What Star Wars Episode 10 Needs to Learn From the Writer’s X-Men Failures

As a seasoned gamer with a soft spot for both Star Wars and the X-Men universe, I find myself in a peculiar position regarding the news of Simon Kinberg’s new trilogy. With a mixed bag of experiences from his work on the X-Men franchise, I can’t help but feel a tinge of apprehension coupled with a pinch of excitement.

Lucasfilm has tapped Simon Kinberg for scripting and producing an entirely new set of Star Wars films, bringing both potential advantages and drawbacks to the space opera series. Kinberg is primarily recognized for his contributions to the X-Men universe, having penned four installments and overseeing multiple others. He could introduce a consistent narrative thread across the distant galaxy, yet opinions on his filmmaking may not align with everyone’s preferences.

Simon Kinberg has been the screenwriter for films like “X-Men: The Last Stand,” “X-Men: Days of Future Past,” “X-Men: Apocalypse,” and “Dark Phoenix.” He also penned the 2015 reboot of “Fantastic Four” and was involved in producing several other X-Men movies, as well as all three Deadpool films. Kinberg served as a creative consultant on “Star Wars: The Force Awakens” and is credited in both “The Force Awakens” and “Rogue One.” As reported by “The Hollywood Reporter,” he will now write and produce a new Star Wars trilogy, focusing on fresh characters rather than continuing the Skywalker Saga.

This situation opens up numerous opportunities for Kinberg and Star Wars, and it’s sparking plenty of curiosity among fans. Examining Kinberg’s recent career, there are several notable strengths that could translate well into this fresh project. As per Variety’s report, Kinberg was selected due to his demonstrated ability to succeed, as he is regarded as reliable, financially sound, and a pleasure to collaborate with. Industry experts have noted that Kinberg excels at communicating effectively with studio executives, particularly when it comes to venturing into creative risks within large franchises.

Despite his successes, it’s also true that Simon Kinberg has had a few missteps in his career. The screenwriter faced significant criticism for the 2019 film “Dark Phoenix,” which was both panned by critics and underperformed at the box office. This was the third consecutive X-Men movie written and produced by Kinberg, and it marked his directorial debut. Critics generally agreed that the film fell short in its adaptation of the comic book arc it was named after. If any of Kinberg’s future projects touch on elements from the Star Wars Legends canon, this could potentially be a point of contention once more.

In a positive light, Kinberg’s X-Men films were often dedicated to maintaining consistency and constructing a cohesive universe, though not everyone was always thrilled with how the execution unfolded. If executed effectively, this approach could prove beneficial in Star Wars, given its reliance on nostalgia while also needing innovative ideas and characters. Kinberg is likely to earn kudos for his subtle nods demonstrating a deep understanding of the material and its heritage. Given his background with Star Wars, this should be relatively straightforward for him.

It’s been hypothesized that Kinberg landed this job primarily due to his accomplishments with the animated series “Star Wars Rebels,” which he co-created, wrote, and served as executive producer. This assumption is based on his close ties with Lucasfilm executives Carrie Beck and Dave Filoni, who were also involved in creating “Rebels.” Given their history of working together and their understanding of a significant portion of the “Star Wars” fanbase, this collaboration could be an ideal match for them all.

It’s important to mention that Kinberg’s trilogy appears to be in its initial stages, while many other Star Wars projects are slated for release ahead of it. For now, fans can enjoy the entire franchise by streaming it on Disney+.

2024-11-11 02:09

Read More