Every Willem Dafoe A24 Movie, Ranked

by

Recently, Willem Dafoe featured in the recently released fantasy film by A24 titled “The Tale of Ochi“. While the movie has garnered positive reviews thus far, it might not be Dafoe’s finest collaboration with A24, a production company renowned for its independent dramas, offbeat comedies, and spine-chilling horror flicks. Dafoe’s acting career took off in the 1980s and has flourished since then. Some of his most impactful roles include portraying Jesus in Martin Scorsese’s “The Last Temptation of Christ ” and the Green Goblin in Sam Raimi’s “Spider-Man. “. It is worth mentioning that Dafoe has forged a robust bond with A24 over the years.

Starting from 2017, Joaquin Phoenix has starred in four movies produced by A24: “The Florida Project, At Eternity’s Gate, The Lighthouse, and The Legend of Ochi.” These movies differ significantly in terms of genre, subject matter, and style, but they all feature impressive set pieces and striking visual effects. Moreover, Phoenix delivers a significant impact on these narratives through his expressive acting and dedication to his roles. In my opinion, all four of these films are worth watching, but here’s how I would rank them from least favorite to favorite:

1. The Legend of Ochi
2. At Eternity’s Gate
3. The Florida Project
4. The Lighthouse

4. At Eternity’s Gate

The Final Years Of Vincent Van Gogh

A testament to Dafoe’s exceptional acting skills and A24’s impressive track record is evident in their “least” successful joint production, which is still an outstanding film. The movie, At Eternity’s Gate, released in 2018, features Dafoe portraying the troubled artist Vincent van Gogh during his final years in Arles, France. There, he painted the natural landscapes that would later become renowned masterpieces. Joining Dafoe in this film are Oscar Isaac, Mads Mikkelsen, and Rupert Friend. Upon its release, Dafoe received Academy Award, Golden Globe, and Critic’s Choice Award nominations for his exceptional performance as the artist.

At Eternity’s Gate” manages to be both beautiful and melancholic, yet it holds the distinction of having the lowest Rotten Tomatoes score among any Dafoe/A24 production at 79%. Despite boasting stunning visuals and exceptional performances, some critics argue that the film missed its mark. In essence, “At Eternity’s Gate” may have fallen short in evoking the intended emotional resonance. However, this movie remains a must-watch for fans of Joaquin Phoenix, A24 productions, or art enthusiasts.

3. The Legend Of Ochi

A Young Girl Befriends A Strange Creature

In 2025, Daniel Dafoe’s next highly-anticipated film produced by A24 is “The Legend of Ochi.” This captivating tale revolves around a young girl who has been warned against venturing out after sunset due to terrifying creatures known as ochi. However, when she unexpectedly encounters a baby ochi, she overcomes her fear and embarks on a journey to return it to its family. Daniel Dafoe portrays the character Maxim in this film, alongside Helena Zengel, Finn Wolfhard, and Emily Watson.

The film “The Legend of Ochi” is a contentious choice due to its contrasting reception. While it outscores “At Eternity’s Gate” with critics on Rotten Tomatoes, it falls short with the audience. From a critical standpoint, the movie presents an unusual, enchanting, and visually stunning fantasy world that leaves some questions unanswered. However, many viewers found it uninspired and dull. Despite its divisive nature, “The Legend of Ochi” remains a captivating piece of cinema for those who appreciate its unique charm.

2. The Lighthouse

Two Lighthouse Keepers Fall Into Insanity

The film “The Lighthouse,” released in 2019, is one of Dafoe’s most well-known movies. This horror movie features two lighthouse keepers who must maintain a lighthouse on an isolated island in the 1890s New England region. In addition to being cut off from society, the men encounter peculiar events and have a unique bond. Dafoe plays his part in this grim, black-and-white setting alongside Robert Pattinson, with direction by Robert Eggers.

As a cinephile, I must affirm that The Lighthouse, boasting a remarkable 90% on Rotten Tomatoes, undeniably ranks among Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe’s most captivating collaborations under the A24 label. This cinematic masterpiece stands out from the pack with its visually striking imagery that transcends conventional filmmaking of today, while the raw, unyielding performances of Dafoe and Pattinson leave no stone unturned.

The movie is a haunting, enigmatic journey that lingers long after the credits roll. Critics have hailed it as one of the best films of its kind due to its ability to make viewers feel as if they are losing their sanity alongside the protagonists. It’s a film that leaves an indelible mark, whether the impression is positive or negative.

1. The Florida Project

Young Girls Find Joy In A Colorful Yet Bleak World

Interestingly enough, Willem Dafoe’s debut project with A24 has proven to be his most outstanding – a 2017 drama titled “The Florida Project”. This film revolves around the life of a 6-year-old girl named Moonee, who resides in a motel situated near Disney World with her hard-pressed mother. Surrounded by other young girls, Moonee endeavors to make the most of her days, infusing them with joy and merriment, while the adults in her vicinity grapple with escalating problems. In this narrative, Dafoe portrays the compassionate manager of the motel, striving to shield Moonee from the harsh realities of life.

Experience the captivating and heartfelt journey of “The Florida Project”. Unlike other films from A24 which might appeal to a specific group or stray too far from the ordinary, this movie resonates with most viewers. It delves into themes such as the loss of innocence, the hidden shadows beneath appearances, and the enchantment of childhood. Essentially, “The Florida Project” is a masterful film that showcases Willem Dafoe at his finest. For more of Dafoe and A24, don’t miss “The Legend of Ochi” currently playing in theaters.

Read More

2025-04-30 22:28