5 Justice League Heroes the DC Movies Totally Butchered

by

As a passionate cinephile, I must admit that live-action adaptations of DC Comics characters are not always perfection. Just like any other genre, they’ve got their high points and low ones. We can’t expect every film to be on par with masterpieces like “The Dark Knight,” “The Suicide Squad,” or Christopher Reeve’s initial two “Superman” movies. Regrettably, some less-than-stellar productions are bound to surface. Among these creative misfires, there are titles that squandered characters synonymous with the classic “Justice League” comics. In those comics, imagination and creativity were on full display. However, when brought to life on the big screen, these characters often lacked the same flair or fun that made them beloved in the comic books.

It’s truly unfortunate that the impactful legacy of Justice League comics is tarnished by certain adaptations in live-action DC Comics films. Specifically, five key elements from the Justice League were diminished or distorted in these productions. Unfortunately, not every movie can reach the quality of Shazam! or Wonder Woman.

Barry Allen/The Flash

In the comics, Barry Allen, also known as The Flash, was initially a key member of the Justice League, boasting immense potential for a compelling movie character. However, the first live-action portrayal of this character, played by Ezra Miller, unfortunately turned into a misstep rather than a success. The decision to make this version of Allen overly witty and annoying (due to him being the youngest member of the Justice League) didn’t resonate as intended in the final product.

The intriguing visual and narrative possibilities tied to his powerset were seldom utilized across his appearances within the DC Extended Universe. Consequently, films such as “Justice League” and “The Flash” failed to deliver a satisfying portrayal of this Justice League mainstay, offering instead a rather simplistic depiction.

Barbara Minerva/Cheetah

In a different scenario, Wonder Woman’s adversary Barbara Minerva, also known as Cheetah, had the potential to shine on the big screen. Regrettably, the portrayal of Minerva/Cheetah in “Wonder Woman 1984” turned out to be a puzzling fiasco. The decision to keep her in human form for nearly the entire film, only transforming during the final scene, was a significant misstep. Moreover, Kristen Wiig’s portrayal (an excellent choice for the role on paper) made it challenging to connect with Minerva as either a humorous antagonist or an engaging character. Essentially, this version of Cheetah lacked the fun and excitement that she typically embodies in the Justice League comics.

Steppenwolf

In the New 52 comics, the infamous New Gods character Steppenwolf transitioned into the main antagonist in the 2017 Justice League movie. Regardless of which version of Justice League you watched, Steppenwolf’s appearance deviated significantly from his vibrant comic book attire. Discarding such visual opportunities is undeniably a significant loss. Steppenwolf’s character design and persona in the film were generic compared to the extravagant appearances and impulsive nature of Steppenwolf in the comics. In the comics, even when Steppenwolf served as Darkseid’s lackey, he left a lasting impact. However, in Justice League, his potential was squandered in favor of muted colors and excessive growling.

Hal Jordan/Green Lantern

In a less than flattering portrayal, even among the founding members of the Justice League, Green Lantern’s on-screen debut was particularly disappointing. The 2011 solo film “Green Lantern” is still remembered for all the wrong reasons. While the movie had numerous flaws, Hal Jordan’s character was especially unsatisfying. The creators missed a golden opportunity to explore the intriguing cosmic aspects of the Green Lantern lore, instead focusing on dull Earth-bound storylines. It’s no surprise that Ryan Reynolds continues to poke fun at “Green Lantern,” given its significant impact on the comic book version of a key Justice League member.

Clark Kent/Superman

The idea of taking a more brooding path for DC Extended Universe’s Clark Kent/Superman wasn’t necessarily flawed, serving as a means to distinguish this portrayal from previous Supermen in popular culture. However, the manifestations of Henry Cavill’s Superman starting with 2013’s “Man of Steel” failed to deliver on many levels, going beyond just the visual themes of the movies. For instance, a superficial treatment of Superman’s mythology was deeply unsatisfying. The intriguing, quirky aspects of his backstory were largely ignored.

To put it mildly, the portrayal of Superman in this particular version was bound to face issues due to Cavill’s casting. His performance as Superman lacked the captivating appeal that keeps viewers hooked, and he didn’t seem to radiate much charisma. It was challenging for Cavill to convey a sense of warm humanity or introduce a unique, darker aspect exclusive to the DCEU’s interpretation of the DC hero. The textures of his Superman costumes, which varied significantly, are symbolic of this version of the character being flawed in every minor detail. Kudos to Zack Snyder and his team for attempting something fresh with such a well-known character. Unfortunately, Cavill’s portrayal of Superman tarnished an essential element of the Justice League comics in numerous ways.

Read More

2025-04-20 19:16