Why Mervin's Critics Are Missing the Point in Death in Paradise

After three episodes, it seems that some fans of Death in Paradise are gradually growing fond of the new lead detective, Mervin Wilson.

“Settling in, getting better,” said one individual on Facebook.

“He is different. I like him, nice change,” added another.

From a passionate cinephile’s perspective, I find myself observing that opinions on Mervin are divided into two main groups. Some of us haven’t fully formed our opinions yet, while others have, but seem to hold a less than favorable view towards his contributions to the cinematic world.

“Still on the fence with the new DI,” commented one viewer, while another wrote: “Not sure yet.”

Others were more specific with their criticisms.

The new employee comes across as overconfident and unintelligent, and I find it hard to continue observing further.

“This new chap isn’t quite what I thought he would be like,” said another. “No laughs, no humour.”

One audience member expressed their sentiment as, “I’m wishing the newcomer would adapt, but his persistent negativity and disdain for this place are becoming exhausting, and I can’t help but feel frustrated with his constant complaints about how good things were back where he came from.

However, although certain judgments may hold up under technical scrutiny and have sufficient supporting proof, it’s worth questioning whether the individuals rendering these judgments have taken into account Mervin’s exceptional personal hardships.

It’s clear now that the individual, originally from London, journeyed to Saint Marie to encounter his mother named Dorna. He had never built a bond with this woman who brought him into the world for nine months, which is why he felt so apprehensive about approaching her door in the first place and ultimately chose to return home without even speaking to her.

As for now, we only have a basic understanding of Mervin’s past events. The circumstances leading up to his birth and everything that happened afterward remain undisclosed.

Initially, his visit was planned to be brief, but it has evolved into a three-month stay – for now at least. It’s clear that he won’t be leaving anytime soon, a fact that even Selwyn, with a hint of mischief in his gaze, seemed to suggest might lead to an extension of his time there.

At first, he postponed his trip to aid the team in solving the murder of rookie officer Benjamin Brice, an incident that turned out to be emotionally taxing. However, he later stumbled upon a shocking and unsettling revelation: there was a possibility that his mother could have been killed, which undeniably alters everything.

Previously, Selwyn shared with the DI that Dorna was scattering her father’s remains in the sea when a sudden, fierce storm arose. However, after reviewing her case documents, Mervin is now convinced of something far more ominous happening and because of this, he feels compelled to stay.

If his mother was murdered, he feels compelled to make sure the culprit is held accountable for their actions. Being a detective, it’s only natural that he desires to be the one who solves this case personally.

So, hardly sunshine and rainbows, is it?

Mervin didn’t relocate to Saint Marie for an exciting new experience; rather, it wasn’t the allure of the place itself, a fresh job opportunity, or a romantic connection that drove his decision to leave everything behind and settle there.

No, Mervin’s circumstances do not chime with the norm.

He reached the beautiful, sunlit island, burdened by the heaviness of the world, standing at a distance from his mother’s house as he pondered whether to approach and knock, uncertain if she would embrace him warmly or reject him.

Quite the dilemma indeed.

If she let him enter, would the experience live up to his expectations? Was their heartfelt meeting going to be filled with affection and comfort? Would he find a lasting place in her world, or would she maintain a certain distance and coolness?

What would he discover about his mother and himself as a result of this experience? Would it have an uplifting or devastating impact on him? Could this entire journey turn out to be a regrettable mistake?

Many unanswered questions loom, some of which will remain unresolved due to his mother’s demise, causing an increasing burden on Mervin’s shoulders.

Unanswered queries abound for Mervin, some of which will forever remain so because his mother has passed away, making the weight on his shoulders heavier and heavier.

Then, he found out that her untimely death might have been caused by someone else, harboring ill intent. This revelation only added to the burden, as more questions began to surface.

As a cinephile, I must confess, the current state of Mervin on screen isn’t his finest hour. His mind is like a bustling metropolis, filled with thoughts that create a constant, discordant symphony, seldom finding pause. He’s treading uncharted waters, and to make matters worse, these new paths are inextricably linked to his mother – a woman who has been the source of immense anguish for him.

Isn’t it understandable, then, that he comes off as harsh and uncomfortable? That he’s seldom amusing? That he frequently appears preoccupied or unengaged?

While it’s crucial to acknowledge that I, too, believe he shouldn’t be completely shielded from criticism, there have indeed been instances where an apology and behavioral correction were necessary. However, let me emphasize that his mind is grappling with a multitude of challenges stemming from intricate traumatic experiences, which are pulling him in various directions.

And for that, he should be afforded some grace.

It’s clear that his prolonged solitude and yearning stem from the separation, which we caught a hint of during the Christmas episode. At that point, he confided in Naomi that he consistently works on Christmas because otherwise, he’d be celebrating the holiday by himself.

As she discussed spending the holiday season with “those who care for you,” Mervin found few words. However, the quiet moments revealed a deep sense of sorrow within him.

Now, Mervin’s journey is underway, just as the Chinese philosopher Lao Tzu put it, “A long journey starts with a single step.

People who dismiss him without giving him a chance to grow, a common trend on Death in Paradise, might not be grasping the overall scenario, or appreciating the sense of fulfillment that will come when he eventually reaches his destination.

Mervin’s transformation will become even more touching and impactful due to his journey towards self-acceptance and comprehension. Its power will stem from his current situation.

As a cinephile, I find myself drawn to a character who vehemently shuns emotional connections and vulnerability, carefully concealing aspects of himself to safeguard his own heart.

Over time, as he delves deeper into the realm of his mother and her associated experiences, there’s a growing likelihood that he will ease his inner turmoil – perhaps even managing a grin, something missing from his expression that has been causing concern among certain spectators.

We haven’t encountered the authentic Mervin as of yet, and I must admit, I’m unsure if he has either. So, hold tight, skeptics. Leaving now would definitely be unjust – and certainly not in keeping with the essence of this program.

Despite the many unknown aspects regarding Death in Paradise’s latest Detective Inspector, it is clear that he merits an opportunity to thrive and make his mark.

2025-02-10 23:35

Why Mervin’s Critics Are Missing the Point in Death in Paradise

Read More