Silent Hill 2 Has Several Endings, But the Movie Needs to Use This One

by

The film “Back to Silent Hill” is working on bringing the story of “Silent Hill 2” to the big screen. Although this isn’t the first game in the series to get a movie adaptation, it’s a fan-loved title with rich content. However, the challenge lies in the fact that “Silent Hill 2” has multiple endings, some of which are meant to be humorous rather than serious. Most of these endings, though, provide plausible conclusions for protagonist James Sunderland’s journey. The movie might choose the ending that the writers deem most suitable for their adaptation or write a new ending specifically for this version. This decision could prove challenging to satisfy everyone, but I believe there’s one ending that would make a good choice for “Return to Silent Hill”.

After experiencing the games and their corresponding films, I’ve come to appreciate them while keeping my expectations low. They had to alter the game narratives to suit the main plot and context required by a movie within a limited timeframe. Consequently, they don’t perfectly mirror the games, but they deliver an acceptable horror movie experience. Given this understanding, Return to Silent Hill must choose a conclusion that appeals to both gamers and horror movie enthusiasts alike.

Return to Silent Hill Should Use the Leave Ending

Some conclusions can be discarded immediately due to various reasons. The ‘Dog’ ending could entertain players, yet it seems too far-fetched for practical application. The ‘Bliss’ ending, in which James gets trapped within a VHS tape, is another possibility that might not deliver a fulfilling climax for the film. Lastly, endings like ‘Rebirth’ and ‘Stillness’, though dark, are challenging because they demand extensive details and background information to maintain coherence.

As a die-hard gamer diving into the twisted world of Silent Hill 2, I must say that among the various endings this game offers, three are the ones you’ll likely stumble upon during your initial playthrough: Leave, In Water, and Maria. It’s safe to say these are the most frequently witnessed conclusions by players. Among them, the Leave ending is often considered the canonical one, and it’s arguably the happiest resolution you can achieve in this game. Given its familiarity among gamers, it could make for a fitting conclusion in Return to Silent Hill. Considering the heavy nature of the game’s content, wrapping up the movie with a slightly brighter note may provide viewers with some optimism regarding James’ future.

The Maria Ending Could Be Beautifully Thematic

In another perspective, one could justify that the Maria ending might be the most fitting conclusion for “Return to Silent Hill” if the creators aim for a more complex emotional resolution. To achieve this ending in the game, players must be vigilant and develop an affinity towards Maria throughout the narrative. This choice eventually results in battling Mary as the final boss, leading to James departing Silent Hill with Maria instead.

This conclusion carries an element of uncertainty. Contrasting with the ‘Leave’ ending, where it can be inferred that James raises Laura as his daughter and they lead a fairly good life after departing from Silent Hill, the ‘Maria’ ending is not so clear-cut. Instead, it leads one to presume that James and Maria may not experience a happy conclusion. The final scene hints at this when Maria coughs, and James suggests she should seek treatment for her cough.

If the filmmakers prefer a sadder outcome over a happier one, I find the concept of Maria’s ending intriguing. Coughing suggests that Maria, much like Mary she resembles, might develop a serious illness that could prove fatal. This tragic turn would see James experiencing another heartrending cycle of love and loss. It’s a mix of sweetness and sadness as James finds love in Maria, only to potentially lose her just as he did with Mary. The twist being, it may even involve him causing her death, adding an extra layer of drama to the movie’s ending.

Translating games into movies can be quite challenging due to the vast amount of content from the game needing to fit within a limited screen time. Adding to this complexity is the existence of multiple endings, as it becomes impossible to satisfy everyone when only one conclusion can be chosen. In my opinion, for the movie “Return to Silent Hill”, opting for either the Leave or Maria endings would be the wisest choice. These are among the most frequently achieved endings by players, and they provide a contrast between a hopeful ending and a tragic one. The final decision between these two outcomes depends on the desired tone that the movie’s writers aim to conclude with.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/new-return-to-silent-hill-movie-release-date/embed/#

Read More

2025-06-19 03:40