Bachelor Alum Caila Quinn Shuts Down Husband’s Cheating Rumors

by

Caila Quinn is setting the record straight.

A former Bachelor student, who competed on Ben Higgins’ season and later appeared on Bachelor in Paradise, addressed speculations about her husband Nick Burrello being unfaithful on various social media platforms.

One of the claims made was that Nick intended to attempt meeting a woman who remained unidentified, supposedly for a business trip. However, Caila swiftly refuted this assertion.

Caila expressed her confusion on April 16 via TikTok, accompanied by a laugh emoji, saying “What in the world is this…?” She clarified that what was being suggested wasn’t accurate and her husband doesn’t go on business trips. She emphasized that this was a jest and to disregard any rumors about her. In other words, this information is untrue.

Four years following their wedding in 2021 at the Ringling Museum of Art in Sarasola, Florida, rumors of infidelity have surfaced against Nick and Caila.

In that moment, Caila, who has two children, Teddi (age 2) and Christian (7 months), both fathered by Nick, expressed her joy on their special day.

She expressed on Instagram that no words could capture the enchantment of the day. She was touched by the love shown by their guests, the dedication of their skilled vendors, and the cherished moments with her partner. A big thank you goes out to everyone who played a part in making this extraordinary day happen! This special occasion will remain dear to our hearts forever!

On that special day, Caila chose to wear a strapless dress featuring a lacy bodice from Kleinfeld, while Nick opted for a sleek black tuxedo complete with a black bow tie from BALANI Custom Clothiers.

On the given event, Caila selected a strapless gown adorned with a delicate lace bodice from Kleinfeld, and Nick donned a stylish black tuxedo accessorized with a black bow tie from BALANI Custom Clothiers.

Initially, the plan was to have the wedding in Italy, but because of setbacks caused by the coronavirus pandemic, the wedding eventually took place in Florida instead.

For Caila and Nick, what mattered most wasn’t the location; rather, it was the opportunity for their dear ones to gather.

Caila shared with Us Weekly that it’s been a while since we’ve all gotten together, and many of her dear ones have stayed home for safety reasons, not going out at all in over a year. However, she’s thrilled that they are making an exception this time to attend her wedding with her fiancé. It really means something special to her that these people decided to travel to witness us finally saying ‘I do.’

In their own words, Caila expressed that she is more content than ever before, as she shared a collection of photos from the year, highlighting herself, Nick, and their two children. When reflecting on what she’s thankful for in 2024, she found it difficult to know where to start!

For more on where your favorite Bachelor Nation alums are in their love lives, keep reading.

Status: Engaged

 

On his initial night at the Bachelor mansion, Grant Ellis might have encountered 25 possible love matches; however, it was Juliana Pasquarosa, in the end, who received his final rose. As they prepare for their wedding, the soon-to-be bride shared her most important wish for their special day.

 

In her interview with TopMob News in March 2025, she emphasized that regardless of the location or appearance, it’s crucial that it’s filled with love and all family members are present. Her message was clear: as long as we’re together, we’ll make memories no matter what activities we engage in.

Status: Engaged

After making an impression on the inaugural season of “The Golden Bachelor” and leaving Gerry Turner’s season prematurely, Joan Vassos moved on to become the star of the first season of “The Golden Bachelorette”. It was during this show that she found her match in contestant Chock Chapple.

In the finale of “The Golden Bachelorette” held in November 2024, Joan expressed her optimism about love despite life’s challenges, stating, “Even at our age, there is still hope.” This was followed by Chock’s proposal in the enchanting locale of Bora Bora. Chock declared his affection with, “I waited until this special moment in this beautiful place to tell you that I love you and want to spend the rest of my life with you. I look forward to waking up next to you each morning and kissing you goodnight.

Status: Split

 

In the season finale of “The Bachelorette” (season 21), it appeared that former Bachelor contestant Jenn Tran was on her way to a happy ending with her final choice, Devin Strader. However, during “After the Final Rose” in September, Jenn, who is 26 years old, disclosed that Devin, aged 28, had turned cold towards her once the cameras were no longer rolling.

 

During the September 3rd show, Jenn explained to host Jesse Palmer that he had been expressing strong declarations of affection one day, only to be indifferent the next and deny any past feelings of love. She added that all the pledges and affection he had expressed towards her seemed to have vanished.

 

The events unfolded further as Devin posted a 13-minute video on Instagram, detailing his perspective and admitting fault (taking accountability) while also explaining the reasons behind ending the relationship during a 15-minute conversation over the phone.

 

Instead of Jenn claiming he ended their conversation abruptly in August, he stated that she pressed for answers about his feelings and he was trying to find a suitable moment to tell her in person.

 

He said, “To be honest, I wasn’t sure what other option I had,” indicating that he had been holding back to discuss it with her face-to-face. “In a way, she made me take action.

 

Ever since then, Jenn has strolled towards “Dancing with the Stars” and perhaps into the affections of her dance partner, Sasha Farber. They’ve been fueling romance speculation since their elimination on October 29th.

Status: Split

In November 2022, Greg Grippo, who was among Katie Thurston’s suitors on ‘The Bachelorette’ the previous year, appeared alongside Victoria Fuller in the finale of ‘Bachelor in Paradise’. During their time there, they declared that they were in a relationship. However, in April 2024, he disclosed that their relationship had ended.

Prior to Victoria Fuller and Greg Grippo confirming their relationship during the finale of Bachelor in Paradise’s 8th season, Victoria Fuller had previously ended her engagement with her fellow cast member, Johnny DePhillipo.

Status: Divorced

Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist became engaged in November 2023, during the final episode of the first season of ‘Golden Bachelor’, and they officially wed in a live television wedding ceremony in January 2024.

However, three months after their nuptials, the couple announced that they were breaking up.

During our recent sit-down on Good Morning America with my partner, Theresa, we’ve both taken a deep introspective look at our life together and our living arrangements. After careful consideration, we’ve arrived at the shared decision that it seems appropriate for us to part ways in the next stage of our lives, which unfortunately means dissolving our marriage.

They reached a divorce settlement in June 2024, according to court records reviewed by TopMob News.

By April 2025, Gerry disclosed on the “Bachelor Happy Hour” podcast that he had started seeing someone new, and things were progressing positively for him.

Status: In a committed relationship
Tennis pro Joey Graziadei, after considering 32 potential partners, found his ideal partner in project manager Kelsey Anderson. Overwhelmed with joy, he expressed to his chosen one during the March 2024 finale, “I’ve been longing to tell you for so long that I love you.” As he got down on one knee, he confessed, “There’s something about you that captivates me. You possess an infectious enthusiasm that always brings a smile to my face. It’s a sensation I’ve never experienced before.” Dreaming of their future together, he added, “For a while, I’ve known that I wanted a wonderful life, but I truly didn’t realize just how wonderful it could be until I met you.

Despite not initially connecting until halfway through season nine of “Bachelor in Paradise”, John Henry Spurlock (one of Charity Lawson’s suitors) and Kat Izzo (a contestant vying for Zach Shallcross’ heart) decided to take a chance. As he presented an Ascher cut Neil Lane diamond, John Henry expressed his feelings, saying, “I’m going to try something different today. My heart is telling me that you are amazing, you are everything I’ve been searching for.” However, just after the season finale, they announced that their paths were diverging due to conflicting career aspirations. In a joint Instagram post, they thanked their families, friends, and “Bachelor Nation” for their love and support, stating, “Unfortunately, our careers are taking us in different directions.

In the end, despite her apprehensions about a romantic event, elegantly dressed Eliza Isichei (one of Clayton Echard’s former partners) gracefully accepted Aaron Bryant’s proposal on the shoreline. Moved by Aaron’s gesture of seeking approval from her mother, she expressed, “I couldn’t predict what words would come out of my mouth.”

The final episode’s conclusion hinted at a few hurdles Eliza faced after their trip to Mexico, and shortly afterwards, they made it official that they had called off their engagement. On December 2023, Aaron posted on Instagram, “Navigating the complex feelings as events unfold. We are managing our amicable separation with nothing but goodwill and mutual respect for each other.

Status: Divorced

Nurse Kylee Russell initially regretted boyfriend Aven Jones’ reluctance to propose traditionally – an action he apparently planned during his courtship of Bachelorette Rachel Recchia. However, she eventually agreed to Aven’s Paradise proposal, stating they needed to leave and try to make things work. This decision meant her chosen engagement dress remained untouched, as she felt compelled to do what she believed was correct. “Love is about taking risks,” she explained.

Two days following their December 2023 finale, Kylee revealed on Instagram Stories that their relationship had fallen apart due to numerous instances of infidelity. Aven later extended an apology to Kylee, admitting, “I have made serious errors in our relationship and caused pain to someone very dear to me.

Charity Lawson expressed her satisfaction with the current season and hinted at a grand finale in an interview with TopMob News. In a surprising turn of events, integrative medicine specialist Dotun Olubeko got down on one knee and declared their love as “perfect,” proposing to Charity, a child and family therapist, by asking if she would make their fairytale come true. Although they haven’t set a wedding date yet, the couple is considering tying the knot in 2025 or 2026. Before that, Charity will showcase her dancing skills on Dancing With the Stars. Excitedly, Dotun told Charity during The Bachelorette: After the Final Rose that she would be a contestant on Dancing With the Stars and encouraged her to embrace the opportunity.

 

Status: Engaged

Zach will have his fairy tale ending. Despite some hiccups during the Fantasy Suite, Zach Shallcross wrapped up season 27 in March 2023 with a proposal. “I’m so in love with you,” he said to travel nurse Kaity Biggar. “You are my world. The love I have for you is something I could never have imagined.”

In July 2023, the Texas-based pair took their relationship to the next level, as Kaity announced on Instagram, “We’re officially housemates.” They’re currently working on setting their October 2025 wedding date.

Status: Broke Up

Well, it seems like Danielle Maltby and Michael Allio, who appeared on season seven of BIP without Neil Lane diamonds, were destined to be the perfect Bachelor Nation couple. Unfortunately, they parted ways despite their best efforts. Danielle had lost her fiancé to a drug overdose before appearing on Nick Viall’s season, while Michael shared a 7-year-old son named James with his late wife.

However, after Danielle moved from Nashville to be with Michael in Ohio, they announced their separation. In a September 2023 episode of Jason Tartick’s Trading Secrets podcast, Michael explained their breakup: “We both invested a lot into this relationship, and it’s heartbreaking when things don’t work out. When you realize that love is there but you’re not necessarily compatible, you grieve the loss, not just of that person and the friend in your life, but also the future you had imagined.

Brandon Jones declared his eternal love for Serene Russell during their appearance on season seven of ‘Paradise’. However, despite this romantic start, they later announced their separation five months after their engagement was aired. They explained in a joint Instagram post in May 2023 that maintaining their relationship under the public eye has been challenging and painful. They asked for understanding and requested no negativity as they both are going through a difficult time with much love between them.

The relationship between pilot Rachel and general contractor Tino Franco encountered a halt due to an incident where he kissed another woman during their 2022 season, which was ongoing at the time. In his own words on “The Viall Files”, he admitted, “I have absolutely no defense for my actions. It was not right, it wasn’t fair to Rachel, and I regret it deeply every day. It’s something I’m ashamed of and if given a chance, I would change it countless times over.

The story unfolded as follows: Status: Split. In the finale of 2022, Susie Evans turned down proposals from Clayton Echard. However, off-camera, they reconnected, but eventually parted ways six months later. Despite this, Susie, a videographer based in L.A., justifies their breakup, stating on her blog “Susie Was Like” that she wasn’t flourishing and had lost her sparkle. She admitted that while they shared many happy moments, deep down she was battling internal struggles and felt out of sync with the best version of herself.

After dating Justin Glaze from Bachelor Nation, Susie later confirmed that they had parted ways as well, in August 2024.

Status: Split (broke up)

Teacher Michelle from Minnesota received an engagement ring and a $200,000 check for her future home from sales exec Nayte Olukoya and show producers during the filming of their season in 2021. However, they found that they didn’t have a strong enough connection, announcing their separation six months later.

Nayte spoke about the relationship on “The Viall Files,” admitting there were many disagreements, arguments, and fights, and they simply couldn’t see eye-to-eye. He also regretted not having a proper goodbye conversation in person, calling it a thoughtless act.

Michelle began dating Jack Leius in 2023, and they announced their engagement the following year.

The pair, Maurissa Gunn and Riley Christian, who had shared a vision of tranquil Sunday mornings during their time on BIP season 7, were unfortunately only able to spend a few weekends together. In a joint statement released in January 2022, they revealed that they’ve decided to part ways. They never anticipated this, but they now find themselves at a point where they both need to focus on their personal growth.

Status: Split

On season six of “Bachelor in Paradise”, the franchise’s initial same-sex couple exchanged engagement rings, but they declared their separation in October 2019, which coincided with Halloween.

In their shared announcement on Instagram, they expressed that love and concern for each other have always been central to their relationship. They prioritize making decisions that benefit them most. With hearts heavy with affection, they’ve chosen to take a break from their relationship. Essentially, they desire what is best for their future, and at this moment, that means growing separately.

Status: Engaged

Though Noah Erb and Abigail Heringer parted ways during the seventh season of BIP, they found that they could see an eternity in each other’s eyes. After initially settling in San Diego, the travel nurse (who sought Tayshia’s heart) and the financial manager (who received Matt James’ first impression rose) have recently purchased a home in his hometown of Tulsa.

“Ready to embark on our Chip and Joanna Gaines era as your girl just bought her very first house!!!” Abigail wrote on Instagram in July 2023. “Looking forward to starting our next chapter and the memories we’ll create here!!” Preparations for their wedding are underway, with Noah proposing at a beachfront San Diego home in August 2023 before their move.

As a lifestyle expert, I might rephrase it like this:

“Last year, following their stints on ‘Paradise’, reality stars Serena Pitt and Joe Amabile decided to take the plunge early and tie the knot at City Hall in New York City. Their official wedding is scheduled for September 2023, but who wouldn’t want a sneak peek at marriage life? Serena, now co-hosting the ‘Bachelor Happy Hour’ podcast with her new husband, excitedly announced their October 2022 nuptials with the caption: “JUST MARRIED!! We’re still having our big wedding in September, but why wait for a second chance at love?

As a devoted admirer, I can’t help but express my profound affection for you, Mari. In the finale of Paradise 2021, Kenny Braasch, the renowned boy band manager, spoke these heartfelt words as he adorned your finger with a stunning Neil Lane diamond ring: “I am completely and utterly in love with you.” He continued, “I can’t imagine my life without you.”

Following this magical moment, the enchanting Maryland beauty queen, who had initially captured Bachelor Matt’s heart, moved to Kenny’s hometown of Chicago. Together, they began planning their eternal journey as husband and wife. Before exchanging vows in a beautiful oceanfront ceremony with 65 guests in Puerto Rico in November 2023, they made their love unbreakable. In a memorable trip to the Bahamas during May 2023, they got inked with matching tattoos, symbols of their deep and lasting bond.

Status: Married

Becca, previously from The Bachelorette, and Thomas Jacobs (a contestant on Katie Thurston’s season) started dating during Bachelor in Paradise season seven in 2021. They split up while the show was airing but rekindled their relationship post-production. In May 2022, they announced their engagement, with Becca taking the initiative to propose. As she told TopMob News, she hopes this encourages others to break traditional rules. Thomas reciprocated in October of the same year. In September 2023, they welcomed their first child, a son named Benson. On Instagram, Becca expressed her immense love and wonder for their little boy. Just weeks after Benson’s arrival, the couple decided to get married in an impromptu ceremony on October 13, 2023.

Status: Split

In the final episode of season 17 of “The Bachelorette” in 2021, Katie got engaged to Blake Moynes. Their love for each other was first expressed during their overnight date, which included a paintball adventure, a cowboy tub, and a chat under the night sky.

Bending on a knee, Blake expressed to Katie, “You are worthy of the whole world, and I am thrilled to assist you and always be by your side in the future.

Approximately three months following the broadcast of their proposal, the couple revealed their separation. They expressed their sentiments in identical statements, “We are incredibly thankful for the moments we experienced together and the incredible journey we embarked on this year. However, we have determined that we are not ideally suited as lifelong partners, and making the decision to part ways separately is the kindest choice for us both.”

Now, she is set to marry comedian Jeff Arcuri.

Current Status: Separated
After parting ways briefly following their 2021 season, Matt and graphic designer Rachael Kirkconnell have been the subject of numerous breakup rumors. However, Matt clarified in an exclusive interview with TopMob News at a July 18 Baskin-Robbins event that everyone should take a break from social media, as people often jump to conclusions when someone is not constantly online.
Despite the speculation, Matt expressed that marriage remains their ultimate goal. He told TopMob News in May 2022 that their relationship moves at its own pace, and they are determined to make it work.
Regrettably, less than three years later, Matt announced their separation on Instagram in January 2025, expressing hope for strength and peace amidst this difficult decision. He also requested kindness and love from their friends and family during this challenging time, reminding everyone that their happiness comes from God.

Status: Split

Following her replacement for Clare Crawley in the 2020 season of The Bachelorette, Tayshia encountered and developed feelings for Zac Clark. Despite exiting their season with an engagement, the previous lead-turned-co-host eventually disclosed that their relationship had its fair share of highs and lows.

Being in a new relationship and then leaving for a few weeks can be challenging, let’s put it that way. And I’m being truthful about this,” she shared on The Ben and Ashley I. Almost Famous podcast in August 2021.

Subsequently, she expressed, “It seemed as though we had to recall the reasons for our connection. I believe this is quite standard.” However, in November 2021, it was reported by TopMob News that they had parted ways.

Status: Split

During season 16 of “The Bachelorette,” I found myself deeply smitten by Dale Moss. By the fourth episode, we were even engaged. However, the unexpected twists didn’t end there. After my departure and Tayshia’s engagement, Dale shared on social media that our romantic journey had ended prematurely.

Approximately a month later, whispers of reconciliation circulated as they were seen together once more. By July 2021, following numerous get-togethers, Clare and Dale had rekindled their relationship, complete with an engagement ring. However, in September of the same year, they decided to part ways again. Now, Clare is blissfully married to Ryan Dawkins, and they are eagerly anticipating the arrival of their first child together.

Status: Split

Following a short engagement with victor Hannah Ann Sluss and later a separation from runner-up Madison Prewett, fans had high hopes for Peter’s third attempt at love. Unfortunately, his relationship with Kelley Flanagan, the star of The Bachelor season 24, didn’t last either. On New Year’s Eve in 2020, Peter announced that their nine-month romance had ended.

Pete shared on Instagram, “Though our bond held many cherished moments, it ultimately didn’t sustain, but know that Kelly remains someone I hold a unique affection for.

In 2022, they tried to fly again, but later in May, they disclosed that their relationship had come to an end after reaching its ultimate point.

Status: Split

After an emotional ending in 2020, the pair shared on Instagram that they would no longer be continuing their romantic involvement. In his post, Peter expressed that both he and Madi had made a joint decision not to carry on their relationship any further. He acknowledged that this choice was difficult for them both but, after heartfelt discussions, they agreed it was the best course of action for them. The affection and regard Peter holds for Madi will persist.

In her statement, Madi expressed, “I’ll continue to cherish and admire him. I firmly believe that our lives intersecting was destined, and it has undeniably improved us both.

Status: Split

During the 24th season of “The Bachelor,” Peter and Hannah Ann had a short-lived engagement. Regrettably, just two episodes before the finale, they disclosed that their romantic journey faced obstacles only a month into their private relationship. More specifically, Hannah Ann was taken aback when she discovered Peter still harbored feelings for Madison from previous seasons.

She said, “All along, all I desired was for someone to offer their entire affection, just as I give mine. And yet, you ended my first engagement.” This was her statement before returning the ring. “You took that from me. That’s what you asked me to do – trust you, and be patient with you, have faith in you.

Read More

2025-04-18 15:48