The Watcher Season 2 Must Keep Its Biggest Mystery Unsolved to Succeed

by

The first season of “The Watcher” concluded rather enigmatically after seven instalments filled with speculation and uncertainty, leaving me eagerly anticipating the next chapter of this Netflix series. Despite not being one of the top shows on Netflix, it seems that the initial season managed to captivate viewers enough to merit a second season. Although the production team has confirmed “The Watcher” season 2, there’s been scant progress since the finale in October 2022, leaving us uncertain about what the new episodes will bring.

Although the enigmatic ending of Season 1 in “The Watcher” didn’t fully unravel the series’ main mystery, it wasn’t a mistake. Inspired by true events, the Ryan Murphy production has deliberately bent some rules to enhance the narrative. Interestingly, one crucial aspect of the finale in Season 1 was remarkably accurate to actual occurrences. Fervently hoping that Season 2 of “The Watcher” maintains this faithful aspect, as deviating from it might adversely affect the series.

The Watcher’s True Identity Needs To Remain Unknown In Season 2

Netflix must keep the mysterious stranger’s alter ego under wraps

Despite various opinions about who the main character in The Watcher is actually meant to represent, the first season ends without unveiling their true identity, which might feel disappointing. However, the ending of The Watcher season 1 aligns with reality since the real family behind the show never discovered who was posing a threat to them, and the case remains unsolved even today. Although some may argue that the series could have fabricated a different ending featuring a grand reveal, I’m glad it didn’t and I hope future seasons continue in this vein as well.

The purpose of The Watcher is to immerse the audience in the genuine emotions experienced by the family during their time, and the suspense about who was sending the letters plays a significant role in that immersion. Guessing at who it might have been is one of the main attractions of the show. Unveiling the answer would eliminate the mystery, which essentially forms the core of the series. Although discovering the identity of the watcher in season 2 could be satisfying, maintaining the enigma seems more fitting to preserve the essence of the show as a whole.

What The Watcher Season 2‘s Story Should Be

Netflix could make a follow-up or turn the show into an anthology series

In the first season of “The Watcher”, all available resources from the original case have been utilized. This leaves the Netflix series with numerous possibilities moving forward, as it is no longer tethered to real-world events and can craft its own unique narrative. However, the title “The Watcher” does restrict the show to specific types of narratives. For instance, season 2 could bring back the cast from season 1, allowing the Brannocks’ story to continue in their new residence. If this were the case, having the same family under the watchful eye (or a new watcher) could be intriguing but might feel repetitive or like revisiting old themes.

As a fan, I believe a fresh and engaging approach for The Watcher season 2 would be to transition entirely from the Brannocks and establish a new set of characters at the heart of each storyline. This transformation could make The Watcher into an intriguing crime anthology series, where every run of episodes unfolds a unique and self-contained narrative. There are likely numerous other cases like the one featured in season 1, but even if not, season 2 can always create its own compelling tale from scratch.

This method might imply that “The Watcher” season 2 may not be as dark due to being unanchored from real-life incidents, but its initial foundation in general could provide an original narrative with a unique sense of truthfulness. Since specifics about “The Watcher” season 2’s direction haven’t been disclosed yet, it’s challenging to predict the path the show will follow. However, having numerous possibilities to choose from is certainly advantageous.

Why The Watcher Season 2 Is Taking So Long

The delay is approaching 3 years long

It’s now been over two years since “The Watcher” season 1 concluded, and we’re still uncertain about when the series will return and what shape it will take. The announcement of a second season by Netflix took many by surprise for two key reasons:

Firstly, the show was initially marketed as a miniseries, implying that it would not extend beyond the original case which served as its source material.

Secondly, this uncertainty is further compounded by the fact that “The Watcher” season 1 didn’t receive favorable reviews from critics or viewers alike.

As a dedicated Netflix viewer, it seems they’re meticulously crafting season 2 of “The Watcher” to outshine its predecessor, despite the mixed reviews and impressive viewership numbers in season 1. Strangely enough, there doesn’t appear to be much communication from the platform regarding updates on the show’s cast, including Naomi Watts herself. In an interview with Entertainment Weekly back in 2024, she admitted, “I’m as clueless about the show’s future as you are; I can’t provide a definitive answer.

Contrastingly, executive producer Eric Newman has given a more enthusiastic (yet somewhat mysterious) statement regarding the potential second season of The Watcher. In an interview with Radio Times, Newman stated: “I can only say that we’re very thrilled about the possibility of another season of The Watcher. That’s all I’m allowed to say. I wish I could reveal more details, but unfortunately, I can’t“. Due to his focus on promoting Griselda at the time, Newman also mentioned that he was reluctant to delve deeper into the topic without his partners from the production of the first season of The Watcher present with him.

Read More

2025-04-23 05:50