Teenager’s Twisted Experiment: What REALLY Happens in John and the Hole’s Chilling Ending?

by

In the 2021 psychological thriller directed by Pascual Sisto, titled “John and the Hole“, the audience is drawn into a chilling scenario where a 13-year-old boy drugs his family and confines them within an incomplete bunker to experience life as an adult. Without any guidance, regulations, or limitations, John (played by Charlie Shotwell) indulges in the unfettered freedom of adulthood for the first time. However, John’s actions are driven by motivations that extend beyond mere curiosity. Languishing in a shallow existence, John seemingly lacks direction and purpose in life.

1) John poses numerous questions, some rather peculiar, yet it’s his deepest wonder that comprehends adulthood. Bizarrely, John confines his family within a bunker hidden in the woods adjacent to their home, reveling in the liberty to indulge in his desires without restraint. Notably, the film’s title holds two interpretations at this point. Despite his youth, it is evident that John cannot fill the void in his existence, even with his newfound freedom. John and the Hole offers an uncommon narrative, concluding just as strangely and disquieting as its initial concept.

Why Does John Drug and Trap His Family?

John’s Pursuit of Freedom Endangers His Own Family

As a teen myself, I can’t help but dream of the carefree life that adults seem to lead. To me, it appears effortless and full of fun, with the grown-ups keeping their struggles and hardships hidden away. It seems like they can do whatever they please, eat whatever they want, without worrying about the consequences. The allure of this supposed freedom often tempts us teens to dabble in adult activities secretly, only to find ourselves in over our heads.

In the film “John and the Hole“, the central theme revolves around John, a teenager who’s exploring his twisted perception of adulthood through unconventional means. With his parents and elder sister out of sight, John indulges in whatever he pleases. He consumes junk food, drives the family car, withdraws money from their savings account, orders a large TV, and even invites a friend to join him for a swim in the pool. However, growing up turns out not to be as fun as John had imagined. As loneliness sets in, he yearns for his family back. After nearly a week, John is prepared to release them from the bunker, but can life ever return to its pre-incident state — or could it?

John’s Parents Want to See the Best in Their Son

Brad and Anna Don’t Want to Believe He Trapped Them

By the point when John desires his family once more, he has kept them confined within a bunker where another intense situation unfolds. His father Brad, portrayed by , has come close to insanity due to realizing the true meaning of hunger. John’s sister Laurie, acted by Taissa Farmiga, quickly figured out that it was John who had drugged and lowered them into the concrete shelter. Nevertheless, their parents remain optimistic about the situation. Even as the truth becomes evident, John’s mother, Anna (Jennifer Ehle), is still more concerned with her son’s welfare than her own. The family almost gives up on surviving within the bunker when John lowers a ladder for them — however, upon exiting the bunker, John himself is nowhere to be found.

Upon returning home, John’s family finds him face-down in the pool. Brad, fearing for John’s safety, jumps in to find him unharmed. At that moment, it would have been appropriate to question John about his actions. Yet, they don’t. Instead, they remain silent, relieved but not reprimanding. The scene shifts to them sitting at the dinner table as if nothing out of the ordinary has occurred. Once more, there is no conversation.

Is John Suffering from a Mental Illness?

John’s Mental State Is Open to Interpretation

So far, Pascual Sisto hasn’t provided any definitive analysis or formal diagnosis regarding John’s unusual actions, but many people, including critics and viewers, have developed their own interpretations. They generally believe that John shows clear signs of a mental health issue. Some label him as a sociopath, while others suggest he exhibits psychopathic traits. A few even speculate that he could become a serial killer in the future. However, these are informal assessments. It’s evident that John is displaying some symptoms indicative of a significant psychological disruption.

I compared John’s actions to those of real-life children who have perpetrated heinous acts, such as school shootings, for instance. Sisto concurred that John exhibited concerning behaviors, expressing, “We often felt that, yes, John could potentially be a school shooter. He might have ended up in some tragic news story like that — of course, what he did was still horrific, but it could have led to a more devastating outcome. Yet, we always wished to say, What if this is a story about a character who doesn’t commit such acts, but struggles with the same issues and problems that are prevalent in so many other children?

It’s uncertain if John won’t continue to commit heinous acts in the future, given his psychotic behavior towards his family. What makes this story chilling is not just John’s actions, but how the adults fail to address them appropriately. Essentially, John escapes punishment for his wrongdoings, implying that grown-ups can act however they wish, even when their actions are deeply immoral, without facing any repercussions. The idyllic image of adulthood that teenagers envision becomes eerily real.

John and the Hole’s Ending Reaffirms the Film’s Dark Tone

The Return to Normal Life Has Never Looked So Dark

In my perspective, one intriguing aspect of “John and the Hole” lies in its enigmatic nature. The movie leaves several questions unanswered, such as the reason behind John’s act of trapping his family in the hole. Was it a temporary escape to indulge in personal desires or was it fueled by some underlying anger towards them? Or could there have been something deeper and more complex driving him that we haven’t yet fully grasped?

The puzzling aspects of John’s story, as depicted in “The Hole,” are the family’s refusal to discuss the incident and the fact that John escaped punishment. It’s possible they understood their contribution to John’s actions, or they felt compassion for him after finding him in the pool, fearing he might be dead. Could there have been a complex family dynamic that made ignoring the event more appealing than addressing it? Or did the family believe that remaining silent was better than trying to comprehend why John behaved as he did?

The family’s silence on the matter is quite alarming if it suggests that they prioritize maintaining a facade of normality over addressing John’s obvious problems and modifying his behavior. This could explain why John resorted to drugging them and imprisoning them in the bunker. It seems that the family’s emotional detachment may have driven John to seek independence prematurely, making the movie even more unsettling because it implies shared blame among multiple parties, leaving viewers with few prospects for redemption.

John Is Best Understood in Contrast to Lily

John and the Hole Is a Kind of Fable

In the movie, Lily is a character who appears beyond John’s timeframe. She is first introduced approximately 30 minutes into the film, and it becomes evident that the narrative unfolding for John serves as the bedtime tale that Lily’s mother Gloria tells Lily. The audience learns only that Lily never leaves her room. As the movie ends, Gloria informs Lily that she is departing, leaving behind enough funds to sustain Lily for a year. However, after this period, Lily must fend for herself.

There are multiple perspectives on this particular scene, but if John’s parents are deemed unresponsive to his troubling journey into adulthood, some argue that Lily’s mother might have prepared her for survival instead. However, Gloria’s actions in placing her daughter in a ‘survival of the fittest’ scenario can hardly be justified as the behavior of a caring parent. While helping a child to spread their wings is beneficial, leaving a 12-year-old like Lily was never acceptable. Those seeking a model of compassionate parenting will have to find it elsewhere. In essence, this discussion revolves more around the audience’s view of Lily rather than John.

Initially, the movie’s mysterious and fairy-tale-like ambiguity becomes significantly significant. What lesson is Lily meant to learn from this? Is it more beneficial to be loved and then abandoned rather than being pampered and neglected? If so, one might ponder “In what world are these the only options?” Maybe they aren’t choices at all. Fundamentally, the ending of John and the Hole seems to imply that parenting through silence is as uncaring as not parenting at all. The viewers are led to contemplate that both situations lead to the same outcomes.

What Really Happens at the End of John and the Hole?

John and the Hole’s Ending Could Be Interpreted In Different Ways

The movie titled “John and the Hole” leaves many viewers pondering its meaning after the credits finish rolling, sparking discussions among fans since it was first shown. In the closing dinner scene, the family sits in quiet tension around a table without discussing the harrowing experiences they endured due to John’s actions in the titular hole. One possible reading of this scene is that the family has become so traumatized from their ordeal that they can’t bring themselves to speak about it. This interpretation seems most straightforward, as it suggests that the events portrayed in the film are accurate. However, some viewers propose alternative interpretations for what the final scene of “John and the Hole” truly signifies.

In simpler terms, some people believe that John’s family not speaking about the events of the movie in the final scene suggests that the entire story might have been just in John’s mind. This could mean that John made up the whole situation as a way to deal with his stress and discomfort. If this is true, it would imply that John didn’t actually change or improve during the film, but instead continued to live a miserable life without any hope for change. No matter what the actual interpretation of the ending of ‘John and the Hole’ is, it’s definitely a troubling one for viewers.

The Movie’s Symbolism Highlights John’s Emotional Void

John’s Character Arc Is Comparable to Jamie in Adolescence

Netflix’s “Adolescence” explores the challenges that teenagers encounter in the 2020s, including a young teenager’s journey toward self-acceptance. In contrast, “John and the Hole” uses symbolism extensively. The main symbol is the hole itself, which represents the emotional emptiness within John. This allegory aligns perfectly with the bunker, implying that John isolates himself emotionally from his family before venturing into his adult experiences.

In numerous films focusing on childhood and youth, young characters often endure trauma which significantly influences their future paths. However, the specific nature of John’s traumatic past, if he indeed has one, remains unexplored in the movie. It seems the creators rely on viewers to assume that John grew up in a neglectful environment, an assumption with some basis. Simultaneously, John’s emotional void could represent a lack of empathy, similar to Jamie Miller from the film ‘Adolescence’. Like John, Jamie rebels against his parents, and his violent act against a female classmate might have been an attempt to assert control over a world he perceived as threatening.

Jaime Miller’s radicalization online mirrors that of many teenagers offline, but John’s lack of interest is shrouded in mystery. It’s crucial to acknowledge that parents play a part in their children’s conduct, as they should instill good values and apply discipline when needed. The parents in ‘Adolescence’ deeply lament their failure to grasp the extent of Jaime’s radicalization, while those in ‘John and the Hole’ are puzzlingly unresponsive. This apathy could signify suburban nihilism, a theme expertly portrayed in Sam Mendes’ ‘American Beauty’. When parents are oblivious or indifferent, they can’t be shocked when their child seeks to defy them.

Read More

2025-04-18 01:23