One Tree Hill’s Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

As I delve deeper into the captivating world of “One Tree Hill”, I find myself utterly mesmerized by the extraordinary lives led by its cast members. Hilarie Burton, a beacon of strength and resilience, experienced an unimaginable tragedy with the loss of her dear friend Scott Kirkpatrick in 2007. This heart-wrenching event served as a catalyst for Burton to reevaluate her priorities, ultimately leading her to quit the series and embark on a journey that took her to Paris and beyond.


Bethany Joy Lenz is getting candid about her off-screen friendships.

In the course of filming the popular teen drama series “One Tree Hill” during the early 2000s, the show’s alumna disclosed that she and her costar Sophia Bush had a disagreement. This discord was reportedly sparked by the former’s prolonged association with The Big House Family, a religious organization to which she has earlier likened as a “cult.

In her memoir titled “Dinner for Vampires: Life on a Cult TV Show” (and yes, she was actually part of a cult too!), Bethany wrote in People magazine that she had been using religion as a standard or guideline. Her blossoming friendship with Sophia suffered due to this, and instead of mourning her ego’s loss properly, she deeply regrets not being able to go back in time, walk into Sophia’s trailer, and offer her a heartfelt, lasting hug.

Regarding the effect Bethany’s participation in the organization had on their friendship: The former star of White Collar, who departed the Big House Family not long after the birth of her daughter Rosie in 2011 (with ex-husband Michael Galeotti Jr.), expressed that Sophia’s actions frequently clashed with Bethany’s beliefs about how a woman should conduct herself.

Despite not initially realizing it, she was remarkably intelligent beyond her bubbly and compassionate nature – smart enough for NASA, if looks weren’t a factor as the astronauts wouldn’t want to leave Earth,” Bethany clarified. “I hadn’t fully appreciated her dedication.

As a die-hard admirer, I can’t help but observe that Sophia was often cherished yet overlooked due to her stunning beauty throughout her life. Yet, this unassuming beauty only fueled her relentless pursuit – a tireless effort to validate her worth.

The 43-year-old found their disagreement particularly distressing since she initially got along well with Sophia during the show’s filming. In truth, they even decided to take in pit bull puppies together, until Bethany discovered that she wasn’t prepared for a close relationship with Sophia.

In her memoir, it was reported that Sophia had a knack for being quite amusing and a touch playful – never hesitating to join in on a spur-of-the-moment escapade.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

During the entirety of One Tree Hill’s nine-season run, Sophia (Brooke Davis) and Bethany (Haley James Scott) portrayed friends on screen. However, it wasn’t until they started co-hosting the Drama Queens podcast with Hilarie Burton in 2021 that they began discussing their past disagreements.

On the October 16th episode of “Call Her Daddy” podcast, Bethany shared that on “Drama Queens”, she discussed their past experiences, what was challenging, joyful, and the emotions of untangling mysteries that we both felt back then.

However, Bethany acknowledged that their connection continues to develop, describing it as “an ongoing process of growth and change.

TopMob News reached out to Sophia’s rep for comment but has not heard back. 

Read on for more secrets from the One Tree Hill cast…

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

Originally, Mark Schwahn conceived the project as a film titled “Ravens,” but after four years of persuasion from Warner Bros. TV officials, he decided to adapt it into a television series instead.

2. The show’s title was derived from the U2 song “One Tree Hill,” taken from their album “Joshua Tree.” Each episode of the series was titled after a song by different artists, including Dashboard Confessional and R.E.M.

3. As a lifestyle expert, let me share an intriguing tidbit about Chad Michael Murray. Despite being offered the part of Ryan on The O.C., he chose instead to play Lucas, the complex character with a love for basketball and writing. Initially, producers saw him as Nathan due to his bad boy roles on Gilmore Girls and Dawson’s Creek. However, Murray found a personal connection with Lucas, having experienced the pain of his mother leaving his family at a young age, which drove him to fight for the role.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

4. Bethany Joy Lenz tried out for both Haley and Brooke, but she wasn’t particularly interested in playing the latter since she saw them as similar roles. Eventually becoming a main cast member, Lenz changed her blonde hair to dark and straightened her naturally curly hair to distinguish herself from Hilarie Burton, who portrayed Peyton, in the series.

17-year-old James Lafferty, with his extensive basketball background, found himself facing a challenge in securing the role of Nathan due to his limited acting experience. In an exclusive behind-the-scenes interview, he admitted, “I don’t believe I was their first choice.” Instead, he had to audition on six separate occasions.

He wasn’t wrong. Noted executive producer Joe Davola, “When James went into casting he was a dark horse to get the job.” 

6. Sophia Bush didn’t appear in the first episode, but she joined the cast as Brooke starting from the second one and continued to be present weekly, also directing three episodes later on.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

7. A year after first working together, Murray and Bush got engaged in 2004 and married shortly afterwards. However, just five months into their marriage, reports emerged that they had separated. In 2018, Bush shared insights about their professional relationship post-split during an episode of Dax Shepard’s Armchair Expert podcast.

In his words, there wasn’t any room for introspection following their split, Bush mentioned. Moreover, the producers were, in her opinion, overstepping boundaries by being excessively disrespectful towards both herself and Murray.

She went on to say, “They frequently aired ads about it, and it was quite distressing,” she added. “They often exploited individuals’ private affairs, not only for me and my ex, but also for other cast members when they became close. They would share sensitive, personal details from their lives that would later be incorporated into storylines. This wasn’t acceptable.

8. Bush later started dating Lafferty in 2008 and then entered a romance with Austin Nichols, who portrayed her TV husband Julian on One Tree Hill. However, their relationship ended in 2012, which was also the year that the series concluded.

In the later seasons, actress Lisa Goldstein, who portrayed Millie, tied the knot with Brendan Kirsch, the show’s basketball coordinator, back in 2011.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

10. In an episode of their podcast “Drama Queens,” which she co-hosts with Bush and Lenz, Burton disclosed that her husband, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, nearly worked with her on “One Tree Hill.

When she mentioned meeting Jeff, he replied casually, “I tried out for that show,” which turned out to be the part of Keith, a character who served as Lucas’ mentor. However, this role ultimately went to Craig Sheffer, and Jeff seemed surprised when I said, “Really? What about that?

11. Danneel Ackles, Burton and Morgan’s co-star, was the one who introduced them. Her husband, Jensen Ackles, who had a close bond with The Walking Dead star because he portrayed his father on Supernatural, played a role in this introduction.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

12. In an unexpected public statement released in November 2017, 18 individuals associated with the production (actors and crew) alleged instances of sexual misconduct against Schwahn, suggesting a troubling environment on the set.

In her 2020 memoir titled “The Rural Diaries: Love, Livestock, and Big Life Lessons Down on Mischief Farm”, Burton described Schwahn as the antagonist in her personal fairy tale. He was someone who incited rivalry among female actors, coerced us into performing explicit scenes that made me feel unwell and embarrassed, encouraged young actresses to accentuate their busts, made physical advances towards all of us, and forced unwanted kisses upon me.

13. Furthermore, Bush shared her personal experiences during a June 2021 interview on the “Chicks in the Office” podcast. She alleged, without naming them, that herself and some of her co-stars from “One Tree Hill” were subjected to control and manipulation by unnamed individuals behind the scenes.

According to Bush, there were adults whom we believed and still believe to be reliable, but who we now realize were excessively controlling and manipulative. They did not want us to form close relationships because they feared we might unite and demand more resources, which was something we were unaware of at the time. It’s quite strange when looking back on it now.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

14. Murray and Burton left the show after six seasons in 2009. However, Burton hinted that the reasons for her exit had been brewing long before, as she shared in her autobiography.

Following the tragic death of her cherished friend Scott Kirkpatrick during his service in Iraq in the summer of 2007, she experienced a significant shift in her life. His demise served as a powerful reminder, causing her to realign her priorities and aspirations once more.

Speaking as a lifestyle guide, let me share a personal journey that resonates with many. For years I roamed, seeking my niche, yearning for something more profound. What I yearned for was not just a place, but a sanctuary, a space where dreams could bloom and risks could be taken. A place to try, to stumble, and rise again. A place that would challenge me daily and fill each moment with purpose.

15a. In the moment, Schwahn addressed a gathering of devoted fans in Paris, as reported by The Los Angeles Times. He disclosed that their departures were due to contractual issues, yet expressed hope that they might return to us. “I’m confident they’ve been presented with enticing opportunities,” he said. “Should they choose not to return, well, that’s always a possibility…[the show] has managed to weather some of the boldest decisions we’ve ever made.

In simpler terms, Murray addressed the show’s audience in a video, stating “They won’t be bringing me back next year…in order to save money. I suggest you start blogging about your frustrations.” However, unlike Burton, Murray did appear in the final season of the show.

One Tree Hill's Bethany Joy Lenz Reveals Past Fallout With Sophia Bush

16. In a daring decision, the show One Tree Hill leaped ahead in time during season six, opting to skip over the college years and instead rejoin the characters as fully-grown adults.

In an interview with TopMob News back in 2015, Lafferty stated that if you compare our show to others and notice the transition from high school into their characters’ next life stage, it often feels uncomfortable and doesn’t flow smoothly.

17. Country artist Jana Kramer appeared on One Tree Hill during its last few seasons and disclosed on her podcast Whine Down that a certain cast member created a difficult environment for everyone involved in the show, claiming she was prohibited from being friends with Lafferty.

In a 2021 episode, she explained that while she was on the show, there were some complex social dynamics, not necessarily petty arguments, but more like rules about who could and couldn’t interact if they were friends with someone else. Due to these circumstances on set, she wasn’t particularly close to James during that time.

2010 saw the imprisonment of Antwon Tanner, a former cast member, for his part in a fraudulent scheme involving the sale of illegally obtained Social Security numbers across different states. Convicted after being caught in an undercover operation attempting to sell fake Social Security numbers (16 of them) and three counterfeit cards in 2009, Tanner, who portrayed Antwon “Skills” Taylor on the show, admitted his guilt.

Read More

2024-10-23 05:49