Comic Book Reviews for This Week: 9/11/2024

DC #1

Absolute Power: Task Force VII #6

In this series, the individual pieces are more impressive than the whole sometimes seems. There’s a lot to explore here, and the way the stories intertwine doesn’t always provide a fully satisfying experience. Yet, each piece on its own is quite compelling. It’s evident that the continuous narrative threads are robust, and “Absolute Power” manages to keep you hooked on these storylines. – Paraphrased by AI Model

Rating: 3 out of 5

Batman ’89: Echoes #4

As a devoted fan, I must admit that the pace of Batman ’89: Echoes remains somewhat leisurely, despite the increasing intensity and unmasking of characters. Yet, Joe Quinones’ meticulous linework and Leonardo Ito’s somber color palette keep the visual experience smooth and engaging. Perhaps it’s the extended gaps between issues, but following the intricate web of deceit within the plot has become somewhat challenging. Nevertheless, with Batman and Robin finally taking center stage, I sense an exhilarating climax is on the horizon. – Jamie Lovett (paraphrased)

Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Batman and Robin #13

In a surprising turn, Batman and Robin #13 delves deep into Damian’s personal growth and family ties. This issue sees him uncovering truths about himself and his familial relationships, which is both heartfelt and poignant. Additionally, there’s an exhilarating scene where Bane takes on a dinosaur in a punch-filled encounter. While the storyline seems crisp and straightforward, it effectively concludes the current narrative, setting the stage for changes to come as DC embarks on All In. Despite the clean finish, it’s rewarding to witness the resolution of the ongoing conflict between Batman and Robin, father and son. – Paraphrased by AI Model

Rating: 3 out of 5

DC #2

From the DC Vault: Death in the Family – Robin Lives #3

Nearly at the End: Robin Lives #3 – A Mini-Series Almost at its Conclusion

Rating: 3 out of 5

Shazam #15

The work of Josie Campbell, Emanuela Lupacchino, and their team on this comic title remains remarkably exceptional. As the Shazam! group strives to safeguard their city from impending doom, Billy Batson’s bond with his superpowers’ fate is significantly challenged. The script penned by Campbell is rich with emotionally resonant and meticulously crafted scenes, brilliantly enhanced by Lupacchino’s emotive and consistently developing art style. Following this issue, I am eagerly anticipating what lies ahead for this comic book series. – Jenna Anderson (Paraphrased version)

Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Marvel #1

The Amazing Spider-Man #57

During Zeb Wells’ tenure as writer for Peter Parker, the series is best known for introducing characters like Paul, but another aspect that may not always get noticed is the delving into New York City’s criminal underworld and Tombstone. As Wells’ story arc nears its climax, a showdown between Spider-Man and Tombstone is imminent. In this phase of the narrative, Zeb adds some unexpected twists that readers might find intriguing. Generally, I appreciate Zeb’s knack for crafting smaller scale adventures featuring Peter Parker. While there are significant perils in Spidey’s path, they seem authentic to New York City and the elements established by Wells so far. John Romita Jr. is responsible for the artwork here, and while he delivers well, some panels appear less detailed, suggesting they could have benefited from additional refinement. — Paraphrased by Evan Valentine

Rating 3.5 out of 5

Avengers Assemble #1

This comic, “Avengers Assemble,” aims to recapture the essence of Avengers comics from an earlier period, a task that Marvel has struggled with in the past, whether through “back-to-basics” reboots or miniseries set in those bygone times with some familiar creators. Instead of being molded by blockbuster film visions, this team is portrayed more as a superpowered emergency response unit. Orlando’s script emphasizes the relationships between the characters, who seem like perfect embodiments of their original selves. Smith skillfully handles an action-packed plot leading to a surprising twist on the final page that will keep fans guessing. “Avengers Assemble” #1 is a charming debut that fills a gap in what’s been missing from Avengers comics. – Paraphrased by AI

Rating: 4 out of 5

Captain America #13

Charlie Ridgely says that this latest Captain America issue, similar to many previous ones, seems disorganized and lacks the charm of our beloved Captain America character. However, it does include an exciting fight scene which makes it more enjoyable compared to some of the other issues. But overall, it’s not as good as we’d hoped.

Rating: 2 out of 5

Fantastic Four #25

The ongoing Fantastic Four saga remains a remarkable demonstration of storytelling prowess, delivering a serialized yarn that’s full of surprising twists. Stranded on an alien planet, the team grapples with love, grief, and destinies beyond our comprehension. Ryan North’s script is a heart-wrenching beauty, while Carlos Gomez’s artwork and Jesus Aburtov’s colors showcase a bold, whimsical style. In short, this issue left me both uplifted and devastated. Kudos to the entire team! – Jenna Anderson (paraphrased)

Rating: 5 out of 5

Spider-Man: Reign 2 #3

The narrative doesn’t seem to offer significant insights or departures from our existing understanding of Spider-Man/Peter Parker. Instead, the concept of an older Spider-Man in a new setting appears more as a marketing ploy than a storytelling tool. However, the ideas presented are quite entertaining, and at times that can be satisfying enough for readers, like seeing Mary Jane transform into Venom. – Charlie Ridgely

Rating: 3 out of 5

Marvel #2

Star Wars #50

After over four years, this version of the Star Wars comic concludes with a solitary issue, presenting an independent story. Since this narrative falls between Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back and Star Wars: Return of the Jedi, most of the storylines it developed had minimal impact on the established canon, which diminished the excitement of the adventures our heroes embarked upon. In this issue, Luke recalls to Ben Solo an occasion where he, Leia, Lando, and Chewbacca were given the opportunity to defeat the Emperor, but at a heavy price. This extended issue offers an exhilarating and captivating standalone tale that underscores the contrast between the Jedi and the Sith, particularly their willingness to make sacrifices for their goals. Although Charles Soule’s writing remains engaging, the overall tone of this story seems more like an afterthought than a conclusion. Considering that many readers have followed this Star Wars series for nearly half a decade, and its finale, including the preceding issues, lack substance on a larger scale, it’s difficult not to feel a bit disappointed. If this issue had been a special edition or any other one-time story, it would have been more satisfying, but as the series’ farewell with no plans for renewal, we’re left with a melancholic sense of what could have been – Patrick Cavanaugh.

Rating: 3 out of 5

Ultimate Black Panther #8

In a new twist, Black Panther: The Ultimate Edition has been subtly deviating from traditional styles, with occasional departures that set it apart from the usual character aesthetic. The latest installment, penned by Bryan Hill and illustrated by Stefano Caselli, continues this trend but in a way that adds depth to the storyline. Big ideas are becoming more prevalent in Hill’s script, potentially opening doors for innovative and original concepts. Meanwhile, Caselli masterfully portrays war’s grisliest aspects, with each graphic panel carrying a powerful visual impact. – Reimagined by AI

Rating: 4 out of 5

Uncanny X-Men #2

In this new comic series, titled “Uncanny,” Rogue’s team’s second issue continues the storyline started in the first issue, following the aftermath of Krakoa’s destruction for one of the main X-teams. The initial issue laid a strong foundation, and this issue builds upon it effectively. Previous comic series have introduced new mutants seeking to join Xavier’s school, but “The Outliers” are particularly likable from the start. Writer Simone manages to juggle multiple storylines skillfully, adding intriguing aspects to each one. The artwork by David Marquez is exceptional and represents a career high point for him. Although Krakoa cast a large shadow over the X-World, “Uncanny” meets and exceeds that standard in quality. -Paraphrased by AI.

Rating 4.5 out of 5

Vengeance of the Moon Knight #9

Over the last few months, Moon Knight has experienced quite an adventure, which leads us to the final instalment of Vengeance of the Moon Knight. This thrilling series concludes by presenting the highly anticipated showdown between the original Moon Knight and Maximilian Coleridge, aka The Shroud, who attempted to become the new Moon Knight. Along the way, many loose ends are neatly tied up. The artwork by Devmalya Pramanik and colorist Rachelle Rosenberg is impressive even before we reach the main event, but when the fight begins, it’s truly spectacular, with one standout page that warrants all the acclaim. The final page doesn’t disappoint either, as Moon Knight consistently combines style and substance, and Jed MacKay once again demonstrates this masterfully by writing a chapter that keeps its edge without compromising the character’s essence at his core. As we move into a new phase for Moon Knight, his future has never looked brighter. – Paraphrased by AI

Rating: 4 out of 5

Venom #37

One engaging spin-off from the Venom War saga unfolds, featuring a narrative set outside the main timeline. Writer Torunn Gr?nbekk effectively breathes new life into Dylan Brock’s character by delving into his own history and the concept of future events in a manner reminiscent of Kyle Reese. Artist Cafu skillfully merges the 1960s Spider-Man universe with a battle-worn figure from the future, a fusion that seemingly wouldn’t gel but surprisingly does here. Despite Dylan primarily being a one-dimensional character, this series remains enjoyable. – Sarah Johnson

Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Wolverine #1

2024 was a standout year for the Wolverine, starring in one of Marvel Cinematic Universe’s top hits, Deadpool & Wolverine. After a triumphant return to the role in the applauded Logan, actor Hugh Jackman reprised his iconic character. Known for his frequent bloody and violent escapades, the new creative team ensured that these elements were preserved in the updated storyline of Wolverine. Writer Saladin Ahmed and artist Martín Céccolo have crafted a fresh journey for the indestructible X-Man, who has left Xavier’s School For Gifted Youngsters behind to explore the wilderness. Check out the full review here. – Evan Valentine.

Rating: 3 out of 5

Other Publishers #1

Ain’t No Grave #5

Issue #5 of “Ain’t No Grave” wraps up as you might anticipate, with Ryder given a chance to argue for her life, but ultimately death remains undefeatable. However, the ending may seem a tad underwhelming. What truly shines in this issue is its exploration of life’s significance. Ryder is forced to confront the consequences of her actions and understand the true cost of her quest for additional time. Though the story seems to be concluding too neatly at times, the weight of Ryder’s lessons transforms this issue into a truly exceptional one, making the entire mini-series a real gem worth treasuring. – Nicole Drum (Paraphrased)

Rating 4.5 out of 5

The Department of Truth #25

In its 25th edition, the Department of Truth reaches a climactic point as Osawald expounds his theory on the significance of all events leading up to this moment. This captivating comic features an elite group of guest artists whose work, guided by Martin Simmonds’ intellectually stimulating style, challenges the boundaries of reality and has characterized the series. For dedicated readers, this issue promises a sense of release as well as anticipation for what lies ahead. – Jamie Lovett (paraphrased)

Rating: 4 out of 5

Geiger #6

Issue #6 delves into the consequences following the clash between Geiger and The Electrician, focusing particularly on Barney, the two-headed mutant wolf. This installment primarily explores Barney’s post-battle state and his coping mechanisms, offering a unique angle: exploring the lives of animals in this world. Readers get a glimpse into human nature through an animal’s perspective, learning a valuable lesson about standing up against adversity instead of hiding. The artwork, as always, is exceptional, making for a tranquil but emotionally resonant read. – Paraphrased by AI

Rating: 4 out of 5

Godzilla: Here There Be Dragons II – Sons of Giants #3

In Sons of Giants #3, the narrative strategy remains consistent with the first two installments, utilizing familiar strengths and drawbacks. Inaki’s artistic talent is undeniably adaptable, yet the storyline progresses at a snail’s pace, as Thomas Jefferson devotes an entire issue to explaining concepts that readers might have already figured out themselves. If you’re after striking Kaiju art, you won’t be disappointed, but this issue doesn’t provide much insight into why we should empathize with these kaiju enthusiasts and their enigmatic conspiracy. – Paraphrased by AI

Rating; 3 out of 5

Johnny Quest #2

The latest installment of Johnny Quest, titled issue #2, is maintaining an exhilarating trajectory, offering much-anticipated content following the climactic ending in the premiere issue. Writer Joe Casey skillfully navigates between satisfying established series expectations while simultaneously reflecting its contemporary context. Meanwhile, artist Sebastian Piriz, alongside colorist Lorenzo Scaramella, strikes a harmonious blend of preserving the series’ past action-packed essence and infusing it with modern action comic dynamics. In essence, this narrative promises to captivate longtime fans while also appealing to newcomers. – Paraphrased by AI

Rating: 4 out of 5

Other Publishers #2

Profane #4

As I edge closer to Profane’s climactic end, I can feel a shift in the air – elements once frustrating are now fitting seamlessly into the noir narrative they’re meant to be. It’s like the meta gimmicks have finally found their place, and it feels amazing. The next issue is going to determine so much, but the penultimate one has set the stage nicely for a satisfying conclusion. – Charlie Ridgely (Gamer)

Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Space Ghost #5

The latest reboot of Space Ghost sees the battle against Zorak venturing into unanticipated, emotional realms. It’s evident that David Pepose has a unique grasp of the title’s history and future across various platforms, which is enhanced by Jonathan Lau’s rugged yet timeless artwork and Andrew Dalhouse’s vibrant coloring. This Space Ghost series is consistently finding its ground in an engaging manner, according to Jenna Anderson.

Rating: 4 out of 5

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #2

In issue 1 of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, we found Raphael in a physical prison, but in issue 2, Michelangelo finds himself in a metaphorical one. After a falling-out strained the Turtles’ brotherhood, Michelangelo journeyed to Japan and became the star of a tokusatsu-style TV show. While fame offers many benefits, it can’t replace family, an absence that starts to torment him, echoing the themes in The Last Ronin. Both the artwork and color palette capture the glamour on the surface of Michelangelo’s lifestyle as well as the shadows lurking beneath. True to form, Michelangelo triumphs over the threat against his life not by suppressing his pleasure-seeking nature, but by amplifying it in an over-the-top manner. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles #2 continues to deliver high-quality storytelling for this relaunch. – Jamie Lovett

Rating: 4.5 out of 5

Time Waits #1

Time Waits #1 Review – A Captivating Debut

Rating: 5 out of 5

Transformers #12

In this latest installment of the Autobots and Decepticons saga, artist Daniel Warren Johnson’s captivating artwork plays a crucial role. But fear not, as fill-in artist Jorge Corona steps up admirably, maintaining the same intensity and style. With Johnson continuing to pen the story, we witness a thrilling, emotionally charged narrative in this twelfth issue. It’s a rollercoaster ride that showcases Optimus Prime and Shockwave in epic proportions. This heart-pounding tale takes us on an unpredictable journey within the Transformers universe, exploring new territories for the franchise. The Energon Universe has been a remarkable endeavor, blending fresh perspectives on Transformers and GI Joe into comic books, and I eagerly anticipate its continued evolution. -Evan Valentine (Paraphrased by Mistral AI)

Rating 5 out of 5