Madden NFL 25 Review: Old Problems Loom Large

Madden NFL 25 Review: Old Problems Loom Large

As a die-hard football fan with years of experience playing Madden games under my belt, I can say that Madden NFL 25 is like that ex you just can’t seem to shake off – it starts off great, promising a thrilling and immersive experience, but as time goes on, the cracks in the relationship become more apparent.


Reflecting on a less-than-subtle comparison, experiencing Madden NFL 25 brought back memories of any high school romance. The initial thrill was undeniable – the first date, stolen moments of conversation, late-night chats about trivial matters. Even attending the prom together felt magical. Yet as time went on, it became apparent that beneath the surface, things weren’t as perfect as they seemed. Eventually, you both realized that your desires and life goals were vastly different.

Madden NFL 25’s On-Field Improvements Are Marred by Countless Legacy Issues

Madden NFL 25 Review: Old Problems Loom Large

On a broader perspective, the gameplay in Madden 25 appears improved compared to its previous version. It seems as though the developers have drawn inspiration from the more open-style gameplay of College Football 25, adding a greater sense of smoothness to your ball carrier. Notable players such as Christian McCaffrey or Tyreek Hill can now evade defenders in a much more spectacular fashion than before. A scene reminiscent of DeAndre Hopkins’ legendary cut on DeAngelo Hall during Hard Knocks reoccurred several times during my Franchise Mode gameplay with Justin Jefferson and the Minnesota Vikings.

In addition to enhancing open-field movements, Madden 25 introduces various pre-snap adjustment advancements borrowed from College Football. You can now employ half-slide strategies on offense or deploy cunning coverage formations to conceal your defensive setup. This level of control is sure to delight seasoned Madden enthusiasts and novices alike, as they master its use with practice. Moreover, the game boasts impressive new catch types and animations that are worthy of making the Sportscenter Top 10 list.

In other words, my observation about digging deeper into the gameplay is particularly relevant now. Indeed, some fresh elements and strategies are commendable, but unfortunately, it’s still the same flawed Madden experience that gamers have faced for quite some time. The blocking mechanism, in particular, continues to be a conundrum, where it’s unpredictable whether your players will act like real individuals or not. All too frequently, blockers end up getting outmaneuvered, slipping off blocks, and then standing motionless as if they were turned into statues.

Beyond the debatable defensive mechanics, I’ve also found that animations frequently overshadow common sense, particularly with EA emphasizing its physics-driven tackling this season. When it functions correctly, it appears impressive, but when it doesn’t, you’re instantly reminded that Madden is not an accurate representation of the NFL. Instead, it reflects Madden’s own world.

As a dedicated gamer, let me share an instance that highlights my point about Madden not truly simulating football. I was controlling the Minnesota Vikings, calling a basic slant route for star wideout Justin Jefferson – a receiver many would argue is among the best in the world today. A slant route involves a quick cut and then a straight run – nothing fancy.

In all fairness, if this were an isolated incident, I might cut EA some slack. But these kinds of plays occur frequently in every match. Your cornerback seems fixated on the opposing QB, only to drift away from the ball when it’s thrown. Your wide receiver is running a go route and you opt for a handoff instead, causing the receiver to block even though he can’t possibly know the ball has been thrown. It’s these subtle nuances that make Madden NFL 25 hard for me to appreciate because I wish another developer could step up to create something more thoughtfully designed in terms of the on-field gameplay.

Mode Improvements Leave Much to be Desired

Madden NFL 25 Review: Old Problems Loom Large

Even though one might acknowledge that care is lacking in various aspects, none of these areas appear particularly flawed. However, they fail to impress or give the impression of progress being made. The longer you engage with modes like Franchise, the more you become aware of peculiarities that seem like oversights. For instance, in my news feed, ESPN was discussing a “highly anticipated quarterback face-off” between two 58 overall, free-agent quarterbacks who didn’t actually take the field. When I went to discuss my plans for my rookie defensive end with my coordinator, we instead focused on my quarterback’s development. It’s these frustrating details that lack depth that ultimately mar the entire experience.

It’s important to mention that during the initial days of playing Madden NFL 25, my PlayStation 5 would freeze if I attempted to start a new Franchise. To play Superstar mode, I had to log in, exit, log into Ultimate Team, log out, and then re-enter Superstar before it functioned properly. Fortunately, these issues appear to have been mostly resolved, but I’ve heard that some players are still experiencing similar problems.

As a lifelong football enthusiast and avid gamer, I must admit that I’ve been following Madden NFL series for quite some time now. Over the years, I’ve seen it evolve, adapt, and occasionally take a step back. With the release of Madden NFL 25, I can’t help but feel that we’re treading familiar ground once again.

Rating: 3 out of 5

Read More

2024-08-23 18:40