Every Fantastic Four Movie Ranked, Worst To Best

by

Over many years, the Fantastic Four, Marvel’s First Family, have faced a challenging path to successful live-action adaptation. Their stories on the big screen have often fallen short, with multiple attempts resulting in films that didn’t quite capture the essence of their unique blend of cosmic action, family dynamics, and scientific curiosity – elements that make the iconic comic book characters so beloved by fans. The resulting cinematic missteps have left a trail of disappointment for fans who have yearned for a movie that truly reflects Stan Lee and Jack Kirby’s original creations. The journey of these adaptations has been complex, marked by troubled productions, studio meddling, and creative misses. It isn’t all the fault of filmmakers, but rather, the history of these adaptations is a tangled web.

Titled “The Fantastic Four: First Steps“, this offering by Marvel Studios signals a shift, promising fans a cinematic experience that harks back to the space race era of the 1960s, thus delivering the retro-futuristic journey through time and space that audiences have longed for on the silver screen. With the heroes now officially joining the Marvel Cinematic Universe, it’s an opportune moment to revisit the team’s entire live-action cinematic history, ranking each film from the most disappointing to the one that finally nailed it perfectly.

5) Fantastic Four (2015)

Josh Trank’s 2015 remake of “Fantastic Four” is often cited as one of the poorest superhero movies ever produced, serving as a warning about studio intervention. To begin with, this film lacks the joy and accuracy that should be characteristic of its source material. Instead of an exciting family-oriented adventure, it delivers a cold and distant cast, weighed down by a dark atmosphere that feels more suited to a Cronenbergian horror film involving body alterations than a typical superhero blockbuster. Furthermore, the creation of “Fantastic Four” was notoriously problematic, and the final product reflects this turmoil, resulting in a fragmented and incomprehensible piece that bears the marks of hasty reshoots, such as Kate Mara’s memorable wig.

As a movie enthusiast, I found myself utterly disappointed with my experience watching “Fantastic Four.” The gifted actors, such as Miles Teller portraying Reed Richards and Michael B. Jordan as Johnny Storm, were seemingly underutilized due to a script devoid of substantial character growth.

The movie started off laboriously slow, and after what felt like an eternity, it leaped forward a year without any significant development or build-up. This hasty progression seemed to rush us straight into a chaotic finale against Doctor Doom, portrayed by Toby Kebbell, whose version of the villain was bewilderingly different from his comic book persona.

Originally an intriguing computer programmer named Victor Domashev, the character’s transformation into a generic CGI creature stripped him of any threatening or majestic qualities that should have been present in the character. The 2015 “Fantastic Four” was a catastrophic creative and financial failure that deservedly brought this adaptation to an end upon release, ensuring the franchise would lay dormant for another decade.

4) Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

2007’s “Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer” can be seen as a setback for the series. Although it attempted to incorporate cosmic aspects, the movie instead magnified the flaws of its precursor and failed to fully exploit its best ideas. The narrative reassembles the original team to combat a worldwide peril embodied by the Silver Surfer, who signals the approach of an apocalyptic force. Despite being visually stunning, especially with Laurence Fishburne providing his voice and Doug Jones portraying him on screen, the character of the Silver Surfer is confined within a film that is overly childish and oversimplified, unable to fully capture his complex nature.

The main flaw in Rise of the Silver Surfer lies in its portrayal of Galactus, which falls short of the powerful, humanoid character from the comics. Instead, it presents Galactus as an ordinary cosmic cloud, lacking menace. This weak creative decision reflects the movie’s overall unwillingness to capture the epic scale of its source material. The story is shallow, the humor is awkward, and the family relationships feel forced and unconvincing. Rise of the Silver Surfer had the potential for a grand cosmic tale, but it ended up creating a weak and forgettable adventure that repeated old mistakes, albeit less effectively.

3) The Fantastic Four

Prior to the high-budget adaptations we know today, Roger Corman, a renowned B-movie director, produced an early, low-budget version of Marvel’s First Family. This movie, titled “The Fantastic Four,” was never publicly released but has since gained legendary status in Hollywood lore. Made on a minuscule budget of $1 million, the film was primarily produced to secure the rights to the characters, a fact that was hidden from both cast and crew during production. Despite its meager budget and questionable origins, this unseen film possesses an endearing quality that later adaptations seem to lack, and surprisingly remains true to the original source material.

Today, watching bootleg copies of The Fantastic Four, one can’t deny its campy feel. Yet, its sincerity is its most powerful asset. Corman strived authentically to animate the Silver Age comics, from the characters to the iconic blue and black outfits. Moreover, the practical effects employed to create The Thing are remarkable for the budget, and Joseph Culp’s performance as Doctor Doom beautifully encapsulates the villain’s theatrical bravado. Consequently, The Fantastic Four becomes a captivating “what if” scenario, a heartfelt endeavor that, although made for legal reasons, somehow mirrored the comics’ essence in a way high-budget productions never managed. However, the limitations of the budget make it resemble a fan production at times, which can be somewhat disruptive.

2) Fantastic Four (2005)

The first major on-screen adaptation of Marvel’s original team, 2005’s “Fantastic Four,” stands out as the best among less-than-stellar adaptations. Directed by Tim Story, this lively and vibrant film enjoyed considerable commercial success, despite its imperfections. It effectively captures the essence of its characters, with its strongest asset being an exceptional cast. Chris Evans shines as the cocky yet endearing Johnny Storm, while Michael Chiklis brings a heartfelt depth to the tormented Ben Grimm, conveying raw emotions beneath layers of prosthetics. Their on-screen banter lends credibility to the film’s less convincing aspects, making “Fantastic Four” a watchable choice despite its shortcomings.

Despite having an engaging family dynamic, the movie “Fantastic Four” is hampered by a familiar origin storyline and a rather forgettable antagonist. Julian McMahon’s portrayal of Doctor Doom falls short, as he is depicted more as a pesky business adversary instead of the formidable Latverian king we expect. The action scenes are competent but lack originality, while the romance between Ioan Gruffudd’s Mr. Fantastic and Jessica Alba’s Invisible Woman feels lacking in chemistry. However, “Fantastic Four” manages to maintain a certain charm that makes it an enjoyable watch for superhero movie enthusiasts reminiscing about its nostalgic value.

1) The Fantastic Four: First Steps

First Steps”. Directed by Matt Shakman, this film showcases a lively journey that faithfully portrays the essence of the comics. Instead of retreading the familiar origin story, it presents a team that is well-established and self-assured in their roles as heroes and adventurers. The movie also boasts a retro-futuristic design, drawing heavily from the 1960s comic books, providing a distinctive and fashionable visual appeal that distinguishes it from other genre productions. Moreover, Pedro Pascal as Reed Richards and Vanessa Kirby as Sue Storm lead an ensemble cast with palpable chemistry, effectively embodying the loving family dynamic central to the team.

Title “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” offers a visual spectacle, boasting flawless special effects and an overwhelming sense of grandeur. This is particularly noticeable in the portrayal of Galactus (Ralph Ineson), who is now fearsomely depicted as intended, correcting past misrepresentations. Notably, Shakman, having previously directed WandaVision, lends a precise directorial touch to the production, blending thrilling action with substantial emotional depth while examining the personal toll of the team’s cosmic journeys. By capturing the essence of hope, positivity, and scientific curiosity that defines these characters, “The Fantastic Four: First Steps” delivers a cinematic interpretation that truly encapsulates these iconic superheroes.

https://comicbook.com/movies/news/vanessa-kirby-movies-and-tv-shows-to-watch-fantastic-four/embed/#

Read More

2025-07-25 02:10