Clayton Echard’s Surprising Response to Susie Evans’ Cryptic Remarks Revealed!

Every rose has its thorn.

Clayton Echard can openly acknowledge that his relationship with Susie Evans, which started during his challenging stint on The Bachelor and concluded around late 2022, had its ups and downs.

Currently, Clayton is addressing remarks that Susie made during his 2023 paternity trial, where it was determined that he was not the father of a 33-year-old’s child, despite his previous assertions. During this period, Susie stated about her ex, “You know, Clayton might be many things, but he’s not a liar. And that held significant weight for me.

Clayton expressed on The Ben and Ashley Almost Famous podcast on January 22nd that “there were reasons for our breakup, and neither of us should be held responsible.” He further explained that “it didn’t work out from my perspective because of how she behaved, but the same is true in reverse.

He went on to say, “There have been occasions where her lighter remarks seemed significantly impactful to me. That particular quote was one such instance. Consequently, I hope Susie finds success in her future.

He also speculated over why his ex made the comments she did.

Clayton expressed, “I believe the comment wasn’t appropriately phrased, and there were instances where I disagreed with her statements. It seemed to me that she was attempting to shift blame for the failed relationship onto me.

He elaborated by saying, “If you’re using this as a quote, you may question why it was phrased that way. Instead of stating ‘Clayton isn’t a liar,’ why did it say ‘he might be many things’? This indicates I haven’t supported the idea and I’ve made it clear to her.

Initially, the retired NFL player confessed that although he had asked, Susie didn’t explain the specific meaning of her remark to him. Later, he mentioned that he has already moved past the issue and let it go.

In September 2021, Susie and Clayton initially crossed paths on the television show, “The Bachelor.” Although Susie was among his final three contenders alongside Gabby Windey and Rachel Recchia, he made the decision to send her away. However, later, he came to understand that it was Susie whom he truly desired.

As a devoted follower, I’d like to share that despite their season not culminating in an engagement, during the “After the Final Rose,” they disclosed that they had reignited their relationship. However, after being beset by rumors about Clayton cheating on Susie—which he refuted—by September 2022, they chose to go separate ways.

They acknowledged that people might have many questions regarding their decision, since social media often presents only the best moments. However, they’ve kept most of their shared experiences private, as I’m sure you can understand. Yet, they wanted to share this: despite the last year being filled with immense joy and laughter, it also brought a great deal of pain.

They stated, “We recognize that no strong relationship escapes difficulties, yet we found ourselves unprepared for the external factors that impeded our progress in healing both individually and as a partnership.

After their separation, I found myself momentarily connected with another Bachelor Nation figure, Justin Glaze, but our relationship didn’t last beyond August.

For more on where some of your favorite Bachelor Nation couples are today, keep reading.

Currently: In a Relationship
After starring on the inaugural season of “The Golden Bachelor” and ending her relationship with Gerry Turner prematurely, Joan Vassos later became the leading lady on the first season of “The Golden Bachelorette”. It was during this show that she encountered and became engaged to contestant Chock Chapple.

Joan expressed their sentiments on the November 2024 finale of “The Golden Bachelorette”, saying, “Life may throw challenges at us, but there’s always hope, even at our age.” She continued, “I waited for this special moment in this breathtaking location to tell you that I love you. I want to spend the rest of my life with you, waking up next to you each morning and kissing you goodnight.” Chock then proposed to Joan in Bora Bora.

Status: Split

 

In the finale of season 21 of The Bachelorette, it seemed like former Bachelor contestant Jenn Tran was set to find her lasting love with her final choice, Devin Strader. However, during After the Final Rose in September, Jenn, aged 26, disclosed that Devin, who is 28, abruptly ended communication with her once filming ended.

 

During the September 3rd episode, Jenn explained to host Jesse Palmer that he had been expressing passionate declarations of affection one day, only to act indifferent and deny any feelings of love the next. She added that all the commitments he had made to her, along with the love he had expressed a desire to give, seemed to have vanished without a trace.

 

The events became more intriguing as Devin posted a 13-minute video on Instagram, explaining his perspective and also admitting fault (taking accountability), while also discussing the reasons behind ending their relationship during a 15-minute conversation over the phone.

 

Instead of saying Jenn accused him of ending their relationship over the phone in August, it could be rephrased as: In August, he stated that Jenn asked for an explanation about their situation during a call, while he was attempting to figure out how to tell her in person that they were breaking up.

 

He confided that he wasn’t sure what other option he had left, adding that he had been planning to share the news with her face-to-face. Essentially, she made him take action sooner than he intended.

 

Ever since she graced the stage on Dancing with the Stars, I’ve been hooked! And it seems like my obsession might not just be about her dance moves anymore – Jenn has been tiptoeing towards Sasha Farber, her partner, it appears. They’ve kept fueling those romance rumors ever since our hearts collectively broke when they were eliminated on October 29th.

Status: Split

In November 2022, Greg Grippo, who was among Katie Thurston’s suitors on The Bachelorette the previous year, appeared alongside Victoria Fuller in the eighth season finale of Bachelor in Paradise. There, they declared that they were in a relationship. However, in April 2024, he disclosed that their relationship had ended.

Prior to Victoria Fuller and Greg Grippo making their relationship official on the finale of Bachelor in Paradise‘s eighth season, Victoria and her fellow cast member Johnny DePhillipo had previously broken off their engagement.

Status: Divorced

Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist became engaged in November 2023, during the final episode of the first season of “Golden Bachelor,” and exchanged vows in a televised wedding ceremony held in January 2024.

However, three months after their nuptials, the couple announced that they were breaking up.

During their interview on Good Morning America alongside Theresa in April 2024, Gerry stated, “Theresa and I have shared many deep talks and carefully examined our circumstances, particularly our living arrangements. We’ve arrived at a mutual understanding that it seems appropriate for us to end our marriage.

They reached a divorce settlement in June 2024, according to court records reviewed by TopMob News.

As a dedicated follower, I’m thrilled to share the heartwarming story of tennis pro Joey Graziadei. After 32 romantic journeys, he found his soulmate in project manager Kelsey Anderson. “I’ve been eagerly waiting for this moment to express my feelings,” I said, pouring out my emotions during our season finale in March 2024. “You have an energy that is contagious and always puts a smile on my face. It’s a sensation I’ve never experienced before.”

Picture us together, living our lives to the fullest, with Kelsey by my side. I’ve longed for a life filled with beauty, but it wasn’t until I met you that I truly understood the depth of that beauty.

Despite not initially connecting until halfway through season nine of “Bachelor in Paradise”, John Henry Spurlock (one of Charity Lawson’s suitors) and Kat Izzo (who vied for Zach Shallcross’ heart) decided to take a leap of faith. As he presented an Ascher cut Neil Lane diamond, he shared, “I’m trying something different today. My heart is leading me to believe that you are extraordinary, exactly what I’ve been searching for.”

However, just days after the season finale, the couple announced that their careers were taking them in separate directions and their paths weren’t aligned for a future together. “Although our journeys are diverging due to our career goals not matching up,” they wrote in a joint Instagram post, “we are thankful for the love and encouragement we’ve received from our families, friends, and Bachelor Nation.

In the finale, Eliza Isichei (one of Clayton Echard’s former partners) accepted a proposal from Aaron Bryant amidst her apprehensions about their relationship. Moved by his gesture of consulting her mother for approval, she was emotional and said, “I couldn’t predict what I would say next.”

However, the post-finale update revealed that Eliza and her partner had faced some difficulties following their trip to Mexico, culminating in an announcement that they had parted ways amicably. On Instagram, he expressed his feelings about the split, stating “Navigating through these emotions has been challenging, but we’re moving forward with nothing but goodwill and mutual respect for each other.

Status: Separated
Postpartum nurse Kylee Russell reluctantly agreed to Aven Jones’ proposal from ‘Bachelor in Paradise’, despite his initial hesitation to propose during their courtship with Bachelorette Rachel Recchia. She decided to leave her planned engagement dress untouched, stating that she had to follow her heart because “love is about taking risks.”
Two days after the finale aired in December 2023, Kylee revealed on Instagram Stories that their relationship had ended due to several instances of infidelity. Aven later apologized for his mistakes and the pain he caused Kylee, admitting that he had made major errors within their relationship.

In a recent interview with TopMob News, Charity Lawson playfully expressed her satisfaction with this season. However, her August 2023 finale was more than she hinted at, as integrative medicine specialist Dotun Olubeko got down on one knee to declare their love as “perfect.” He then posed the question, “Would you do me the honor of making our fairytale come true?”

Although the details of their wedding are yet to be finalized—with possibilities of tying the knot in 2025 or 2026—Charity has a busy year ahead. She is set to grace the ballroom on Dancing With the Stars, an opportunity she and Dotun have discussed eagerly. On The Bachelorette: After the Final Rose, Dotun excitedly told Charity, “You love to dance and get down, remember when we talked about how amazing this would be? Well, I am thrilled to tell you that you’ve been chosen for Dancing With the Stars! Let’s do this!

 

Status: Set to Marry

Zach will find his blissful conclusion. Although there were a few hiccups during the Fantasy Suite stage, Zach Shallcross concluded season 27 in March 2023 on bended knee. “I am deeply in love with you,” he confessed to travel nurse Kaity Biggar. “You are my universe. The affection I harbor for you surpasses anything I could have ever imagined.”

In July 2023, this Texas-based pair took a significant stride forward in their relationship, as Kaity announced on Instagram, “Now officially housemates.” They’re currently organizing their October 2025 wedding ceremony.

The status of Danielle Maltby and Michael Allio, who were previously thought to be a perfect match after appearing on ‘Bachelor Nation’, is now ‘Split’. Despite their efforts and shared experiences within Bachelor Nation, they have parted ways. Michael expressed his feelings on Jason Tartick’s podcast, stating that it was unfortunate when relationships don’t work out, especially when there was love but perhaps not compatibility. He also mentioned mourning the loss of not just the person and friendship, but also the future they had envisioned together.

Brandon Jones declared his eternal affection for Serene Russell during their proposal on season seven of ‘Paradise’. However, their relationship didn’t last long. A few months after their engagement aired, they announced their separation in a joint Instagram statement in May 2023. They acknowledged the difficulty of dealing with their relationship in the public eye and asked for no negativity as they were both experiencing intense pain.

Status: The relationship between pilot Rachel and general contractor Tino Franco encountered difficulties. During their 2022 season, he was involved with another woman, which he later admitted on “The Viall Files”. He expressed regret for his actions, stating, “I do not stand by what I did at all. It wasn’t cool, it wasn’t fair to Rachel, and it still haunts me daily. It’s something I’m ashamed of and certainly wish I could have done it differently a million times over.

The situation: Split

Susie Evans and Bachelor Clayton Echard parted ways after an initial reunion following their finale in 2022. However, they had split up again six months later. Yet, Susie, a video producer based in L.A., asserts that the separation served its purpose. In a blog post from November 2022 titled “Susie Was Like,” she explained that her enthusiasm had waned, and she was not living up to her full potential. She admitted they shared many happy moments, but beneath the surface, she was grappling with difficulties and feeling out of sync with her ideal self.

After dating Justin Glaze, a notable figure from Bachelor Nation, Susie later announced that they had parted ways as well, in August of 2024.

Status: Separation

Minnesota elementary school teacher Michelle received a Neil Lane sparkler from Texas-based sales executive Nayte Olukoya, as well as a $200,000 check from producers for their future home. However, the couple didn’t build a strong connection and announced their split six months after their season finale aired in December 2021.

On The Viall Files, Nayte admitted there were many highs and lows, disagreements, and fights during their relationship. He also acknowledged that not having an in-person conversation to end things was “immature.”

Michelle began dating Jack Leius in 2023, and they announced their engagement the following year.

The pair from BIP season 7, Maurissa Gunn and Riley Christian, successfully shared their dream of leisurely Sundays with the audience. However, despite the connection, their time together was limited to just a few weekends. In a joint statement issued in January 2022, their coordinator Maurissa (who had a romantic relationship with Peter Weber) and attorney Riley (one of Tayshia Adams’ suitors) declared that they were parting ways. They never anticipated this situation, but they have reached a point where they both need to focus on their personal growth.

Status: Split

The first same-sex pair from Bachelor Nation became engaged during the sixth season of ‘Bachelor in Paradise’, but they announced their separation in October 2019, which coincided with Halloween.

In our partnership, love and concern for each other have always been paramount. Putting our collective interests first has always been our priority. After much thought, a decision filled with love for one another was made – it’s best for both of us to step back from our relationship for the time being. We desire what is truly beneficial in the long term, and at this moment, that means growing independently.

Current Status: Engaged

However, it wasn’t paradise lost. Although Noah Erb and Abigail Heringer parted ways during the seventh season of BIP, they found that they could see an eternity in each other’s eyes. Initially setting up in San Diego, the travel nurse (who competed for Tayshia’s affection) and the financial manager (who received Matt James’ first impression rose) recently purchased a home in his hometown of Tulsa.

In July 2023, Abigail shared on Instagram, “About to enter our Chip and Joanna Gaines era because your girl bought her very first house!!!” She continued, “Excited to start our next chapter and for all the memories we’ll create here!!” In preparation for their new life together, Noah proposed at a beachfront San Diego home in August 2023, marking the beginning of their wedding plans.

Status: Now Married

Serena Pitt (a finalist on Matt James’ season) and Joe Amabile (the Chicago grocery store owner who gained fame after being sent home night one in 2018 by Becca Kufrin), decided to take a trial run for their upcoming September 2023 wedding. They opted to exchange vows at City Hall, located near their New York City residence, approximately a year after leaving the Bachelor in Paradise. Serena, now co-hosting the Bachelor Happy Hour podcast with her husband, captioned an October 2022 video “JUST MARRIED !!” She added, “We are still having a wedding this September but who doesn’t love getting married twice?

Kenny Braasch, a well-known boy band manager, expressed his deep affection for Mari Pepin by saying, “Mari, I am absolutely smitten by you,” as he placed a Neil Lane diamond ring on her finger during the 2021 finale of Paradise. “I truly can’t envision my life without you,” he continued. After their elimination from the show by Tayshia Adams in week five, they moved from Maryland to Chicago together and started planning their lifelong commitment. Before their oceanfront wedding in Puerto Rico in November 2023, they made their love official by getting matching tattoos during a trip to the Bahamas in May 2023.

Status: Married

Previously on “The Bachelor,” Becca and Thomas Jacobs (one of Katie Thurston’s suitors) found love on season seven of “Bachelor in Paradise” in 2021, but split during the show. However, their relationship blossomed after filming ended. In May 2022, they revealed that they were engaged, with Becca taking the initiative to propose. As she shared with TopMob News, “I hope others can now feel empowered, understanding it’s okay to break the rules.” Thomas reciprocated this gesture in October of the same year. In September 2023, they welcomed their first child, a son named Benson. Becca expressed on Instagram, “Words cannot express the love and admiration we have for our little man.” Interestingly, just weeks after welcoming Benson, the couple decided to tie the knot in an impromptu ceremony on October 13, 2023.

Status: Split

As a lifestyle connoisseur, allow me to share a thrilling recap from the grand finale of “The Bachelorette” season 17 in the year 2021: In an unforgettable moment, I found myself engaged to Blake Moynes under the starlit sky. Our journey began during our extraordinary overnight date that featured a paintball adventure, a relaxing cowboy tub soak, and a heartfelt conversation beneath the stars – it was there that we declared our deepest feelings for each other. A truly magical evening!

Lowering himself to a single knee, Blake expressed to Katie, “You’re worthy of the entire universe, and I’m thrilled to stand by your side and be there for you each and every day from now on.

Three months following the broadcast of their proposal, the pair publicly declared their separation. In harmonious statements, they expressed, “We are deeply thankful for the precious moments we experienced together and the incredible journey that unfolded over the past year. However, after careful consideration, we’ve decided that we aren’t suitable as life partners. It is the kindest decision for us both to part ways and move forward separately.”

Now, she is betrothed to comedian Jeff Arcuri.

Current Status: Separated

Since Matt and graphic designer Rachael Kirkconnell parted ways following their 2021 season (which included a brief separation before reconciling), speculation about their relationship has been rampant. In an exclusive interview with TopMob News at a Baskin-Robbins event on July 18, Matt expressed his opinion that everyone should take a break from social media, stating, “Our lives are so intertwined with our phones that when anyone steps away from being online 24/7, people think it’s the end of the world.”

Despite this, Matt emphasized in May 2022 that marriage was still their ultimate goal. He told TopMob News, “I think the good thing about our relationship is we go at our own pace. And you’ve seen with other couples—they rush things and they’re not together anymore. So, I think what we have is a successful recipe, and we’ll get there.”

However, less than three years later, Matt confirmed that he and Rachael had parted ways once more. On Instagram on January 16, 2025, the reality star wrote, “Father God, give Rachael and I strength to mend our broken hearts. Give us peace about this decision to end our relationship that transcends worldly understanding. Shower our friends and family with kindness and love to comfort us. And remind us that our Joy comes from you, Lord.

Status: Split

Following her entry to take over Clare Crawley’s 2020 season of The Bachelorette, Tayshia became smitten with Zac Clark. Despite leaving her season as an engaged couple, Tayshia, the previous Bachelorette turned co-host, disclosed at a later date that their relationship had its fair share of highs and lows.

Speaking candidly on the “The Ben and Ashley I. Almost Famous” podcast in August 2021, she expressed that it can be challenging to maintain a new relationship while being apart for a fortnight or so.

Later on, she explained, “It seemed like we had to recall what brought us together initially. And I believe such feelings are entirely common.” However, in November 2021, TopMob News reported that they had decided to part ways.

Status: Split

During season 16 of ‘The Bachelorette’, Clare developed a deep affection for Dale Moss. Intriguingly, they became engaged by the fourth episode itself. However, further twists unfolded as Tayshia, who replaced Clare later, also found her match and got engaged. Yet another surprise came when Dale announced on social media that his relationship with the hairdresser had ended even weeks after Tayshia’s engagement.

Approximately a month later, whispers of reconciliation swirled around them as they were seen together again. Fast forward to July 2021 – after numerous reunions – Clare and Dale had reconciled completely, even sporting a ring. However, in September of the same year, they ended their relationship once more. Now, Clare is blissfully married to Ryan Dawkins and they’re eagerly anticipating the arrival of their first child together.

Status: Split

Following his short-lived relationship with Hannah Ann Sluss and subsequent breakup with Madison Prewett, fans had high hopes that things would work out for Peter in round three. However, it appears that the connection between Peter and Kelley Flanagan, who gained prominence on The Bachelor season 24, was not destined to last. On New Year’s Eve of 2020, the pilot announced that their nine-month relationship had ended.

Pete shared on Instagram that, although our relationship held many cherished moments, it ultimately didn’t succeed, but Kelly will forever hold a unique place in my heart.

In 2022, they tried to fly again, but later in May, they disclosed that their relationship had come to an end.

Status: Split

After the emotional ending in 2020, the pair shared on Instagram that they were choosing not to continue their romantic involvement. “Madi and I have decided, with mutual understanding, not to advance our relationship any further,” Peter posted. “I assure you this wasn’t an easy decision for either of us, but after heartfelt discussions, we have come to the conclusion that this is what best suits us both. The affection and regard I hold for Madi will persist.

In her declaration, Madi mentioned, “I’ll never stop loving and admiring him. I firmly believe that our lives intertwined were destined, and we’ve both grown for the better because of it.

Status: Split

During season 24 of ‘The Bachelor’, Peter and Hannah Ann had a short-lived engagement. Regrettably, by part two of the finale, it became clear that they were facing difficulties just a month into their exclusive relationship. More specifically, Hannah Ann was taken aback when she discovered Peter still harbored feelings for Madison.

She said, “All along, I merely wanted someone to fully commit to me as I am giving myself to them. And yet, you ended our first engagement.” She conveyed her feelings before returning the ring. “You’ve taken that away from me. This is what I’ve been asking of you: patience and faith. Trusting me, just as I’ve trusted you.

After our adventurous #vanlife chapter, life has taken an exciting turn for me and my partner. Dean Unglert, a finalist from Bachelorette Rachel Lindsay’s season, and I, Caelynn Miller-Keyes who was with Colton Underwood on Paradise, parted ways back in 2019, but ever since then, we’ve been sailing smoothly together.

Fast forward to 2022, we took our relationship to the next level by getting engaged! Our wedding, themed around camp, was a picturesque affair in the Colorado mountains on September 23rd. I couldn’t help but express my joy to TopMob News before the big day. “I adore him so much,” I said. “I’m just thrilled to be marrying someone as wonderful as he is, who can make me laugh every single day, even on tough days. I believe our journey as a married couple will be filled with endless fun.

Read More

2025-01-23 21:49