Why Roger Ebert Called This 1947 Noir Classic a Must-See Masterpiece!

by

The genre known as film noir delves into a dark examination of the human psyche, and Roger Ebert held a particular fondness for it when discussing a specific Robert Mitchum masterpiece. Gaining prominence following World War II, film noir combines distinctive visual aesthetics with intricate crime narratives involving morally complex characters. Derived from the German expressionist art movement in silent cinema, the term “film noir” translates to ‘black film’ in French. Contrasting earlier crime films, the classic era of film noir was marked by a pessimistic outlook, which contrasted sharply with the optimistic sentiments prevalent in the US during the late 1940s and early 1950s.

Although noir may seem predictable due to its well-known elements, it’s actually a versatile genre that has adapted remarkably over time. The original film noir era transformed into neo-noir, which in turn has birthed innovative concepts like tech-noir, as exemplified in movies such as Blade Runner. Despite superficial alterations, the fundamental aspects of noir have remained consistent since the 1940s. The underlying cynicism that defines this genre continues to captivate audiences, and it’s not an overstatement to say that a classic movie from 1947 encapsulated the essence of noir better than most subsequent films – a sentiment shared by the esteemed film critic Roger Ebert, who was indeed correct in his assessment.

Robert Mitchum’s Jeff Bailey Is The Perfect Film Noir Protagonist

Embodying The Tropes While Adding Something New As Well

In his 2004 critique on “Out of the Past“, the late Roger Ebert dedicated a significant portion of his article to praising the 1947 classic film. Notably, he gave special recognition to Robert Mitchum’s performance, whom Ebert considered his top-ranked actor. Mitchum portrays Jeff Bailey, an ex-private detective who is compelled by a former associate to resume work after he had previously betrayed him. As a result, Bailey is forced to abandon the peaceful lifestyle he had established and revisit the shady world he once left behind.

Among the iconic anti-heroes of film noir, Jeff Bailey stands out as the quintessential figure, blending classic tropes with unique nuances that set him apart from predecessors like Philip Marlowe and Sam Spade. Unlike these established tough-talking gumshoes, Bailey brings a witty humor to his tough-guy persona that seems genuine, contrasting the perceived insincerity of his pulp fiction counterparts. Moreover, while other characters exude a “do anything to stay alive” attitude, Bailey’s fatalistic demeanor presents a striking contrast.

Robert Mitchum’s five highest-rated movies include:

Movie Release Date Rotten Tomatoes Score
The Lusty Men 1952 100%
Pursued 1947 100%
Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo 1944 100%
The Friends of Eddie Coyle 1973 98%
El Dorado 1967 96%

A significant aspect of Bailey’s flawless portrayal is Robert Mitchum’s acting, yet the skillful creation of his character deserves equal recognition. Despite knowing that he’s being manipulated throughout the story, Bailey steps into a precarious situation without explaining his motivations. Deep within him, Bailey senses that his past mistakes would eventually catch up to him, and instead of resisting, he lets himself be pulled back into the dirty swamp from which he originated. Unlike many noir heroes, Mitchum’s Jeff Bailey seems to understand his fate from the very beginning.

Out Of The Past Is One Of The Best Film Noir Movies Ever Made

A Near-Perfect Movie That Captures The Soul Of Film Noir

The style known as film noir is uniquely American, and its surge in popularity following World War II wasn’t by chance or happenstance. “Out of the Past” earned its spot among other remarkable film noir productions because it flawlessly embodies the essence of the genre. Roger Ebert deemed it one of the greatest ever made, an opinion bolstered by hindsight. As time goes on, noir continues to prove timeless, but few manage to remain as relevant and captivating with each new decade.

As a passionate movie enthusiast, I must say that “Out of the Past” never fails to astonish and provoke me, despite cynicism being prevalent in today’s mainstream films. That’s because its cynicism isn’t confined to the gloomy recollections of the Great Depression and World War II; rather, it offers a profound exploration of the human condition as a whole. The protagonist, Jeff Bailey, finds himself ensnared in a self-destructive cycle, yet he struggles to muster the strength to break free. The narrative could be set in any era and still pack a punch, while its ingenious use of multiple flashbacks showcases a daring take on noir storytelling.

In a visual sense, “Out of the Past” is an exceptionally beautiful film that deviates from the common urban landscapes and shadowy backstreets often seen in other popular noir productions. Rather than relying on these familiar settings, it delves into the inner lives of its characters, using compact scenes to convey the complex relationships between them. Notably, Roger Ebert highlights a particularly intense encounter between Kirk Douglas’ character and Mitchum’s Bailey, commending the film for its nuanced use of visuals to depict the tumultuous emotions swirling within these men. Unlike most noir films, “Out of the Past” stands out by encouraging viewers to form their own interpretations.

Read More

2025-05-29 00:58