We Loved Both of These Classic Sci-Fi Films (But They’re Pretty Much the Same Movie)

by

It’s quite frequent for movies produced during the same period to share similarities, either due to behind-the-scenes factors like corporate decisions, as demonstrated by the cases of Antz and A Bug’s Life, or because they explore similar themes or motifs. This tendency is particularly noticeable when the films belong to the same genre. Take for instance two popular sci-fi movies from the 90s and early 00s, Stargate and Atlantis: The Lost Empire. These films are remarkably similar in their storylines, and surprisingly, they aren’t discussed as such often. Although one movie was released before the other, it seems more plausible that they were simply exploring common sci-fi tropes and trends of the time.

In 1994, I watched a groundbreaking sci-fi film titled “Stargate” that sparked an entire TV series and spin-offs, becoming a massive success. A bit later, in 2001, I came across another Disney movie, “Atlantis: The Lost Empire,” which didn’t achieve the same level of success as “Stargate.” There are several reasons suggested for this difference, one being that Disney isn’t typically associated with the sci-fi genre. But let’s set aside the discussion about their varying fortunes; instead, let’s focus on their shared aspects. These two movies, despite their different outcomes, have a lot in common.

The Leading Characters Are the Same People

To put it simply, we can’t dispute that the main characters in these movies share striking similarities. They are exceptional yet misunderstood figures in their respective fields. Dr. Daniel Jackson, an Egyptologist and linguist, has unconventional views on ancient civilizations, while Milo Thatch is a cartographer and linguist who champions the legend of Atlantis. Both characters face rejection due to, or perhaps because of, their innovative ideas, being shunned for theories that seem too extraordinary to others.

In a similar vein, both Daniel and Milo are skilled in ancient languages, finding themselves recruited by significant military or exploratory entities, thrusting them into an impromptu expedition. Throughout this journey, they assume roles as interpreters and ethical guides for the team. Daniel quickly develops affinity towards the locals they encounter, to the point of unintentionally marrying one (an intricate tale). Similarly, Milo selflessly risks himself to protect the revived Atlanteans.

Ultimately, their stories unfold in an interesting manner. Both characters start as scholarly loners but transform into brave adventurers with kind souls, setting the stage for romantic elements. Daniel finds himself smitten with Sha’uri, whom he unintentionally weds. In contrast, Milo and Kida develop a friendship first, hinting at potential future romance.

Similar Plots & Core Elements

Let’s delve into the shared themes and elements between the movies Stargate and Atlantis: The Lost Empire. Notably, their openings bear a striking resemblance. In both instances, an academic figure is drawn in to provide guidance on an extraordinary predicament. This scenario serves to highlight the theories that set them apart within their respective fields. Subsequently, they are propelled into a prearranged journey orchestrated by an external group. Isn’t it fascinating how reality can sometimes mimic magic?

Moving forward, the tales revolve around the quest to locate or resurrect other societies. For Daniel, this journey is about unraveling the mysteries of what supposedly remains from the other side of the Stargate (little did he know that real inhabitants inhabit this planet later on). For Milo, his adventure kicks off with a dose of thrill, considering numerous dangers stand between him and Atlantis. Once discovered, he is instantly engrossed in their narrative.

Essentially, we find common ground in the themes they explore, as both narratives intertwine magic and mythology with science and technology, resulting in a unique blend that’s quite popular. This leads us to the next prevailing topic: their discoveries challenge traditional beliefs derived from legends. Lastly, both characters defy authority. For Daniel Jackson, it’s about stopping the Colonel (Jack O’Neil) from destroying the Stargate, while Milo is in a struggle to safeguard the essence of the Atlanteans. While these circumstances often lead to confrontations, they don’t always unfold as viewers anticipate.

A Fun Sci-Fi Romp Through Hidden Histories

By the close of the day, one might find themselves thinking that a significant amount of “Atlantis: The Lost Empire” bears resemblance to “Stargate”. Nevertheless, no definitive proof has surfaced to support this idea, so it’s wiser to consider the creative team as exploring similar themes instead of outright duplication.

I found it fascinating to see how differently each movie was received. For instance, Stargate was warmly embraced and performed well financially, paving the way for Stargate: SG-1 which in turn generated more stories. On the flip side, Atlantis: The Lost Empire underperformed at the box office, a disappointment considering its potential to expand the sci-fi genre in Disney films. This was partially due to strong competition from movies like Shrek that were still showing in theaters at the time.

We’re really happy that these two charming films are out there. Although we sometimes tease that they’re almost identical, the truth is, they’re among our all-time favorites. So, even though we might make light of their similarities, we’re not about to grumble.

You can watch the movie titled “Stargate” on either Pluto TV or Amazon Prime Video. As for “Atlantis: The Lost Empire”, you’ll find it streaming on Disney+.

Read More

2025-05-28 22:18