American Horror Story: Asylum Is The Scariest Season, And It’s Not Even Close

These days, it can be challenging to come across compelling horror TV series as much attention is given to feature films within the genre. However, if anyone has mastered creating chilling television content, it’s none other than Ryan Murphy. Shows like “Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez” and “Grotesquerie,” which have received Emmy and Golden Globe nominations (and in some cases, wins), are proof of his talent. However, among all his productions, it’s safe to say that “American Horror Story,” co-created with Brad Falchuk, stands out as his magnum opus, having premiered back in 2011 and still captivating audiences today through its anthology format. As a result, fans often find themselves debating which storyline is the finest.

Among the twelve seasons, each offering unique stories, some truly shine due to their storylines, characters, or handling of social themes. Interestingly, this choice varies among fans, but it’s indisputable that many find Asylum, Season 2, to be a clear favorite.

What Makes Asylum the Best Season of American Horror Story?

Following the triumph of “Murder House”, “Asylum” significantly elevated “American Horror Story” into a captivating television show, demonstrating that viewers were eager for unique stories each season. To provide context, “Asylum” was the only season to receive a record-breaking 89 award nominations and it also took home an impressive 28 awards. On Rotten Tomatoes, it boasts a score of 84% with an audience approval rating of 90%. While the entire series is terrifyingly good, one might wonder how “Asylum” stacks up against the others. One key factor that sets it apart is its depth.

In the 1960s, I found myself immersed in a chilling tale unfolding at the Briarcliff Sanatorium, nestled in the Massachusetts countryside. As a movie enthusiast, this series took me on an unforgettable journey through a maze of macabre incidents and intricate character dynamics.

I followed Lana Winters, a tenacious journalist who was unjustly incarcerated, Kit Walker, a man falsely accused of being the Bloody Face killer, Sister Jude, a stern religious figure with a hidden past, and Dr. Arthur Arden, a doctor concealing unspeakable secrets. The narrative weaves through various themes such as mental stability, religion, misuse of power, scientific exploration, and supernatural occurrences.

Throughout the season, I witnessed these characters confront horrors that tested their morality and challenged the very fabric of reality itself. This gripping story left me pondering questions about sanity, faith, power, and the unknown.

American Horror Story regularly delves into societal problems, as evidenced by seasons such as Freak Show, Cult, and NYC. However, it was the season Asylum that stood out with a distinctive approach to this theme.

From a passionate film enthusiast’s perspective: In Asylum, I found the storyline compelling as it delves deep into the lives of characters who are often overlooked by society. Rather than relying on supernatural elements for suspense, this series exposes how institutions can prey upon and manipulate these marginalized individuals, turning the spotlight on a horror that is all too real – the cruel and oppressive actions perpetrated by those in power. It’s a chilling reminder of how systems can strip people of their humanity in the name of so-called morality or order, making viewers feel unsettled and empathetic towards situations that sadly still resonate in today’s world.

To pull off an engaging and suspenseful viewing experience that stays true to American Horror Story’s classic horror vibe, a delicate blend of genre and emotional drama was essential. The season managed to strike this balance perfectly, creating an emotional bond with the audience from start to finish. Furthermore, key scenes were meticulously designed to become memorable, such as Dr. Thredson’s revealing tale, Lana’s unjust detention at Briarcliff, and the chilling alien abduction in the premiere. Upon closer examination, the narrative is rich with intricate details that contribute to its reputation as a masterpiece, thanks to its skillful and clear development without causing confusion.

Additionally noteworthy is Jessica Lange’s portrayal of “The Name Game,” a truly astounding moment. However, the climax of Asylum, particularly Sister Jude’s poignant last words, “If you gaze upon evil, evil will gaze back at you,” outshines all else. This line encapsulates the show’s underlying message, highlighting that battling evil can inadvertently taint its adversaries. By blending emotional intensity with profound introspection on human nature, it significantly enhances the season, imparting a potent and enduring impact on viewers.

Even years after its release, Asylum is still capable of giving anyone goosebumps.

American Horror Story: Asylum Was Based on Real Events

In some instances, the tales from American Horror Story drew upon actual incidents, and Asylum was no exception. The setting of Briarcliff Manor mirrored Willowbrook State School, an institution for intellectually disabled children in New York. The events that unfolded within were indeed a harrowing ordeal. Operating from the 1940s to the late 1980s, it was overrun with filthy conditions, and the residents suffered from malnutrition and various forms of abuse. Additionally, during this period, there was a study where patients were deliberately exposed to the hepatitis A virus.

The characters were also derived from real-life figures. For instance, Lana resembles Nellie Bly, a journalist who embarked on an undercover assignment to expose and write about the appalling conditions in a Women’s Lunatic Asylum situated on Blackwell’s Island. Similarly, Kit and his wife Alma bear some resemblance to Betty and Barney Hill, a pair who claimed they were abducted by an alien spacecraft in 1961. Dr. Arthur Arden mirrors Josef Mengele, a doctor notorious for the atrocities committed during the Auschwitz concentration camp, where he conducted gruesome experiments leading to numerous deaths. On the other hand, Dr. Oliver Thredson reflects the infamous serial killer Ed Gein.

All seasons of American Horror Story are available to stream on Hulu.

Read More

2025-01-25 20:41