Why Andor Didn’t Include Jyn Erso: The Secret Reason Revealed

by

In the wrap-up of Andor, while it skillfully utilized links to Rogue One and other Star Wars tales, it didn’t feature a longed-for cameo by Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso that many fans anticipated. Showrunner Tony Gilroy discussed this exclusion in a recent interview with Backstory Magazine, stating that he couldn’t find a way to incorporate Jyn without disrupting the well-crafted narrative we’re familiar with. Although some fans are disheartened, others praise Gilroy for avoiding inconsistencies, particularly given these stories take place during such a significant phase of the larger plotline.

During the creation of Season 2, following Season 1, I was meticulously considering all aspects. Felicity is an exceptional actress and a wonderful individual, and I was aware of the immense affection for her among fans who were eagerly requesting this development. If I could have devised a method that didn’t disrupt the existing balance, I believe Lucasfilm wouldn’t have objected.

The problem arose and remained during the writing process, Gilroy stated. “I could never… Once you begin it, what do you do with it? You have to see it through completely. Does it share some link with Saw, and then you delve into that, but then you retreat, and what does he say in Rogue One? It just didn’t come together.

Some viewers online expressed satisfaction with a brief appearance by Jyn Erso in Andor, unrelated to the storylines – merely a nod to where this narrative is heading. However, others contend that such an inclusion would have unnecessarily increased the budget and screen time, both of which were effectively utilized in Andor Season 2.

A Star Wars Story could cause problems because it features Jyn Erso, who isn’t meant to appear until later in the timeline. This is challenging since even characters like Saw Gerrera, who are close to her in the Rebellion, haven’t seen Jyn for a long time before the movie starts, making it tough to explain why she would be part of the prequel series.

Rogue One” is a precursor to the initial film in the Star Wars series, “A New Hope,” where the Rebels demolish the Death Star during the Battle of Yavin. This event serves as the foundation for the entire Star Wars timeline, with years being labeled as happening “before the Battle of Yavin – BBY” or “after the Battle of Yavin – ABY.” As this part of the story is closely examined and deeply cherished by fans, any discrepancies could have negatively impacted the reputation of both “Andor” and “Rogue One.

Luckily, Gilroy and his colleagues skillfully navigated their way through a difficult task, and Andor has quickly become one of the most highly regarded titles within the Star Wars collection. The entire series is currently available for streaming on Disney+, alongside Rogue One and the rest of the Star Wars catalog.

Read More

2025-05-18 19:39