The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon season 2’s long awaited reunion is thrilling but flawed

The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon season 2’s long awaited reunion is thrilling but flawed

As a dedicated fan of The Walking Dead franchise for over a decade now, I must say that the return of Melissa McBride as Carol Peletier has truly rejuvenated the series. The transformation of Daryl Dixon’s solo season into “The Book of Carol” was not only unexpected but also incredibly refreshing, offering a new perspective on the undead apocalypse without requiring extensive knowledge of previous seasons.


In place of Melissa McBride for season 1, Norman Reedus moved into the spotlight, leading “The Walking Dead” to its strongest performance in years.

In France, Daryl Dixon’s standalone season breathed fresh life into the zombie series, offering a novel take on the ever-hungry undead creatures that could be easily understood even without prior knowledge about the franchise.

And that’s probably a good thing, given how the main show ended. 

However, the closing moments of the first season for The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon brought about an unexpected twist. McBride, who had announced his departure from the spin-off a few months earlier, reappeared in a post-credit scene, confirming that Carol would indeed be part of the series once more. Notably, this wasn’t just a minor role; she was set to play a significant part.

Originally known as Daryl’s solo venture, the series has been rebranded as “The Book of Carol,” a title that suggests an equally significant role for McBride. Indeed, the show delivers on this promise in a remarkable way.

The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon season 2’s long awaited reunion is thrilling but flawed

The temptation to immediately reunite Carol and Daryl must have been strong, despite the distance between them. After all, their relationship was the original inspiration behind this spinoff, and it’s arguably the most popular and well-fleshed out still across this entire franchise. But thankfully, the writers avoided making the same mistake made by the team behind Rick and Michonne’s The Ones Who Live. 

There, Grimes and his katana-wielding wife were first reunited in awkwardly written dream sequences before their actual reunion happened for real in the flesh. But here, three out of this season’s six episodes are dedicated to the journey Carol embarks on to find Daryl, despite how much the odds are stacked against her. 

Carol proves herself to be incredibly inventive, quickly persuading a plane owner to take her on a transatlantic flight. You see, she had tragically lost touch with her daughter in France, which is the story she uses to convince Ash (Hamish Patel), who himself lost his son years ago to a horde of zombies. However, Carol’s ‘daughter’ isn’t a young girl; instead, she’s a 55-year-old motorcycle enthusiast with greasy hair and a fondness for crossbows. Ash doesn’t need to know the truth, so they embark on their journey filled with hope and a tank of gasoline.

In the second installment, Carol and Ash travel to Greenland, where they must repair a leak on their plane. During their stay, they sample reindeer stew and meet two fellow survivors. However, these individuals ultimately prove to be dangerous as is often the case, with over a decade having passed since the onset of the zombie apocalypse. At one point, strange vegetative walkers rise from the ground, momentarily disrupting our appreciation for the breathtaking scenery.

It’s a shame that new variants like these don’t appear as much this time around, because these zombie twists were a big draw in season one, helping to set Daryl’s show apart from everything that’s come before. In fact, there’s much more emphasis on the past in general when it comes to season two. 

In the initial three episodes, particularly, The Book of Carol skillfully interweaves her past experiences of pain with her present role as a formidable killer, subtly hinting that beneath Carol’s tough exterior lies a tender, mourning mother and an unhealthy propensity for deception.

McBride consistently stands out among the top performers of this franchise, skillfully portraying contrasts just as effectively now as ever. It’s truly moving to witness Carol, in a moment of vulnerability, weeping in Daryl’s embrace during their reunion. Reedus also captures the genuine bond between them, subtly hinting at the strong connection they share both on and off-screen.

Despite the certainty of their meeting, The Book of Carol skillfully amplifies the emotional impact when they first recognize each other amidst the turmoil, a sense of familiarity returning swiftly as the duo slide effortlessly back into their old routines – an instant delight for long-term readers. Their bond encompasses affection, yet it’s also filled with quick wit and the sort of squabbles that arise from a shared history of overcoming adversities together.

In this latest chapter of our apocalyptic journey, I find myself intrigued by a change within Daryl’s character – his unexpected bond with Isabelle (Clémence Poésy) and Laurent (Louis Puech Scigliuzzi). The mystery surrounding Laurent, the boy who could potentially be humankind’s last hope amidst this gruesome zombie landscape, adds an extra layer of intrigue. It’s puzzling to me, Carol, as I observe Daryl, why he seems so deeply invested in these new relationships when he has the comfort and familiarity of Judith waiting for him back home in the States.

The underlying strain suggests broader conflicts within the show “The Walking Dead: Daryl Dixon.” By elevating Carol’s role, it no longer stands as distinct and apart from other shows like it used to. Integrating McBride into the series has attracted dedicated fans of the franchise, and their interactions remain as compelling as ever. However, this shift in focus might unintentionally diminish screen time for the French supporting characters during season 2.

Upon Carol’s comeback, some difficulties similar to those that made “The Walking Dead” hard to stay invested in towards the end resurface. This isn’t McBride’s responsibility at all, but it’s a bit of bad timing that references back to the main series now share the same pacing problems and forgettable antagonists that characterized its later years.

In the first season of “The Walking Dead,” Daryl Dixon’s storyline was focused and compelling, as he worked diligently to escort Laurent to safety at the Nest. However, the second season became confusing with the introduction of two uninteresting groups, each vying for control over Daryl and the boy. Amidst this chaos, there was less opportunity for Norman Reedus to shine, despite his impressive performance as a leading actor in the series’ inaugural season.

Indeed, it’s incredibly exciting to witness Daryl and Carol reunited once more, as this spin-off evolves into the series it was intended to be. Now that the practicalities of their reunion have been addressed, there remains a great opportunity to create something truly exceptional in the upcoming third season for Daryl (and Carol).

Read More

2024-09-29 21:34