Agatha All Along Showrunner Shocks Fans with Major Theory Confirmation!

by

The Disney+ show titled “Agatha All Along” has been a significant success for both the streaming service and the Marvel Cinematic Universe as a whole. Debuting in September, it swiftly garnered accolades from Marvel enthusiasts and critics alike, largely due to its representation of LGBTQIA+ themes, notably the stories of Billy Kaplan/Maximoff (Joe Locke) and the relationship between Agatha (Kathryn Hanh) and Rio/Death (Aubrey Plaza).

One intriguing fan theory about the series revolves around Agatha’s son, Nicholas Scratch. Although the series depicts Agatha giving birth, it never clarifies who Nicholas’ father might be. Instead, Agatha merely implies that she created her son “from scratch.

Due to some intriguing similarities between the actors playing Nicholas and Rio, and their interactions on the show, Marvel enthusiasts have speculated that Rio (the character personifying death) could be Nicholas’ father. This theory has gained traction among fans. However, showrunner Jac Schaeffer has now clarified the matter, providing a response that fans will undoubtedly find satisfying.

Nicholas Scratch’s Parentage Revealed

During a panel discussion at PaleyFest on March 22nd for the show “Agatha All Along,” Schaeffer and the cast shared insights about how viewers have responded to the series. Actress Sasheer Zamata, portraying Jennifer Kale, mentioned that her preferred fan theory is that “many believe Rio could be Nicholas’ mother.

During its creation, we encountered numerous inquiries, such as ‘Who is the father?’ To which we responded, ‘What’s your reason for asking?’ Schaeffer explained. This aspect mattered to the writers and resonated with me. It was heartening to hear that this detail sparked curiosity among fans, and we were able to confirm it later on.

At the panel discussion, the crowd burst into excited applause since Schaeffer had never publicly endorsed or refuted the theory until then. Earlier, Schaeffer tended to talk about it in secretive terms, saying that the filmmakers knew they chose an actor resembling Aubrey Plaza for Nicholas. Additionally, Schaeffer had previously acknowledged that Agatha and Rio were essentially married, which strengthened the idea that Nicholas originated from their relationship.

What Does This Mean for the Future of Agatha?

The fact that Nicholas is the offspring of a powerful witch and Death herself significantly impacts the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), paving the way for numerous intriguing storylines in the future. Although Schaeffer and the cast have debunked speculations about a second season of Agatha All Along, there is buzz that Agatha, Rio, and Billy could reappear in another series centered around Billy and Agatha’s mission to locate Billy’s twin brother, Tommy Maximoff.

Although the upcoming series might not directly be “Agatha All Along” Season 2, the plots introduced in “Agatha All Along” will likely have a substantial impact, as the finale showed Agatha and Billy teaming up to locate Tommy. Given that Rio aims to capture Billy’s soul because he deceitfully cheated death, it could be logical for her to perceive Tommy’s reincarnation in the same manner.

At the moment, enthusiasts will just need to be patient as we await an official announcement about a potential second season of Agatha All Along, a linked series, or a movie follow-up.

Read More

2025-03-23 23:41