Mr Loverman review: Line of Duty and Death in Paradise stars lead BBC adaptation

Mr Loverman review: Line of Duty and Death in Paradise stars lead BBC adaptation
3.0 out of 5 star rating

As a viewer who has seen my fair share of love stories, I must say that Mr Loverman stands out as a unique and captivating series. The story’s focus on the Black queer experience within the older Caribbean community is both refreshing and vital, offering a perspective that is often overlooked in mainstream media.

Isn’t it intriguing, in a way, that Bernardine Evaristo’s book, Mr Loverman, and the TV series adapted from it both borrow their names from Shabba Ranks’s Jamaican dancehall tune?

In a 1992 interview on the talk show The Word, broadcasted by Channel 4, I found myself utterly astonished by the musician’s appalling remark, suggesting that gay men should face crucifixion. This shocking statement was met with boos and outraged responses from the audience, who clearly disagreed with his views. Host Mark Lamarr swiftly dismissed this hateful speech as nonsensical, earning himself a thunderous applause. The atmosphere in the studio that day was one of disapproval and unity against such intolerance.

Evaristo’s “The Loverman” and its eight-episode TV version focus on a particular aspect of the LGBTQ+ community, where homophobia is present, yet this narrative emphasizes the profound love story that spans several decades between Barrington Jedidiah Walker (Lennie James) and Morris De La Roux (Ariyon Bakare). Despite marrying women and having children with them, these characters have harbored feelings for one another since meeting as teenagers in Antigua. Their eyes were only for each other from that moment on.

In the initial episode, it’s revealed that Barry, affectionately called by his friends, has been married to Carmel (Sharon D Clarke) for fifty years. However, over time, their relationship seems to have spoiled like sour milk.

She believes he’s habitually unfaithful due to his late nights out and arriving home reeking of alcohol. However, it turns out that her husband has indeed been untrue, but the evidence was always in plain sight, often found sipping coffee and reading newspapers at their kitchen table, near her husband.

Peering into the kaleidoscope of memories, I’m granted a vivid glimpse into Barry and Morris’s clandestine romance across the decades. From the tender, dreamlike moments on that idyllic island beach during their teenage years, where sparring and frolicking served as a veiled exploration of each other’s bodies, to furtive encounters in Hackney, east London during their adult lives – Mr. Loverman masterfully portrays the evolving phases of their relationship through three distinct epochs of their lives. Although makeup can only go so far in mirroring the passage of time, it manages to paint a compelling picture of their love story.

However, we primarily exist in the current moment, and at this seasoned age of 74, Barry has come to a decisive point. He’s tired of living a falsehood, an announcement that elicits a subdued reaction from Morris, whose connection with his former spouse has been fractured for quite some time.

As a movie enthusiast, I must confess that the plotline seems eerily familiar, and I’m cautiously guarding my expectations for an immediate resolution to this classic will-they-won’t-they dilemma. This story revolves around a man who is bravely grappling with the decision to shatter his current life at a time when most of us are comfortably entrenched in our familiar routines.

Mr. Loverman moves at a leisurely pace, which is neither unwelcome nor surprising. Those who find it sluggish may have misinterpreted the task.

Mr Loverman review: Line of Duty and Death in Paradise stars lead BBC adaptation

In various roles spanning shows like Save Me, The Walking Dead, and Line of Duty, James has consistently given dedicated performances. Here, he truly shines with a powerful portrayal that feels authentic, and the numerous vintage suits Barry wears definitely add credibility to the character.

As a film enthusiast myself, I can’t help but echo James’ sentiments about Barry’s role being a goldmine due to his intriguing contradictions and imperfections. Delving into these complexities was an engaging challenge for me as well. Despite the undeniable effort he put in to embody the lead character, ‘loverman’, Barry makes it seem effortless – such is the depth of his acting prowess.

As a passionate cinephile, I can’t help but admire Sarah Clarke’s exceptional performance as the devoted wife of Barry, a role that resonates deeply with me. Her character yearns for her husband’s love, a connection that has always been elusive, leaving her feeling neglected and unwanted in their relationship.

As Barry yearns for a life with Morris, she grieves for the life Barry had vowed to provide, or the one that could have been if she were with someone more compatible.

Carmel’s solitude prompted a fleeting affair with a coworker from Hackney Council, an encounter potentially destined for something deeper. Additionally, she received romantic overtures from other men during her younger years. However, her affection for Barry continually pulled her back, adding to the agony, and Clarke vividly portrays that torment, her grief and anger palpable on screen.

But don’t expect a sob fest, even though there are plenty of heartbreaking moments and reckonings throughout the series.

In a unique blend, the writing navigates the delicate balance between dramatic intensity and comedic relief, primarily through Barry’s sharp narration. This narrative approach prevents the story from descending into unbearably sad realms with no escape. Some viewers might find this style jarring, as it seems to undermine the more solemn scenes. However, the screenwriter, Nathaniel Price (known for Noughts + Crosses and The Outlaws), might argue that it reflects the complexities of real life.

Although Carmel’s experiences may not resonate with everyone, the sensation of feeling unwanted or isolated within a relationship is sadly relatable for countless individuals. Similarly, even if Barry’s circumstances seem foreign to you, the contemplation of whether one is truly living authentically and if it’s ever too late to alter the trajectory of your life are questions that many people grapple with throughout their personal journeys.

Mr. Loverman delves into a unique Black perspective, an area seldom discussed in mainstream platforms; however, its core topics – identity, love, family, and connections – transcend racial boundaries, further emphasizing the notion that so-called “Black stories” are, in fact, universal narratives that resonate with everyone.

On-screen, the depicted world is intimately detailed, precise, and centered, yet it delves into the profound human abilities to love and deceive; our propensity to soar and plummet. It’s a narrative that explores coping with regrets and yearning for something improved, something more personally fulfilling – a struggle we all can identify with.

However, it’s important to acknowledge that this situation also highlights a persistent, awkward issue regarding homophobia within Caribbean communications, which is not exclusive to places like Antigua but rather widespread. It’s worth noting that same-sex activity was legalized in Antigua and Barbuda as recently as 2022, and in Trinidad and Tobago in 2018.

In Jamaica, it’s still illegal.

The themes of religion and the identity struggles faced by young Black men, such as Daniel (played by Tahj Miles), intertwine to form a harmful concoction that influences Barry’s indecision, compounded by his apprehension about losing his daughters, particularly Maxine (portrayed by Tamara Lawrance), who is most dear to him.

In my perspective, as a fellow believer, I’ve often heard my companions at Carmel Church express concern that those who deviate from what they call the path of righteousness set by God may face eternal consequences such as suffering in the hereafter.

Apart from being a tribute to Mr. Loverman himself, this novel is also a heartfelt homage to the Caribbean, particularly Antigua. The author’s team included an Antiguan consultant in their work to maintain the genuine feel of the setting, whether it’s here in the UK or back in its sunny islands.

This captivating show is full of vivid details, but there’s a part of me that feels it could work well on stage too. The dialogue and acting are quite dramatic, with characters expressing their inner feelings aloud during tough scenes – as one might do in a play when close-ups aren’t an option. Even the narration enhances this sense of theatricality.

It seemed that Daniel’s storyline required more development, or perhaps he could have had his own series altogether. Conversely, Maxine and her sister Donna’s struggles with launching a fashion line and re-entering the dating world didn’t hold much intrigue and appeared to divert attention from Barry and Morris.

It’s truly invigorating and essential that a unique kind of love narrative, one centered around Black queer relationships within the older Caribbean community in Britain, is being explored. Moreover, it’s worth noting that the Black characters portrayed aren’t merely depicted as oppressed or involved in illegal activities like drug trafficking. Instead, Barry amassed his wealth through property investments – a departure from the stereotypical narratives often preferred by commissioners and studios.

Just as the case of Mr. Bates versus the Post Office demonstrates, television is not merely for amusement; it holds the power to positively transform lives. Certainly, Mr. Loverman delivers on the entertainment front, and it might very well accomplish something far more significant.

Starting at 6 am on Monday, 14th October, every episode of Mr Loverman can be streamed on BBC iPlayer. Meanwhile, the initial two episodes will debut on BBC One at 9 pm that same day. The subsequent episodes will then be aired each week.

2024-10-14 08:34

Read More