Why Over the Garden Wall Is the Halloween Tradition You’ve Been Missing

Why Over the Garden Wall Is the Halloween Tradition You've Been Missing

As a connoisseur of all things eerie and enchanting, I must say that Over the Garden Wall has certainly captured my heart (and perhaps a bit of my soul) during the Halloween season. Having grown up watching classics like The Great Pumpkin and Ray Bradbury’s The Halloween Tree, this series has managed to carve out its own unique niche in the annals of spooky storytelling.


Animation has played a significant role in the traditions of Halloween, captivating young audiences with a wide range of tales and subtly introducing darker motifs that aren’t frightening at first glance. This tradition dates back to Disney’s “The Skeleton Dance” short from 1929, and was continued in 1949 with the release of The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad. Iconic Halloween imagery has been honored throughout this history, with 1966’s It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown being a classic animated adventure that horror fans still enjoy each year. Now, as we move ten years forward, it’s time for a new era to begin, where Cartoon Network’s Over the Garden Wall can be seen as the definitive series to celebrate Halloween.

Despite being widely acclaimed by millions of fans during fall, particularly close to Halloween, the ten-episode series “Over the Garden Wall,” created by Patrick McHale, initially aired a week after Halloween instead. The story’s inception was from a short titled “Tome of the Unknown.” Initially envisioned as a feature film or a long-running narrative, financial and time limitations transformed the plot into roughly two hours, with each episode lasting approximately 11 minutes.

As I delve into this captivating series, I find myself as bewildered as Wirt (Elijah Wood) and Greg (Collin Dean), lost in a world that’s enchanting, puzzling, and slightly ominous all at once. The artwork transports me to a dreamy New England scene, reminiscent of a Thomas Kinkade painting, with lush greens, earthy browns, and vibrant oranges setting the stage. Wirt’s distinct hat and Greg’s overalls hint at a storyline that remains shrouded in mystery, leaving me guessing if we’re in the recent past, the distant past, or perhaps even a Tolkien-esque fantasy realm (a theory bolstered by Elijah Wood’s past work in The Lord of the Rings trilogy). The opening scenes hook me and keep me guessing, withholding answers and igniting my curiosity.

Why Over the Garden Wall Is the Halloween Tradition You've Been Missing

Spending time with Wirt and Greg reveals their entertaining and comical relationship, as their humor is both childishly funny for young viewers and absurdly witty for older ones. It’s not surprising that McHale devoted a lot of effort to Adventure Time before creating Over the Garden Wall, another Cartoon Network show that shares many of this miniseries’ tonal characteristics.

In their journey through the mysterious forest known as “The Unknown,” Wirt and Greg meet a gruff-voiced woodsman called Christopher Lloyd, who narrates chilling stories about a monster that murdered his wife and imprisoned his daughter’s soul in a lantern. To keep the lantern burning, he continuously fells trees. This initial episode of the show sets the stage for what viewers can expect throughout the series, offering a dark and eerie tale set against a brooding backdrop, yet infused with occasional humor to lighten the mood. Although there may not be intense fear in this opening, there are enough ominous undertones to foreshadow the growing darkness and increasingly bizarre events that will unfold in each subsequent episode.

Why Over the Garden Wall Is the Halloween Tradition You've Been Missing

In the pilot, the show sets an autumnal tone, but it’s Episode 2, titled “Hard Times at the Huskin’ Bee,” that truly amplifies the eerie vibe of Halloween. Characters Wirt, Greg, and bluebird Beatrice (played by Melanie Lynskey) arrive in Pottsfield, a town where everyone is dressed as pumpkins for their harvest festival. The background music in the first episode helped create the series’ atmosphere, but it’s the tunes in “Hard Times at the Huskin’ Bee” that capture the essence of Over the Garden Wall, offering melodies that seem both timeless and vaguely unsettling, as if they were pulled straight from a dream. The presence of pumpkins and harvest festivals intensifies the Halloween spirit even further, making this episode stand out as a formidable contender for the impact of any classic animated program.

For the remainder of the show, Wirt, Greg, and Beatrice meet an array of characters in whimsically strange scenarios that seem lighthearted but hint at a darker, unsettling undercurrent. The series isn’t exactly scary, but it maintains an overall eerie vibe suitable for this season. Furthermore, the atmosphere of the show is so enchantingly mysterious and spooky that it feels fitting for Halloween. To top it off, the last episodes have a stronger connection to Halloween traditions and provide enough insights to explain the origins of their journey.

Why Over the Garden Wall Is the Halloween Tradition You've Been Missing

In simpler terms, “Over the Garden Wall” is a captivating tale that explores the bond between siblings as they navigate a mysterious world filled with strange creatures. Along their journey, themes such as judgment, loneliness, isolation, and shame are subtly addressed. The series also showcases the courage it takes to overcome these societal pressures, much like “It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown” uses its spooky humor to emphasize Linus’ sincerity. For audiences of all ages, there are layers of meaning and themes within “Over the Garden Wall” that can be appreciated. The brothers’ adventure illustrates how facing the unknown can be terrifying, but sometimes dealing with uncertainty is preferable to confronting real and relatable feelings like anxiety.

During the Halloween season, there’s an abundance of animated tales to explore, ranging from timeless classics to less conventional picks such as “Halloween Is Grinch Night” and “The Halloween Tree,” but McHale’s “Over the Garden Wall” has gradually earned its place as a classic October viewing tradition. This 10-episode series offers an immersive experience for those seeking to delve into the eerie ambiance of Wirt and Greg’s journey through the Unknown, while also providing comfort in seeing animated characters grapple with their own fears in a fantastical realm. Many viewers eagerly await Halloween as a means of temporary escape from real-life terrors, much like how the 2009 anthology “Trick ‘r Treat” gradually built its fan base, culminating in Sam, its mascot, becoming a staple at Spirit Halloween stores. It’s just a matter of time before “Over the Garden Wall” becomes as deeply rooted among mainstream audiences as a seminal, spooky series for generations to come.

Over the Garden Wall is currently streaming on Hulu.

What’s your take on the Halloween franchise? Reach out to Patrick Cavanaugh on Twitter or Instagram for discussions about Star Wars and horror topics! (This version maintains the informal tone while providing a clearer connection between the two ideas – discussing Halloween series and reaching out to Patrick for Star Wars and horror talks.)

Read More

2024-10-01 19:11