EA Sports College Football 26 Review – Homefield Advantage

by

After EA discontinued their NCAA series in 2014, I had been eagerly waiting for its comeback last year. In the past, I considered Madden and NCAA Football equally appealing – the former offered more complex systems while the latter provided enjoyable pageantry. However, since College Football 25, I’ve found the NCAA experience to be more appealing compared to the NFL version.

With College Football 26, this statement rings particularly true. There’s simply no match for the 136 intricately designed stadiums complete with their distinctive marching band fight songs. However, I’ve consistently preferred the style of NCAA over Madden, but what has tipped the balance this time is the inclusion of engaging immersive elements.

I really enjoy the customization options in Electronic Arts’ latest sports games. If you’re looking for a more realistic gaming experience, you can adjust the game settings to simulate 15-minute quarters, wear and tear on players, and even simulated injuries (or just crank up the difficulty level to Heisman). Prefer a more arcade-style experience? Toggle on pass slowdown and fine-tune numerous gameplay sliders to your liking. The Even Teams feature ensures a fair competition by balancing player stats, removing ratings and RPG elements entirely if you prefer. In short, there are countless ways to tailor your gaming experience according to your preference.

In this setting called ‘Even Teams’, competition becomes more balanced as it uniforms all players’ abilities, thereby removing any influence of individual ratings or Role-Playing Game (RPG) statistics. If you prefer a game without these elements, this setting provides that option.

Speaking as a dedicated fan, I must say that the immersion is truly remarkable in this game. The player movement and physics are not only realistic but also balanced, making the experience fair. Defensively, it’s a breath of fresh air compared to previous EA titles. The new tackle system adds depth to the gameplay, making each attempt to tackle more engaging due to the directional physics involved. You still have the hit stick, bull rush, dive tackles, and ball strip options, but the added physics layer brings an extra dimension to these actions.

In other words, the improved animations clearly show whether a running back is guarding the ball or charging ahead, enabling quick judgments on whether to dislodge the ball or tackle aggressively. It’s clearer to understand player actions when their movements are so lifelike – although, of course, it’s not flawless. The realistic physics also increase the chances of players tripping and getting entangled in crowded areas, leading to some unexpected plays.

During a play in the end zone, I tossed the ball towards an unguarded receiver close to the left post. He had a chance to catch it, but instead, he accidentally nudged it with his shoulder pad (though it didn’t physically touch the ball, the hitbox still registered the contact), causing the ball to drift awkwardly among a cluster of linebackers before ultimately being intercepted. In essence, there are instances where the collision detection isn’t perfect, largely due to the intricate player movements and physics, but it’s not overly apparent.

Currently, I haven’t delved deeply into every gameplay aspect and alteration, but my general take on how it all combines is quite favorable. The throwing mechanics, with pass leading and power adjustments, seem smooth and adaptable, while the pre-snap options appear to be more diverse and abundant than before.

To fully leverage the array of gaming improvements, Dynasty Mode makes a comeback, offering greater detail and personalization options. Initially, I found myself a bit overpowered by Dynasty, particularly due to the numerous additions related to the transfer portal and expanded coaching roles.

As a devoted fan, I’m thoroughly impressed by this year’s version. It captures the essence of every team’s head coach authentically, from their unique archetypes to their playbooks and career statistics. The pursuit of realism extends to the players as well. For those who closely follow college football, it would be challenging to find a squad without its actual roster perfectly represented. Each player comes with a set of distinct Physical and Mental Skills, which can make managing details quite engrossing, but also a bit overwhelming at times.

At certain moments, the hit detection could use improvement, mainly because of the intricate player actions and physics. However, these issues are usually subtle enough that they don’t significantly impact the gameplay experience.

In Dynasty, delving into details is appreciated, but if you’re like me and prefer jumping straight into the gameplay, you can automate the intricate aspects of recruitment using League Settings. I wasn’t aware that automation was an option, so I had a hands-on experience with the recruiting process until I eventually delegated that part of coaching to the computer.

As an avid gamer, I reached my recruitment cap and couldn’t help but feel like I was drowning in monotonous paperwork with no end in sight. The game’s recruiting interface left me yearning for a more user-friendly experience. Instead of streamlined actions, it seemed I had to perform numerous button presses just to complete one task—one of the many tasks required each week during recruitment phase. It was like wading through quicksand, and once I broke free, I knew I wouldn’t look back.

To capture the attention of a promising prospect, it’s essential to start by providing a scholarship opportunity. Following this, engage in a series of small but significant steps like meeting family members, communicating via social media, and arranging a visit before aggressively selling your product or service. Each step can consume anywhere from five to 50 time units, with a weekly limit of approximately 700 units.

Those eager to invest time in these routine tasks will find plenty to explore here, thanks to the enhanced Transfer Portal and more authentic coaching staff.

As a gamer, I truly miss having a bulk action option. Constantly navigating into each player’s sub-menu, checking off tiny tasks just to give them a chance to perform feels like a micromanagement migraine. In my gaming days, I fondly remember the NFL Head Coach games that were a breeze compared to this new level of user frustration in interface design. If you could incorporate bulk actions, it would significantly ease the assembly-line pain of recruitment.

To put it simply, if you’re prepared to invest effort in these minor duties, this game offers a wealth of depth with its updated Transfer Portal and more authentic coaches. My experience in Dynasty significantly enhanced when I activated automatic recruiting and solely concentrated on enhancing my coach and participating in matches.

The coach tree caters perfectly to my RPG enthusiast side, avoiding excessive complexity. Each coach initially comes equipped with a few archetype trees, each boasting distinctive abilities that can be unveiled over time. Strategists such as Steve Sarkisian of Texas enhance their players’ potential for success while also inflicting demoralizing penalties on the opposition.

Additionally, you have the freedom to design a coach completely from the ground up and customize all the settings to your liking. However, I found the default setting at level 1 slightly challenging when surrounded by coaches at level 40. But for those who enjoy embarking on a prolonged dynastic adventure, crafting your team from the beginning could become quite addictive.

Discussing obsession and lengthy travels, Road to Glory provides a comparable type of adventure, albeit with significantly less need for detailed management. Upon first play, I was pleased to discover the expanded high school section compared to last year’s version. The four-game senior year experience at your chosen high school assists in deepening my connection to my character’s narrative and personal growth. However, it’s worth mentioning that the way these high school games are played out leaves me feeling somewhat neutral.

Without a roster or depth chart at your high school, it’s impossible to devise any kind of strategy. If you want to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the opposing team, that won’t be possible. It seems that all teams in this league are balanced equally to prevent a star player from intercepting passes unexpectedly. However, without knowing which players to steer clear of and which to collaborate with, the high school football experience might as well be run by an automated system.

“The execution of how the Road to Glory mode handles high school games leaves me wanting more.”

Despite my best efforts, the high school section seemed less engaging than expected and even hindered my play due to its reliance on blind strategy. Automating these high school games can limit your control because performance on game day impacts which schools express interest in you. However, receiving offers from schools after a game was thrilling, and completing challenges to enhance the evaluation score created an enjoyable progression system.

At Washington State University, where my player eventually found themselves, the challenge was to prove myself worthy to the coach, so I wouldn’t be relegated to the bench. An exciting aspect of Road to Glory is that it allows you to choose between a highly-rated player from the get-go or an underdog with only one star. The journey of your character is entirely customizable. If you desire a challenging and authentic experience, begin as a one-star player and grind through high school matches. Poor performance might mean limited college recruitment opportunities. However, there’s always the transfer portal available once you accumulate some experience.

One aspect of my journey in Road to Glory that left a lasting impression on me was realizing how strongly I disliked my coach’s play-selection strategy. Unlike other games, you are bound by the coach’s limited selection of plays until you’ve earned their trust enough to make your own decisions.

During game days, I wasn’t managing to get any screens or curls at all, leaving me pondering a switch to another team where I could connect better with the coach. If it weren’t for the unique coach trust system here, I might not have even considered switching teams. I mean, it’s the local mid-tier school that I had in mind as the backdrop for my player’s journey, and their colors and fight song are fantastic, so why go through the hassle of transferring, you know?

As I progress through my weekly tasks, the rewards for hitting milestones subtly guide me to thoughtfully allocate my efforts and resources.

One aspect I appreciate about immersion is managing academics, social activities, and training. You have a limited number of points to allocate in your weekly schedule. I found myself at risk of failing my grade due to excessive focus on developing leadership skills and earning XP through training, given that I was a new student eager to make an impression. Just before an exam, a classmate invited me for an outing, which could potentially disrupt my studies.

Certainly, I opted out, acknowledging that it might slightly damage my reputation, but my academic commitments have become more manageable after intense study sessions. The skills acquired from achieving milestones in these activities also necessitate a delicate juggling act of allocating resources effectively. In summary, this year’s Road to Glory mode left me quite content. It boasts an impressive array of customization options and RPG elements, although the high school segment could benefit from further development to fully appreciate its potential.

For enthusiasts anticipating online gameplay, Ultimate Team is making a comeback as the major mode, and just like before, it can be played individually. The operation of the live service system remains largely unchanged from last year. A variety of events, which rotate regularly, offer short-term incentives such as card packs and points once completed. Constructing your team still feels laborious and requires a lot of grinding.

Experiencing the repetition of opening packs for fresh characters feels quite dull and lacks the exciting charm that foreign gacha games seem to perfect.

Experiencing a slight delay when opening cards and organizing rosters seems to lag behind by approximately half a second. The game itself crashed twice while I was collecting my rewards from challenges. However, playing in-field ball during Ultimate Team mode didn’t encounter these lag problems; instead, it only affected my navigating through menus. In terms of presentation, there’s not much improvement. Unwrapping packs and acquiring new players feels quite dull, lacking the engaging excitement that foreign gacha games excel in.

Obtaining a unique player card should be an exciting and grand experience with distinctive visual effects and audio, yet it’s just another monotonous reveal (with cards that aren’t particularly appealing), often accompanied by lengthy loading times. In summary, I found myself not delving too deeply into this year’s Ultimate Team primarily because of these problems. However, for those who have enjoyed testing their team against friends and participating in the changing events, it’s more of the familiar experience.

To wrap up, let’s delve into the ambiance of game days as a separate topic. With an accurate portrayal of all 136 NCAA FBS teams, the distinct commentary for each adds a breath of fresh air to the viewing experience.

In simpler terms, this group of seven analysts discusses recent wins and losses of various teams, highlights their overall strengths and areas for improvement, and occasionally delves into the team’s background. If the analysis primarily focuses on a single Dynasty team, you may notice some repetitive commentary lines. However, the commentary strives to mix things up by adapting to your gameplay style.

“The dynamic lighting and detailed buildings are true to their real-life counterparts.”

Listening to Michigan’s brilliantly arranged fight song, “The Victors,” echo from the live marching band following a touchdown score is always an exceptional feeling, and it’s even more magnificent with this particular game’s on-site recordings. No college stadiums appear more beautiful than this one. The vibrant lighting and intricate architecture accurately depict their real-world counterparts. It wasn’t until I played as the Iowa Hawkeyes at home that I truly appreciated all the subtle stadium details. The camera angle and commentary focusing on the structure overlooking the field was a fascinating touch, and the moment when the players and crowd lift their arms towards the children’s hospital above Kinnick Stadium before each game was a captivating piece of real-life stadium folklore.

It’s thoughtful how the game reveals school tales and customs, and with more than a hundred of these, there’s plenty to appreciate. One of this year’s most impressive visual enhancements is the realistic day-night cycle. One moment that left me genuinely surprised in sports games (other than when I dropped the ball or made an interception) was starting the game during daylight and observing the sun set into nighttime in the fourth quarter. Such progression of time isn’t usually noticeable in other sports games I’ve played, and I must admit, I didn’t anticipate such realistic cycles to be incorporated here.

Certainly, the escalating excitement level enhances the atmosphere at home games, with deafening chants throwing off the visiting team’s focus. Sadly, though, the new stadium entrances for Road to Glory are distressingly silent and devoid of sound effects. Where are the booming cheers and band music? Where is the camaraderie among players as they charge onto the field? The balance of audio in RtG entrances seems off, requiring immediate attention, which I didn’t detect elsewhere. However, overall, I’m thoroughly impressed with this year’s NCAA championship’s immersive on-field presentation, despite the need for improvements in Road to Glory entrance design.

I really appreciate the impressive on-field spectacle of this year’s NCAA championship, but I think there could be significant improvements made to the Road to Glory entrances.

In essence, College Football 26 delivers everything that enthusiasts of this series crave, enhancing its predecessor in significant aspects. However, it’s not a flawless product; there are minor hiccups like the awkward recruiting system in Dynasty mode and the sluggish menus in Ultimate Team. Yet, these problems can generally be disregarded.

As a dedicated fan, I can’t help but marvel at how the school pageantry infuses a dash of grandeur into the football experience, setting it apart from the more subdued and predictable feel of its Madden counterpart. The diverse array of teams, distinctive coaches, and players certainly contribute to a more immersive and engaging gaming experience compared to other sports games out there. Granted, the rebooted series may still be grappling with some growing pains in its sophomore year, but College Football 26 has undeniably earned the title of a winner for me.

This game was reviewed on the PlayStation 5.

Read More

2025-07-14 14:13