Luigi Mangione’s Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

As a seasoned observer of human nature and events, I find myself deeply moved by the tragic tale of Brian Thompson, a man who seemed to have it all yet was tragically taken from us. The irony of his death is not lost on me – a life dedicated to the healthcare industry, yet he himself became a victim of its darker aspects.

Luigi Mangione’s lawyer is standing by his client’s right to due process.

Following the murder accusation of Brian Thompson, the CEO of UnitedHealthcare, in New York City on December 5, Thomas Dickey, his attorney from Pennsylvania, provided further details about the case. Mangione, who was apprehended in Pennsylvania on December 9 for felony charges including forgery and unlicensed gun possession, is anticipated to plead not guilty in both states, as stated by his legal representative.

Dickey stated to reporters on December 10th that he hasn’t found any proof supporting the claim that he is the gunman, emphasizing that it’s crucial to remember the principle of “innocent until proven guilty” in American justice. At present, I’ve seen no evidence whatsoever that points to his guilt.

In light of Mangione being accused of murder in New York rather than Pennsylvania, his lawyer argues that he was unfairly denied bail. According to Dickey, only in specific circumstances such as capital crimes or first-degree murders resulting in life sentences can bail be withheld in this particular state.

He argued that a bail should have been established in this case. The judge might have set a $1 million bail or even a $5 million bail, but it doesn’t matter the amount. What matters is being granted bail. Imagine yourself standing in the spotlight of the criminal justice system; you would want to be free as well.

In addition, Dickey verified that Mangione is resisting being sent back to New York. Simultaneously, New York Governor Kathy Hochul declared her intent to issue a warrant for the extradition of Mangione from Maryland to New York.

She indicated that she is working with the District Attorney’s Office and will endorse a petition for a governor’s arrest warrant, aiming to bring this person to justice. Ensuring public safety is her main concern, and she is determined to use all her authority to maintain the safety of New York City’s streets. (per NBC New York)

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

The reasons behind the actions of the University of Pennsylvania graduate have left authorities baffled as they reconstruct the series of events that culminated in the deadly shooting of Thompson outside a hotel in New York City on December 5th. Friends of Mangione offer some insights into his life, particularly the challenging impact of a severe back injury he had to endure.

In a December 9 interview with The New York Times, R.J. Martin, the founder of the Hawaii co-living space where Mangione lived in 2022, stated that Mangione’s spine was slightly out of alignment. He described how his lower vertebrae were slightly misplaced by about half an inch, which possibly compressed a nerve.

His health issue eventually took a toll on his social interactions, with Martin noting that Mangione, who departed Hawaii in 2023, recognized that due to his back condition, romantic relationships and physical intimacy were not feasible for him.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

In the meantime, his close family members released a statement expressing their deep sorrow over this recent development.

It was stated, unfortunately, that we cannot provide comments on the news stories concerning Luigi Mangione. Maryland State Delegate Nino Mangione, who is related, shared this on behalf of his family on Dec. 9. All we know is what we’ve read in the media. Our family has been left stunned and heartbroken by Luigi’s arrest. We extend our sympathies to the Thompson family and request that people keep all those involved in their prayers.

Now, read on for a full breakdown of the ongoing investigation.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

Brian Thompson served as the chief executive officer (CEO) for UnitedHealthcare, a position he assumed in 2021 after having worked with the company since 2004. During this time, he held various roles within the organization before ascending to the CEO position.

Before joining UnitedHealthcare, Thompson had previously worked at PwC, as per his LinkedIn profile. He also graduated with honors from the University of Iowa in May 1997, majoring in accounting within the field of business administration for his Bachelor’s degree. This information was shared by Steve Schmadeke, the school’s public relations manager, to NBC News.

In Minnesota resided Thompson, who was wedded to Paulette Thompson (as per TopMob News’ examination of public records indicating that they had been dwelling separately for some time). He was also a proud parent of two boys.

He was shot and killed in New York on Dec. 4, 2024. Thompson was 50 years old.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

At 6:46 a.m. on December 4, 2024, police officers from the New York City Police Department’s Midtown North Precinct rushed to a shooting incident outside the New York Hilton Midtown hotel, as confirmed by NYPD Chief of Detectives Joseph Kenny during a press briefing later that day.

At exactly 6:48 a.m., Kenny observed that law enforcement officials arrived on the scene and discovered gunshot injuries on Thompson’s back and leg. The head detective reported that Thompson was taken by emergency responders a few blocks to Mount Sinai West, where the hospital CEO declared his death at 7:12 a.m.

At a recent press conference, NYPD commissioner Jessica Tisch stated that the victim was visiting New York City to address an investor gathering. It seems the perpetrator had been hiding for several minutes beforehand. Upon walking towards the hotel hosting the conference, the victim was approached from behind by the suspect who fired multiple shots, hitting the victim at least twice – once in the back and once in the right leg. Numerous individuals walked past the suspect, but it appears he waited specifically for his target.

According to Tisch, it seems this shooting was carefully thought out and deliberately planned, rather than an unprovoked act of violence.

Investigations by the New York City Police Department are actively moving forward regarding this incident. We’ll keep working tirelessly until we find and bring the person responsible for the shooting to justice.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

As per Kenny’s account, the gunman made his way to the New York Hilton Midtown on foot and reached the hotel’s exterior about five minutes prior to Thompson’s arrival.

In the video, Kenny went on to say, Thompson was spotted strolling solo towards the Hilton at 6:44 in the morning, having left his own hotel nearby, presumably en route to a UnitedHealth Group investors meeting which was set to start at 8 a.m. that particular day.

The lead investigator mentioned that the gunman, who disregarded many bystanders, came up behind Thompson, fired at him, then walked closer while continuing to shoot.

Kenny reported that the armed individual initially escaped on foot, but later hopped onto an electric bike, while the shooter was spotted entering Central Park at Center Drive around 6:48 in the morning.

Kenny said three live nine-millimeter rounds and three discharged shell casings were recovered during the investigation. During a Dec. 6 press briefing, Kenny said the words “depose,” “delay” and “deny” were written on the shell casing in marker.

However, he’s noted the motive for the killing has yet to be confirmed.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

At a news conference held on December 6th, Kenny stated that the investigators possess video evidence showing the gunman’s arrival at Port Authority in New York City on the evening of November 24th.

Kenny added, “I think the bus started in Atlanta. It makes multiple stops, so it’s uncertain where exactly he boarded.

Following the arrival of the gunman at Port Authority, Kenny went on to say, the shooter hailed a taxi and headed towards the neighborhood of the Hilton hotel. He stayed there approximately thirty minutes before taking another taxi to a hostel situated on the Upper West Side.

At five thirty in the morning on the day of the incident, Kenny noted, the gunman exited the hostel and reached the Hilton hotel by 5:41 a.m. According to Kenny, the gunman continued strolling around the hotel’s area before heading to a nearby Starbucks, where he bought a bottled water and a snack. He subsequently returned to the hotel, and the shooting transpired at 6:44 a.m.

Following the incident, the shooter made a hasty escape. According to Kenny’s report, the shooter entered Central Park at the intersection of 60th Street and Center Drive at 6:48 a.m., exited through W. 77th St. and Central Park West by 6:56 a.m. At 7:00 a.m., Kenny noted, the shooter was observed without a bike on W. 86th Street. Four minutes later, as the chief detective reported, the gunman hailed a cab at 86th Street and Amsterdam Avenue. By 7:30 a.m., the gunman was spotted near the George Washington Bridge, according to Kenny’s account.

On December 6th, I, a devoted fan of the news, shared that investigators suspected the gunman had departed New York City, as they’d spotted him at Port Authority, according to Kenny’s interview with CNN.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

At the December 4th press conference, Kenny stated that the suspect seemed to be a man with fair skin, who was wearing a jacket of a light brown or cream color, a black and white pair of sneakers, a black face mask, and a distinctive gray backpack. In the following days, the NYPD published a sequence of photos depicting the person they were searching for, where the individual’s face was hidden by a mask in most of the images.

On December 5th, a senior police officer informed NBC News that images showing an unmasked face originated from security cameras at an Upper West Side lodging house. Furthermore, two different law enforcement sources indicated to the outlet that detectives are working to ascertain whether the person involved used a counterfeit ID and cash to secure a room in the hostel.

As for what led the individual to lower the face mask?

It seems that during the check-in process, they exchanged friendly chat,” Kenny mentioned during the Dec. 6 briefing. “At a certain moment, he lowered his mask and showed a smile to the clerk.

In addition, Kenny mentioned they discovered a mobile phone in the same alley from which the shooter escaped and then proceeded towards the e-bike. However, it’s uncertain whether this phone belonged to the person who fired the gun. Moreover, two authorities familiar with the investigation shared with NBC News that a backpack was located in Central Park as well.

Kenny mentioned that investigators are examining all potential leads related to the case, such as Thompson’s social media posts, conversations with colleagues and relatives, and they’re collaborating with law enforcement agencies in Minnesota and Atlanta as well.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

On December 9th, the Altoona Police Department in Pennsylvania took Luigi Mangione into custody for firearm-related offenses. As per records obtained by NBC News, the charges include two felonies – one forgery charge and one unlicensed firearm possession charge, along with three misdemeanors: tampering with records or identification, possessing tools used in a crime, and giving false identification to law enforcement officers.

According to NYPD Commissioner Tisch, an employee at McDonald’s identified Mangione, prompting a call to the Altoona police. When inquired about his recent visit to New York, Mangione reportedly grew quiet and began shaking, as stated by NBC News.

For roughly five days, NYPD investigators meticulously analyzed countless hours of video footage, acted upon hundreds of leads, and scrutinized all available forensic evidence, including DNA, fingerprints, IP addresses, and more, in order to narrow down the suspect pool. We employed drones, canine units, and scuba divers, utilized our domain awareness system, Argus cameras, and conducted aerial surveys, and our detectives additionally knocked on doors to speak with potential witnesses and applied traditional detective methods that our team is renowned for. This blend of traditional detective work and cutting-edge technology ultimately led to today’s outcome.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

Apart from displaying suspicious behavior, Tisch mentioned, Mangione also possessed several fake identification cards and held a genuine United States passport.

During a press conference on December 9th (as reported by NBC News), she explained that a more detailed search led to finding a firearm and a silencer, which matched the murder weapon. Additionally, they discovered garments, including a mask similar to the one worn by our suspect of interest.

During their investigation, Tisch noted that the officers found a fake New Jersey identification card as well. This ID was identical to the one the person had used to register at the New York hostel before the incident, which later resulted in the shooting.

Furthermore, they found a personally penned note that reveals his drive and mental state.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

On December 9th, court documents show that Manhattan prosecutors have filed a murder charge against Mangione, as reported by NBC News. The 26-year-old is also facing three weapon-related charges: two counts of criminal possession of a second-degree loaded firearm and one count of third-degree possession, which includes a silencer. Additionally, he has been charged with possessing a forged instrument.

He has yet to enter a plea for any charges.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

As reported by NBC News, based on NYPD accounts, Mangione was found with approximately three pages of text, amounting to fewer than 300 words, when he was arrested. Three high-ranking law enforcement sources shared with the outlet that the writings contained phrases such as “Frankly, these vermin deserved their fate.

According to the records, Mangione claimed he worked independently. Nonetheless, these officials have not yet dismissed the possibility of other individuals being involved at the present moment, as reported by NBC News.

According to NBC News, the officials reported that Mangione wrote, “I’ll be brief as I acknowledge your important role in our nation. To avoid any extensive probe, let me clarify directly: I was not collaborating with anyone.

Officals stated that Mangione further commented, “I offer my sincere apologies for any distress or hardships caused, as it was necessary.

However, Tisch noted Mangione’s motive has yet to be confirmed.

In her interview on December 10th, she mentioned that when examining the manifesto – a three-page written statement found – it’s evident that there’s strong opposition towards corporatism and concerns about the healthcare sector. However, as more information is uncovered during this ongoing investigation in the coming weeks and months, the specific motive behind these actions will likely become clearer.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

On December 10, Mangione visited the Blair County Courthouse in Hollidaysburg, Pennsylvania for a hearing. Upon his arrival, as per NBC News reports, he vocalized to the gathered families, “It’s absolutely detached and an affront to the intelligence of the American people.

According to reports, Mangione declined to relinquish the right to avoid being sent to New York and his request for bail was denied. Consequently, he will continue to be imprisoned at the State Correctional Institution (SCI) in Huntingdon, Pennsylvania.

According to attorney Thomas Dickey, Mangione intends to plead not guilty in Pennsylvania, with similar intentions for New York as well, when the case reaches there.

He stated, as reported by NBC News, that he hasn’t found any proof confirming him as the shooter. It’s important to recall that a key principle in American law is the assumption of innocence – one must be declared guilty only after being proven so beyond all reasonable doubt.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

Involved in the killing of Brian Thompson, Mangione is being accused and has multiple cases pending against him, not just in Pennsylvania but also in New York. These accusations encompass offenses such as forging documents and illegally owning a firearm.

He’s an Ivy League graduate, having received a Bachelor of Science in engineering in 2020 and a Masters of Science in engineering at the University of Pennsylvania, the school confirmed to NBC News.

According to the NYPD Chief of Detectives Kenny, further insights were given about Mangione’s background. He was born and brought up in Maryland, but his current address is recorded as Honolulu. Moreover, Kenny mentioned to NBC News that he also has ties with San Francisco.

After Mangione’s arrest, his family released a statement on X.

They stated in their Dec. 9 post, “I’m sorry, but we can’t provide any comments about the news articles concerning Luigi Mangione. The only information we have is what we’ve gathered from media outlets. Our family has been left stunned and heartbroken by Luigi’s arrest. We extend our sympathies to the Thompson family and ask everyone to keep them, as well as all those affected, in their prayers. This news has left us utterly distraught.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

After learning of the shooting, Thompson’s family mourned his passing.

We’re deeply saddened to learn that our dear Brian has been senselessly taken from us,” a statement shared with NBC affiliate KARE in Minneapolis on Dec. 5 says. “Brian was a wonderful, giving, and gifted individual who lived life vibrantly and left a lasting impact on countless others. Above all, he was an exceptional father to our two boys and will be deeply missed. We value your sympathy and kindly ask for privacy during this challenging period as we grieve together.

Thompson’s wife Paulette also recalled how her husband had received threats prior to his death.

She informed NBC News on December 5th that indeed there were some threats made against him, but she wasn’t privy to the specifics. She merely knows that he mentioned there were individuals who had been making threats towards him.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

UnitedHealth Group, the umbrella organization for UnitedHealthcare, conveyed their profound sadness and shock upon the death of their close acquaintance, Thompson. In respect, they lowered their flags to half-staff at their corporate headquarter in Minnesota.

In a statement released on December 4th, it was mentioned that Brian was held in great esteem by everyone he worked alongside with. We are cooperating closely with the New York Police Department at present and ask for your understanding and patience as we navigate through this challenging period. Our thoughts are with Brian’s family and those who were close to him during these trying times.

Furthermore, in their statement on December 5th, the company expressed that their hearts were shattered, but they were equally moved by the tremendous display of compassion and support following the tragic incident.

A multitude of patients, customers, healthcare workers, organizations, and compassionate individuals have made time in their day to contact us,” the message stated. “We are grateful, despite our sorrow. Our top concerns are, firstly, supporting Brian’s family; secondly, safeguarding our employees; and thirdly, collaborating with law enforcement to apprehend the culprit. UnitedHealth Group remains committed to standing by those who rely on us for healthcare. We kindly request that everyone respects the family’s privacy during this time of mourning for their loved one.

Luigi Mangione's Lawyer Speaks Out in UnitedHealthcare CEO Murder Case

Additionally, UnitedHealthcare, Thompson, and the American healthcare system as a whole have faced scrutiny from the public.

Discussions online cover topics such as insurance firms’ rejected claims statistics, along with examining allegations directed towards Thompson.

In a lawsuit filed by the City of Hollywood Firefighters’ Pension Fund in May 2024, NBC News reported allegations against Thompson. He was accused of selling over $15 million worth of UnitedHealth shares, which he supposedly knew were under investigation by the U.S. Department of Justice before the public became aware. When questioned about these trades made by Thompson and other executives, a spokesperson for UnitedHealth stated that they had followed the company’s protocols and received approval from the organization. (Bloomberg was informed this in April 2024.)

The lawsuit, per the BBC, remains active.

Furthermore, although the reason behind the shooting remains undisclosed, various media outlets have pointed out that phrases like “depose,” “delay,” and “deny” found on the spent casings bear a striking resemblance to the title of a 2010 book titled “Delay Deny Defend: Strategies for Dealing with Insurance Companies When They Don’t Pay Claims“.

Read More

2024-12-11 18:21