Captain America: Brave New World Review: The Winter Soldier’s Spiritual Successor

2024 will only see one theatrical Marvel Cinematic Universe release, which is Deadpool and Wolverine, leaving a significant burden on Sam Wilson as Captain America in Brave New World. This fourth installment in the Captain America series has faced numerous reshoots and rewrites during its development and production, causing some Marvel enthusiasts to question if it could match up to its previous versions. However, with Anthony Mackie’s Cap battling villains like Giancarlo Esposito’s Sidewinder, Tim Blake Nelson’s Leader, and a formidable president portrayed by Harrison Ford’s Red Hulk, there’s certainly no shortage of challenges for Wilson to handle. Thankfully, Brave New World offers an engaging experience that I can’t wait to savor.

As a movie critic, I’d say diving into “Captain America: Brave New World” finds me shoulder-to-shoulder with Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson, now deep into his Captain America gig, working alongside the U.S. government. With former adversary General Thaddeus Ross (William Hurt) ascending to the presidency, Sam embarks on a delicate dance of reconciliation and national healing. However, the emergence of the ‘Celestial Island’ and the impending introduction of adamantium into the Marvel Cinematic Universe have sent shockwaves through our world. Partnering with the fresh Falcon, Joaquin Torres (Danny Ramirez), Sam must steer through a stormy sea of espionage and superhero dilemmas.

In this installment of the series, Chris Evans’ Steve Rogers steps back while Anthony Mackie assumes the role as the Captain America wielder, a shift that seems to be generally well-received. The film doesn’t shy away from showcasing Sam Wilson’s strengths and weaknesses in comparison to the original character, a contrast that enhances the narrative. Mackie brings a likable charisma to the role and can switch between friendly and serious demeanors seamlessly. There were concerns about whether Mackie could match Evans’ performance, but we’re pleased to say he delivers an impressive portrayal of Captain America in this movie. The story offers a compelling look at Sam’s transition into the new Captain America, leaving us eager for more, fortunately, Avengers: Doomsday, scheduled for release soon, promises just that.

Indeed, Mackie has some significant challenges to tackle, primarily involving Harrison Ford’s character, Thaddeus Ross. Ross is well-known in the Marvel Universe, portrayed previously by the late William Hurt. Although Ford is undeniably exceptional in acting, Hurt’s performance was noteworthy as well. Fortunately, Ford has ample material to explore here, as he navigates the complexities of becoming a newly elected President and repairing his relationship with his daughter, Betty (Liv Tyler). Ford skillfully adds depth to Thaddeus, portraying him as a man grappling with his past actions as a General, president, and father. Ford effectively conveys the torment stemming from his previous mistakes.

As a movie enthusiast, I must say that when it comes to the villainous role in Brave New World, one character has managed to keep himself shrouded in mystery throughout most of the promotional materials – Tim Blake Nelson’s Samuel Sterns, who Marvel aficionados may recognize as The Leader from The Incredible Hulk. In this film, he orchestrates everything masterfully, and it’s evident that Nelson is relishing every moment of his performance. His portrayal of the gamma-enhanced genius exudes an enticing wickedness, setting a sinister tone without resorting to the same wisecracks that many Marvel villains have used in the past.

The Leader’s dialogue in Captain America 4 is nothing short of captivating, making him an essential addition to the film as he provides a formidable challenge for both Wilson and Ross. The Leader has consistently been a psychological threat to Marvel heroes, and Brave New World does an impressive job of encapsulating that menacing atmosphere.

One intriguing aspect about “Captain America: Brave New World” is how it managed to hold its own against the impressive shadow cast by “Captain America: The Winter Soldier“. While there are some comical instances, generally speaking, “Brave New World” opts for a more somber tone and delves deeply into its mature themes. Gone are the elements of the multiverse and the humorous variants that used to clutter the screen; instead, this film adopts a much more realistic approach, which seems to enhance its overall quality. (Even though it does feature an unexpected event where the President of the United States transforms into Red Hulk during a press conference and wreaks havoc on the White House.)

Interestingly, the abundance of ideas and key story points in the movie adaptation of “Brave New World” serves as a double-edged sword. While it keeps viewers engaged with its swift pacing, it also prevents the film from exploring some intriguing aspects further. For instance, the scenes between Sam and Steve Rogers could have delved deeper into their contrasting perspectives, Isaiah Bradley might have had more time to grapple emotionally with his past, and the parallels drawn between the Marvel Cinematic Universe and our world could have been examined more thoroughly. The film’s most significant flaw is arguably its brevity, as several story beats would have benefited from extended screen time to strengthen their underlying themes. If “Captain America: Brave New World” had been given an extra half-hour, it could have provided those themes with the breathing space they needed for a more impactful viewing experience.

Discussing the character’s shortcomings, similar to the film’s central ideas, Sidewinder, portrayed by Esposito, seems more like a tool than a fully-fledged antagonist. Giancarlo delivers an excellent performance, but it feels underutilized in this role. The whispers of alterations in the movie, such as removing WWE’s Seth Rollins from the Serpent Society, make one wonder about the original intended narrative.

In a slightly different wording, “Captain America: Brave New World” may have its imperfections, yet it effectively re-establishes Marvel Cinematic Universe’s appeal and showcases what the universe is still capable of when it fully commits. This sequel might not rival “Captain America: Winter Soldier,” but it undeniably builds upon its legacy, which is a delight for movie enthusiasts.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Captain America: Brave New World hits theaters on Friday, February 14th.

Read More

2025-02-12 20:13