Do Star Wars Fans Even Need to See the Original Rogue One Cut Anyway?

by

As a movie critic, I recall the intrigue and anticipation when Disney announced “Rogue One: A Star Wars Story.” For many, the prospect of a big-screen adventure outside the Skywalker Saga was met with a mix of excitement and apprehension – it had equal potential to be a massive hit or a flop. However, with a whopping box office collection exceeding $1 billion worldwide and 86% positive reviews from critics, all fears were swiftly put to rest as the film emerged victorious.

What left audiences scratching their heads, though, was the omission of some captivating scenes teased in promotional materials, which didn’t make it to the final cut. Since then, fans have speculated about the possibility of the original version seeing the light of day; yet, the more pressing question remains: is the release of that version truly necessary?

As a passionate film enthusiast, I’m proud to share that I was involved in the making of “Godzilla,” credited as its director under Gareth Edwards’ leadership. The script for this epic was penned by Chris Weitz, while the concept itself was developed by John Knoll and Gary Whitta. Interestingly, during the summer of 2016, just a couple of months before its December premiere, “Rogue One” underwent reshoots that were predominantly directed by Tony Gilroy. These reshoots were substantial enough for him to earn a writing credit on the adventure.

Both Gareth Edwards and Tony Gilroy confirm that reshoots took place, as they are common in major studio productions. However, there’s a bit of a disagreement regarding the extent to which these reshoots influenced the film’s overall structure.

In various previews and a montage specifically designed for Star Wars Celebration, viewers saw numerous exciting scenes. These ranged from Ben Mendelsohn’s character Director Krennic traversing a fiery battlefield to Rebels fleeing across a shore to Felicity Jones’s Jyn Erso facing off against a TIE Fighter. In essence, Rogue One hinted at numerous pulse-pounding moments. However, many of these scenes didn’t make it into the final film, and while trailers often show slightly altered shots or dialogue, the differences between the trailers and the movie feel more pronounced. As late as 2023, Edwards spoke about the reshoots, with Gilroy addressing the matter earlier this month. To sum up, although the cast, crew, and Lucasfilm have provided different accounts of the situation, no reports have discredited Edwards’s role in the project, which seems to contradict claims that he had to give up control to the studio.

Filmmakers have left their projects under various circumstances, ranging from amicable departures to contentious ones. For instance, in the distant galaxy, the movie ‘Rogue One’ was the first of many instances where creators parted ways with a project, such as Colin Trevorrow leaving ‘Star Wars: Episode IX’ before filming began, or Chris Miller and Phil Lord on ‘Solo: A Star Wars Story’ when production was almost complete. In the DC universe, Zack Snyder departed from ‘Justice League’ due to personal reasons, which led to Joss Whedon completing the filming, resulting in a less-than-favorable reception by critics. Similarly, David Ayer directed ‘Suicide Squad’, and although it was also met with negative reviews, he has been striving for over nine years now to share his original vision of the movie.

With movies like “Solo”, “Justice League”, and “Suicide Squad”, it’s clear that studio intervention can significantly impact film production. After years of hinting at his original “Justice League” vision, Zack Snyder was not only given the opportunity to release his original concept on HBO Max but also to shoot additional scenes. Although many dedicated DC fans praised the four-hour movie as epic, “Zack Snyder’s Justice League” still received 71% positive reviews from critics, a significant improvement over the theatrical version’s 39%, but not the transformative, overwhelming success some DC enthusiasts had expected. This shows that while studio intervention can be harmful in many situations, a Director’s Cut isn’t always superior to a theatrical release.

While Zack Snyder’s Justice League demonstrates that Director’s Cuts can sometimes surpass the original theatrical release, Rogue One stands out due to its unique production history. John Knoll, having worked on the 1997 Star Wars Special Edition and the prequels, shares a strong bond with Star Wars and George Lucas. The filmmaking process of Rogue One was collaborative; it involved John Knoll, Gary Whitta, Chris Weitz, and Gareth Edwards at different stages, with each contributing significantly to the final product. It’s challenging to pinpoint who had the most influence on the finished movie.

Moving from Peter Jackson’s “The Lord of the Rings” trilogy to Ridley Scott’s “Kingdom of Heaven” and James Cameron’s “Aliens,” numerous directors have had chances to share their original movie versions with viewers, often resulting in extended versions compared to what was initially shown in cinemas. However, these longer editions aren’t always preferred, as some audiences find the condensed versions more appealing. Filmmakers such as Scott and Francis Ford Coppola have revisited their works like “Blade Runner” and “Apocalypse Now,” respectively, to release Director’s Cuts and make further amendments. Occasionally, fans even debate that a Director’s Cut can negatively impact a film, as seen with Richard Kelly’s “Donnie Darko,” where many believe it provides answers that the initial release made enigmatic. The more opportunities a director has to modify their movie, the higher the chance these changes may not enhance the viewing experience.

One intriguing aspect of the making of “Rogue One” is that since its release, few significant details about how different the storyline might have been have come to light. Since none of the characters from “Rogue One” appeared in subsequent adventures, it’s reasonable to assume that the film’s narrative would always revolve around a group of rebels stealing the Death Star plans and ultimately sacrificing themselves to complete their mission. It’s impossible to determine whether earlier versions of this story arc were better than what we eventually saw, but given how compelling “Rogue One: A Star Wars Story” turned out to be, fans may want to abandon their quest for discoveries that could potentially tarnish the film’s reputation and legacy.

It can be challenging when a filmmaker’s vision is affected by studio interference, especially now that social media lets creatives share their thoughts and give peeks into what doesn’t make it to the big screen. However, in the case of Rogue One, the end product was both critically acclaimed and financially successful, leading to two captivating seasons of Star Wars: Andor. Unlike Rogue One, where Gareth Edwards served as the primary creative force, the development of this concept was collaborative throughout the process. Fans may forever ponder what the original Rogue One might have been like, but it’s more productive to appreciate the engrossing tale we ended up enjoying.

Read More

2025-04-27 22:11