Batman Begins: The Comics That Made The Movie

by

20 years ago today, Christopher Nolan’s 2005 film “Batman Begins” made its grand entrance into cinemas, significantly altering how the Dark Knight was portrayed on screen. Similar to how Tim Burton’s “Batman” and the brooding Michael Keaton deviated from Adam West’s lighthearted Batman in the 1960s TV series, Nolan’s serious reinterpretation served as a counterpoint to Joel Schumacher’s over-the-top portrayal of the Dynamic Duo in “Batman & Robin” (1997). Unlike previous film adaptations, Nolan’s “Batman” explored the comic book mythology and the psychological depth of Christian Bale’s Bruce Wayne more profoundly, offering a gritty origin story that is often considered the best superhero trilogy ever made.

In an interview for the documentary “Genesis of the Bat”, director Nolan, along with co-writer David S. Goyer, emphasized that they relied heavily on the rich history and mythology of Batman when crafting their story. Nolan stated that they wanted to be extremely respectful to the character’s history and the Batman mythos, as they felt it was crucial for their film adaptation. Notably, the origin story of Batman had not been explored in depth on screen or in comics before, leaving intriguing gaps in the mythology that they could creatively explore.

In a world where the origin story of Batman has become as familiar as an old friend, the director Matt Reeves wisely chose to bypass it in his fresh take on the franchise. Yet, it was not until Detective Comics #33, published way back in 1939 – six issues following Batman’s initial appearance in Detective Comics #27 – that I, as a curious reader, stumbled upon the intriguing tale of “The Batman and How He Came to Be.

In a two-page narrative penned by Batman’s co-creators Bob Kane and Bill Finger, we find young Bruce Wayne witnessing the tragic murder of his parents at the hands of an armed robber during a hold-up. Deeply moved, he vows to spend the remainder of his life combatting crime in memory of them. With his inherited fortune, he invests in enhancing both mind and body before settling on a disguise for his crusade.

In simpler terms, “Bruce Wayne, a wealthy socialite, states that criminals are easily frightened and superstitious, so his disguise needs to be fear-inspiring. He describes himself as a nocturnal, dark, and terrifying figure… As a bat swoops into the window of his study, he sees it as a sign. ‘I will become a symbol of the night, a bat,’ he decides.

1948’s Batman #47, penned anonymously, delved into Batman’s backstory via flashbacks scattered throughout the comic. In this installment, Batman faced off against Joe Chill, the man who had taken the lives of Thomas and Martha Wayne, his parents. This issue was groundbreaking as it revealed the identity of the Wayne’s killers for the first time, concluding with Chill being fatally gunned down by mobsters.

In the movie “Batman Begins“, a young boy named Bruce (Gus Lewis) witnesses his parents, Martha (Sara Stewart) and Thomas Wayne (Linus Roache), meet the same tragic end as their comic book counterparts. However, before a vengeful Bruce could make the man who killed his parents face justice, Joe Chill (Richard Brake) is himself killed before he could give evidence against his ex-cellmate, criminal mastermind Carmine Falcone (Tom Wilkinson).

In the comic book series “Batman: Year One,” published in 1987, a mafia figure named Carmine “The Roman” Falcone was introduced. This four-issue origin story, written by Frank Miller and illustrated by David Mazzuchelli, marked the first appearance of this character. After years of honing his skills, Bruce Wayne decided it was time to wage war against the rampant crime and corruption in Gotham City, taking on the role of a masked vigilante. The Batman formed an alliance with Jim Gordon, a police officer striving for justice in a city plagued by corrupt officers like Detective Flass (portrayed by Mark Boone Junior in “Batman Begins”).

In an interesting turn of events, Goyer mentioned that one significant work that impacted us was Frank Miller’s “Batman: Year One”. He explained that this piece delved into the initial year when Batman took on his crime-fighting persona. Moreover, he highlighted that “Year One” also marked the early stages of both Batman and Gordon, who at that time was not yet Commissioner Gordon.

Sergeant Gordon, portrayed by Gary Oldman, is as unyielding as the image that Bruce needs to embody, a figure he decides should be fear-inspiring. “Bats scare me,” Bruce confesses to Alfred Pennyworth, his steadfast ally, played by Michael Caine. “It’s high time my adversaries felt the same fear.

The foundation for Bruce’s backstory in the Nolan films was drawn from “The Man Who Falls,” a story written by Dennis O’Neil and illustrated by Dick Giordano, published in the 1989 comic book Secret Origins of the World’s Greatest Super-Heroes. This tale about Batman’s origins significantly influenced not only Bruce’s character development in the movie Batman Begins, but also the conclusion of Nolan’s trilogy, The Dark Knight Rises: “Why do we fall?” Bruce’s father asks after he falls into a well full of bats. “So we can learn to rise again.

Christopher Nolan describes “The Man Who Falls” as offering diverse stages in the transformation of Bruce Wayne into Batman. He explains that this narrative involves Bruce traveling globally, receiving guidance from various figures in different fields, and eventually returning to Gotham City. To Nolan, this storyline is intriguing, offering an engaging link between Bruce’s childhood tragedy – falling down a well and encountering bats – and the character he later creates to exploit people’s fear.

The Fallen Protector” opens by depicting young Bruce Wayne plunging into a cave filled with terrifying creatures resembling leather-winged nightmares. The story concludes with Batman, ever vigilant and poised on a gargoyle’s edge, diving into the darkness, mirroring his fall as a child and symbolizing his ongoing descent throughout his life.

As you’re strolling along, suddenly you find yourself plummeting through a gap. Tragically, there’s no end to your descent. Worse still, you witness others also falling.” In O’Neil’s narration, this describes the murder of the Waynes as depicted by Giordano. “His mother and father tumbled down, never to rise again. Neither did he. For when young Bruce Wayne, at eight years old, rose from that sidewalk, his destiny was already taking shape.

The story titled ‘The Man Who Falls’ combines aspects from O’Neil’s ‘Batman: Shaman’ and the ‘Blind Justice’ storyline from 1989 Detective Comics (written by Batman screenwriter Sam Hamm). It narrates how Bruce embarked on a worldwide journey, perfecting his intellect and physique through training under Master Kirigi in Korea, followed by acquiring skills in deceit and strategy from his subsequent mentor, Henri Ducard.

As a passionate movie enthusiast, I yearn for the tools to combat injustice, to flip terror against those who exploit the frightened. In Batman Begins, Christian Bale’s Bruce confides this desire to the enigmatic Ducard (Liam Neeson). Positioning himself as a figure dreaded by the criminal underworld, Ra’s al Ghul (Ken Watanabe) allegedly sends Ducard to educate Bruce in the methods of the League of Shadows. This training aims to refine him in the arts of mental discipline, dramatic performance, and deceit. However, the climactic revelation is that Ducard himself is Ra’s al Ghul, collaborating with Arkham Asylum’s corrupt psychopharmacologist, Dr. Jonathan Crane (Cillian Murphy) — the fear-instilling Scarecrow — to shatter Gotham by sowing fear among its citizens.

To create authentic portrayals of Batman’s adversaries, Ra’s al Ghul and Scarecrow, for his films, director Christopher Nolan drew inspiration from classic stories such as the initial introduction of Ra’s in “Daughter of the Demon” (found in Batman #232 by O’Neil and Neal Adams, published in 1971) and the Scarecrow-focused storyline in Batman: Terror (spanning issues #137-141 of Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight in 2001).

Nolan and Goyer drew inspiration from the groundbreaking “Batman: The Long Halloween” by Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale, which featured both Falcone and Scarecrow, along with the “Fears” storyline from their 1993 “Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight Halloween Special” #1. They also acknowledged the iconic ’70s Batman comics by O’Neil and Adams as a major influence on their serious and somber approach to the Batman reboot.

In my opinion, Christopher Nolan’s Batman universe mirrors our own world, but with a twist – it’s intensified. That’s precisely what this film achieves, and that’s what I believe makes the best Batman stories so captivating. (Dennis O’Neil in “Genesis of the Bat”)

Read More

2025-06-16 04:12