, expressing that she fits the show perfectly due to her natural talent.

Admittedly, the Love Island alum wasn’t exactly a student of the game. 

Olivia admitted that when she received the invitation for The Challenge, she hadn’t fully grasped what she was signing up for. She thought, “I’ll give it a go,” but upon arrival, she found herself questioning, “What on earth is this?” Before long, she just jumped right in.

Why Johnny Bananas Thought He Wouldn't Be Asked Back to The Challenge

Without a doubt, Kyland Young, who previously appeared on “Big Brother,” thoroughly prepared himself for joining “The Challenge: USA” in the year 2022.

In essence, he pointed out that as a novice, you gain an edge by observing and learning from the experienced players such as Darrell Taylor and Chris “C.T.” Tamburello. He emphasized this is a significant advantage because these champions didn’t have the opportunity to learn from each other or observe their own performances to improve. Instead, they had to figure things out on their own. This period of learning from others’ victories and failures gives you an edge, he expressed, hoping that it will be sufficient for success.

Read More

2024-08-14 20:20