American Horror Story’s Most Underrated Season

Regarding the show “American Horror Story,” each season generally functions independently, but some, like “Hotel,” incorporate characters from previous seasons in brief appearances. On the other hand, “Apocalypse” offers a complete crossover before setting up a new direction for the series going forward. As we move towards Season 13 of American Horror Story, it’s worth noting that its most distinctive and arguably undervalued season took place before the reboot.

This season is referred to as Season 6, more commonly known as “American Horror Story: Roanoke.” What sets this season apart is its unique structure. A portion of “Roanoke” is presented as a documentary series chronicling a supernatural re-enactment program with an unusual backstory. The show itself incorporates footage from this fictional TV series, offering viewers a blend of two worlds. This multi-layered narrative device serves both as a tribute and a critique to re-enactment shows, as well as found footage films. It also subtly exposes the scripted, manipulative aspects of reality TV and the entertainment industry in general.

In addition to its distinctive theme, “American Horror Story: Roanoke” offers its actors, several of whom have portrayed various characters in the series before, a chance to deliver more authentic performances compared to previous seasons (mainly to maintain the appearance that this is a documentary). Unlike other seasons like “American Horror Story: 1984,” “American Horror Story: Roanoke” leans towards realism, even when supernatural elements are introduced. This makes it scarier, more disturbing, and uncomfortable than past seasons.

People usually watch “American Horror Story” for its horror elements, but this series also offers an intriguing plotline that resembles a soap opera due to its dramatic nature. The horror aspect is equally captivating. Specifically, “American Horror Story: Roanoke” delves into one of the oldest unsolved mysteries in the United States – the disappearance of the Roanoke colony. Notably, “American Horror Story” often blends real-life horrors and enigmas into its stories, as demonstrated by the inclusion of various real-life serial killers across different seasons. However, “Roanoke” is particularly intriguing because of the mystery surrounding it and the potential solutions suggested.

As a fan, I’ve noticed a striking difference between the chilling portrayal of Roanoke in the re-enactment show and the raw reality behind its production. The backstage experience is far more harrowing and spine-tingling, serving as a stark reminder that these true crime series aren’t just captivating stories to be immersed in. They’re deeply rooted in real-life tragedies that still echo today.

American Horror Story: Roanoke presents a unique, self-reflective perspective on real crime, television production, and the series itself, without resorting to overtly humorous or ironic elements. This sets it apart as a noteworthy example of meta television, offering a breath of fresh air in a genre that can sometimes lose its edge or become overly reliant on shock value. Despite being a shocking season, the shocks in Roanoke generally serve a purpose and feel integral to the storyline. Among the best seasons of American Horror Story, Roanoke is often underappreciated but stands out for its departure from typical expectations for the series, offering an unexpected take on what one might expect from American Horror Story.

Stream American Horror Story: Roanoke on Hulu.

Read More

2025-03-19 00:46