Supernatural’s Saddest Dean Winchester Story That Fans Wish Had a Better Ending

by

The success of the supernatural TV show, Supernatural, was largely influenced by the emotional bond and chemistry shared by Sam (Jared Padalecki) and Dean Winchester (Jensen Ackles). Although viewers were initially drawn to the series for its action, adventure, and intricate storyline, it was the character-driven drama that truly set this show apart. Many episodes explored heavier, more serious themes, particularly regarding Dean’s character development. In contrast to Sam, Dean tends to conceal his emotions more readily, making it all the more poignant when he reveals them.

The most impactful solo episodes of Supernatural demonstrate that the series’ writers consistently excelled at stirring viewers’ emotions. Over a span of fifteen seasons, the creators of Supernatural were challenged to maintain originality and catch the audience off guard, particularly in the last season. While season 15 did contain some poignant instances, there have been criticisms that the emotional intensity of the show’s ending didn’t match the saddest episodes from earlier in the series. These particular episodes tend to stand out more than much of season 15.

Dean Winchester’s Memory Loss In Season 12 Is His Saddest Story Of The Entire Series

“Regarding Dean” Breathes New Life Into The Emotional Arcs Of The Characters

In the “Regarding Dean” episode of season 12, one of the most poignant scenes occurs as Dean Winchester experiences memory loss. Unlike previous instances where we confronted Dean’s demise, this episode delves deeper into the complexities surrounding a person’s soul and self-identity. By the conclusion of the episode, both Sam and the viewers start to realize that losing his memories could be a more tragic fate for Dean than death itself.

In “Regarding Dean,” the TV show Supernatural delivers one of its most poignant moments. This episode stands out because it powerfully portrays a heart-wrenching tale that resonates deeply with viewers. Unlike other devastating instances when Dean’s heart was shattered, such as in “Dark Side of the Moon” where he learns about Sam’s happiest memories that were lived without their family, this episode takes the emotional impact to another level. Here, we witness Dean losing essential aspects of his identity, something neither brother had experienced before. This profound loss is depicted masterfully, demonstrating the series’ exceptional understanding of its audience.

Title Rotten Tomatoes Critic Score Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Supernatural (2005–2020) 93% 73%

Supernatural’s Saddest Dean Storyline Makes Season 15’s Ending Problems More Noticeable

Season 15’s Flaws Become More Obvious After Watching “Regarding Dean”

Throughout their adventures on Supernatural, Sam and Dean have met their demise numerous times. Since the start of the show, life and death have always been at stake, and the series finale wasn’t the first instance where Dean confronted his morality directly. Given that the show explores themes about Heaven and Hell, it’s understandable that the concept of death could be flexible. However, there comes a point when the protagonists dying so frequently can become repetitive or less impactful, as was evident in the season 15 finale, “Carry On.

Season 15 of Supernatural was met with controversy right from the start, and ending such a cherished and long-lasting series isn’t without its difficulties. Yet, when contrasted to the emotional turmoil evoked by “Regarding Dean,” Dean’s death in “Carry On” falls flat, at best. In this episode, Dean perishes unexpectedly at the hands of a creature he could have easily vanquished, and he seemingly accepts his fate without protest, moving on, allowing Sam to live a more ordinary life. Despite some poignant scenes that follow, they don’t come close to the emotions stirred by “Regarding Dean.

Supernatural’s Series Ending Missed An Opportunity To Devastate Viewers

Unlike “Regarding Dean,” “Carry On” Doesn’t Leave As Much Of A Mark On The Audience

As a die-hard fan of all things cinematic, revisiting the “Regarding Dean” episode from Supernatural would be like experiencing it for the first time all over again – pure joy! Yet, the series finale didn’t leave as lasting an impression on me. I went into that final episode with high expectations, anticipating a deeply emotional farewell to such an iconic show. However, what I got wasn’t a chance to shed tears and mourn the end of this captivating tale, which has been a hallmark of fantasy television since 2005. If executed skillfully, “Carry On” could have been a finale that would go down in history as a masterpiece, instead of just another chapter in Supernatural’s legacy. It was a missed opportunity to create an ending worthy of this remarkable series.

In a nutshell, there are countless incredible episodes and seasons of the series Supernatural, and its disappointing finale doesn’t diminish my admiration for it. Despite having mixed feelings about the ending, I enjoyed the character reunions and full-circle moments depicted in “Carry On.” However, I was left feeling a bit let down by the finale as I believe the show had the potential to go further, considering its impressive performance in episodes such as “Regarding Dean.” It seemed that the memory loss plotline demonstrated that Supernatural could have strived for more in its final season.

Let’s Face It: Dean Winchester Deserved A More Positive Fate In Season 15

Dean Didn’t Have To Die For “Carry On” To Be A Memorable Finale

A significant criticism levied against ‘Carry On’ is that Dean’s sudden death in the final moments was unjust. Throughout the series, Dean indicates that his demise at the hands of a monster was predestined, but it feels unfair that Dean’s life ended prematurely while Sam gets to pursue his ambitions of growing old and starting a family. Given Dean’s character development over the course of the show, there seemed to be ample opportunity for him to achieve similar milestones.

In another scenario, even if Supernatural hadn’t preferred Dean to forego settling down, he could have persisted as a hunter and been present for Sam’s children’s lives. On one hand, it seems fitting that Dean should meet his end, given his long-standing brush with this fate. However, it would have been a refreshing twist to grant him the contented ending he deserved instead. Through thick and thin, Sam and Dean have given their all to protect the world and made countless sacrifices to save it. It would have brought me joy to see Dean enjoy the remainder of his life in Supernatural.

Read More

2025-05-04 02:50