8 Gritty & Underrated Crime Movies From The 1990s

In the realm of discussions about the crime genre, films belonging to this category are frequently characterized as raw, authentic, and unyielding, particularly those produced during the 1990s. Given that the ’90s was a decade brimming with some exceptional crime thrillers and dramas, it’s hardly shocking that numerous movies from this era have slipped through the cracks of memory and aren’t as widely recognized today. Yet, one of the joys of these overlooked films lies in their discovery by viewers for the first time today, immersing themselves in the excitement and mystery woven into their narratives.

Here are some lesser-known films from the ’90s that have garnered a cult following and could benefit from a modern remake. These movies often star well-known actors who take on roles that challenge their usual acting range, sometimes deviating from their typical characters or embracing familiar archetypes. The dedication of these actors to their roles is crucial, as they help maintain the story’s authenticity when it delves into the dramatic excesses of exaggerated plotlines.

8. Carlito’s Way (1993)

Directed by Brian De Palma

In the 1990s, many outstanding crime thrillers had well-known actors because they frequently play similar roles within that genre. This is why it’s not surprising to find acting legends like Al Pacino in the lead role of Carlito’s Way. However, this film is often overlooked in both Pacino’s filmography and the crime thriller genre as a whole. It takes place in 1970s New York City, where Pacino portrays Carlito, a former criminal who finds himself entangled in a labyrinth of deceit and betrayal after being released from prison.

While Al Pacino delivers an exceptional performance in “Carlito’s Way,” it’s possible to contend that his past roles resembling this one may have negatively affected its initial impact and lasting appeal. Nevertheless, Brian De Palma’s direction and the stellar supporting acts by Sean Penn and John Leguizamo make the film a compelling watch even today. Rooted in timeless crime genre tropes and the raw energy of New York City during that period, “Carlito’s Way” continues to captivate audiences right up until the final scene.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Carlito’s Way (1993) 84% 91%

7. King Of New York (1990)

Directed by Abel Ferrara

In addition to its memorable cast, “King of New York” stands out as a must-see ’90s thriller due to its many lasting qualities. The film’s main characters, portrayed by Christopher Walken and Laurence Fishburne as Frank and Jimmy, form the core of an impressive ensemble. Their roles depict them as a drug kingpin (Frank) and his closest confidant (Jimmy), who are on a ruthless mission to control the illicit drug trade in New York City. Along their treacherous path to power, they endanger countless lives, making this gripping story one worth revisiting.

In numerous films, Christopher Walken portrays a crime boss, but “King of New York” stands out as one of the finest, showcasing Walken’s acting prowess. This film offers a grand and suspenseful tale that grips viewers from the very start. Despite moments in “King of New York” that strain credulity, it remains captivating to follow the characters as they clash on the streets and experience how the movie vividly recreates the mood of 1990s New York City.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
King of New York (1990) 73% 77%

6. New Jack City (1991)

Directed by Mario Van Peebles

Renowned actor-filmmaker Mario Van Peebles breathes life into the tale of “New Jack City,” a gripping drama featuring an esteemed cast led by Wesley Snipes, Ice-T, and Chris Rock. This captivating story unfolds in the bustling backdrop of New York City, where it sheds light on the devastating effects of the crack epidemic on predominantly African American communities through the perspectives of a ruthless drug lord, Nino (Snipes), and a dedicated NYPD detective, Scotty (Ice-T). “New Jack City” delicately handles complex themes that contribute to drug issues without romanticizing them.

Generally speaking, the movie “New Jack City” is effective, stirring powerful feelings in viewers as they witness characters succumb to forces beyond their grasp. The acting in “New Jack City” further anchors the plot and underscores the film’s gravity. Re-watching “New Jack City” today highlights its timeless appeal and sheds light on a facet of crime narratives that is frequently underestimated within the genre.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
New Jack City (1991) 81% 80%

5. The Long Kiss Goodnight (1996)

Directed by Renny Harlin

In “The Long Kiss Goodnight,” starring Geena Davis and Samuel L. Jackson, we find an action-packed espionage thriller filled with unexpected plot twists. Despite its somewhat unconventional premise, the film offers a thrilling ride as it unfolds its explosive narrative revelations. As the story develops, Davis’s character gradually uncovers her own identity as a CIA operative suffering from amnesia, which sends her spiraling into a dangerous world of violence and secrets.

Thankfully, you can easily get engrossed in the narrative and enjoy the ride as Davis portrays an action-packed heroine. Jackson, on the other hand, plays a private investigator who becomes entangled in the perilous mission of the story. Both actors seem to relish their roles, creating a dynamic chemistry that propels the movie forward, even during its quiet scenes. Despite not having a profound message, the film’s style is captivating enough on its own.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
The Long Kiss Goodnight (1996) 68% 70%

4. Hard Eight (1996)

Directed by Paul Thomas Anderson

Despite not being widely recognized, Hard Eight stands out as one of Paul Thomas Anderson’s less-known films. It’s surprising given its impressive ensemble cast, many of whom are frequent collaborators of his, and its status as one of his first feature-length projects. While it may lack the polish of his later work, it offers a unique opportunity to witness the emerging elements of his distinctive style in their formative stages.

Nestled within the gambling scene of Nevada’s desolate landscape, the film Hard Eight follows its characters as they sink further into a quagmire of criminal activities and financial obligations. Although the storyline and themes may echo those found in other films, Hard Eight stands out due to its compelling characters and Anderson’s masterful use of the setting. The atmosphere, message, and purpose behind Hard Eight are all unmistakable, which is more than can be said for some thrillers.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Hard Eight (1996) 82% 83%

3. Copycat (1995)

Directed by Jon Amiel

In the film named “Copycat“, which combines elements of horror and thriller, we follow a series of murders committed by a sinister serial killer. This villain patterned his crimes on infamous killers from the past. An ensemble cast, including Sigourney Weaver, Holly Hunter, and Dermot Mulroney, unite to apprehend him. The narrative delves into the themes of violence against women and the influence that media has on violent crime. A significant focus is placed on the dynamic between Helen (Weaver) and M.J. (Hunter), as they collaborate to crack the case.

Watching “Copycat” isn’t always a breeze due to the grueling psychological and physical torment that the characters endure, which affects their detective work. Yet, “Copycat” delivers a fulfilling conclusion that’s not as bleak as some of its darker narrative threads. Since its debut, “Copycat” has garnered consistent acclaim for its portrayal of a female duo in roles typically occupied by men, offering a fresh perspective and enhancing the representation of women on screen.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Copycat (1995) 76% 64%

2. Sonatine (1993)

Directed by Takeshi Kitano

Despite not being as widely recognized as some other ’90s crime films, “Sonatine” significantly contributed to the evolution of the genre and warrants more attention. Notably, Takeshi Kitano, who both wrote and directed the film, portrayed Murakawa, the main character. As the narrative progresses in “Sonatine”, Murakawa, a member of the yakuza, grapples with feeling out of place in his lifestyle, and as events unfold, he and his team must take refuge by the sea following a botched job. His suspicions grow that the boss may be involved in the predicament.

Despite numerous tranquil scenes in the movie “Sonatine,” these moments serve to heighten the tension and anticipation for the ensuing violence and intensity portrayed onscreen. Unlike many 1990s Western gangster and organized crime films, which were predictable and adhered to familiar tropes, “Sonatine” stands out by being moody and reflective, exploring the significance or absence of meaning in criminal activities. Murakawa is a fitting protagonist for the narrative, as he has grown distant from his role in this world, yet feels drawn to complete the storyline.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Sonatine (1993) 93% 89%

1. A Simple Plan (1998)

Directed by Sam Raimi

Despite being directed by Sam Raimi and starring Billy Bob Thornton and Bill Paxton, the film ‘A Simple Plan’ tends to be underestimated. It bears a resemblance to classic neo-noirs such as ‘Fargo’, and its plot revolves around the escalating turmoil and violence that ensue when three individuals stumble upon a downed plane loaded with millions of dollars. As one would expect, their initial excitement quickly turns sour as they find themselves entangled in a web of lies and are forced to take drastic actions to protect their secret, driven by an insatiable greed.

With a rich blend of dark humor and a backdrop of a harsh Minnesota winter, “A Simple Plan” unfolds a taut, intricate plot that grips viewers as events unfold. Although there are comical instances, this film distinguishes itself from other Coen Brothers’ works by delving deeply into the underlying sorrow at its core. The most heart-wrenching aspect of “A Simple Plan” lies not solely in the criminal elements but in how the characters betray each other so readily due to their lives being dominated by money.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
A Simple Plan (1998) 91% 81%

Read More

2025-04-19 19:00