Alien: Romulus’ Most Controversial Scene “Fixed” for Home Release (but Is It Enough?)

by

Among Alien franchise enthusiasts, Romulus is widely appreciated as a fresh take on horror movies for a new audience. Yet, some longtime fans expressed mixed feelings towards certain scenes in Romulus – specifically, those featuring the likeness of the late actor Ian Holm to portray the android character of science officer Rook. It appears that 20th Century Studios and director Fede Álvarez acknowledged this criticism and chose to take action… or so it seems.

During an interview with Empire, filmmaker Fede Álvarez openly discussed the scenes featuring character Rook and confessed that he himself recognized the face-swapping technique employed to resemble Ian Holm’s likeness was less than impressive.

In the editing process, we simply ran out of time to perfect it,” Alvarez explained. “There were certain shots I wasn’t completely satisfied with because they showed too much digital effects interference. For those who have negative reactions, I understand their concerns.

How Alien: Romulus “Fixed” Rook with Help From LotR

As a movie reviewer, I must say I was pleasantly surprised by director Álvarez’s openness, an attribute rarely seen among filmmakers these days. He candidly admitted that they returned to post-production for the Rook scenes in “Alien: Romulus” and refined them further. He explained, “We recognized areas for improvement and took the necessary steps to enhance those sections, ensuring a superior viewing experience for the home release.” Impressed by his dedication, he successfully persuaded the studio to invest more resources into perfecting the project, ensuring all parties involved had ample time to execute it flawlessly. The result? A significantly enhanced viewing experience that’s worth every penny.

To enhance the scene, Álvarez explains that his crew sought an exceptional prop to assist them. The character Rook was crafted through a blend of animatronic puppetry and computer-generated imagery (CGI) techniques. Initially, due to the tight release date, Álvarez relied more on CGI; however, for the home release, they sourced a scarcely available piece of animatronics to make Rook appear more authentic.

As a cinephile, I’m thrilled to share an interesting tidbit about the behind-the-scenes magic of a beloved film. Master craftsman Shane Mahan, in his genius, created the unique animatronic likeness of Ian Holm for a certain scene in Lord of the Rings. This specific piece was one-of-a-kind, and it was this very detail that Álvarez emphasized during our conversation. For the home entertainment version, they chose to lean more towards the puppetry, resulting in a significantly improved rendition.

Was Visual Quality REALLY The Problem?

Instead of criticizing the character Rook from Alien: Romulus for appearing uncanny and silly, it was more about the controversy surrounding the use of a deceased actor’s likeness as what some perceive as an attempt to capitalize on nostalgia. However, it should be noted that director Fede Álvarez is known as a devoted fan of the Alien franchise, and in many aspects, Romulus could be considered a tribute film for enthusiasts.

Covenant’. The ethical question remains whether this portrayal is a thoughtful tribute or an oppressive digital age nightmare – it could be either, depending on the intentions of the filmmaker versus the studio.

You can check out Alien: Romulus and it’s improved Rook scenes on Hulu-Disney+.

Read More

2025-01-11 00:41