Comic Book Reviews for This Week: 1/1/2025


As a lifelong comic book enthusiast, I must say that this week’s selection of comics had me truly excited! The X-Factor issue hit particularly close to home for me as a child of the ’90s, and it was great to see the team finally finding their footing. The X-Force issue was also captivating, with its emotional focus on Askani and Captain Britain. I’ve always had a soft spot for underdog characters, so seeing them shine was truly heartwarming.

On the other hand, the Rick and Morty: New Year, New Rick Special left me wanting more. While it captured the spirit of the show, the dialogue seemed to fall flat compared to its television counterpart. And as someone who knows little about fencing, Fence Challengers: Sweet Sixteen was a bit of a snooze for me.

Overall, I’d say this week’s comics were hit or miss, but there was definitely more to love than hate! Don’t forget to let your fellow comic book fans know what you thought of the week’s releases – we can all geek out together on Bluesky @KnightofOA! And remember, if it ain’t fun, we’re not doing it right!

As a lifelong comic book enthusiast, I eagerly await the arrival of each new weekly installment in this incredible world of sequential art. It’s like Christmas morning for me every Wednesday, affectionately known to fellow fans as “New Comic Book Day”! This week is particularly special, marking not only a fresh start but also the culmination of stories that have been unfolding over the past year.

I’ve been following along with titles from Marvel, DC, Image Comics, BOOM! Studios, Dark Horse, Dynamite, Oni Press, IDW, Mad Cave Studios, DSTLRY, and many more. I can’t wait to dive into the latest issues, dissecting every panel and page, discussing theories with fellow fans, and sharing my thoughts in our weekly reviews here at ComicBook.

Of course, it’s impossible to cover every single comic on shelves, but we do our best to bring you insights into as many of the new releases as possible. So grab your favorite beverage, settle in, and join us as we explore this week’s offerings from the world of comics! Happy New Comic Book Day and Happy New Year!

We’ve created room for extended reviews on two highly anticipated releases – Deadpool/Wolverine #1 and Justice League: The Atom Project #1. If our brief previews catch your attention, be sure to explore the full reviews for a more detailed examination of these issues. Our rating system is straightforward, using whole or half numbers out of five. To delve into our past reviews, simply click here. Now, let’s dive into this week’s fresh comic book releases!

DC

In issue #3 of Absolute Superman, writers Jason Aaron and artists Rafa Sandoval cleverly unravel mysteries about Superman that readers didn’t realize they were curious about. Jason Aaron skillfully infuses the narrative with unexpected nuances, shedding light on aspects of Superman’s character that create a comprehensive portrayal of who he is within this world. Notably, Rafa Sandoval delivers an image on the penultimate page that is truly captivating and worth a look. Letterer Becca Carey continues to be a hidden strength in Absolute Superman, ensuring essential story elements are presented succinctly, intriguingly, and distinctively. – Spencer Perry

Rating: 5 out of 5

In the third issue of Batgirl, we delve deeper into the year of Cassandra Cain as the artistic duo of Takeshi Miyazawa and Mike Spicer continue to deliver captivating superhero battles that rival those seen in movies like Mission Impossible. A fight on a train, in particular, showcases both grace and ferocity. Meanwhile, Tate Brombal’s portrayal of Lady Shiva is noteworthy, as I’ve never felt strongly about this character before. However, much like Cassandra’s evolving perspective, my feelings towards Lady Shiva are gradually shifting as more dimensions are revealed about her influence on the world and her genuine emotions towards her daughter. Batgirl remains engaging across various aspects and is definitely worth checking out. – Matthew Aguilar

Rating: 4 out of 5

In issue #156 of Batman, all the plotlines are skillfully tied up, unmasking the true powers manipulating events within Gotham City, and introducing the formidable adversary that Batman must confront. Although it may have been speculated earlier that The Riddler wasn’t the main puppeteer, the disclosure of the real forces working against Bruce Wayne, Batman, and aiming to seize control over Gotham is both intriguing and timely. This issue is packed with action, fitting for the climax of this arc, and offers a captivating read that could be one of the best Batman issues in recent memory. – Nicole Drum

Rating: 4 out of 5

Batman: Full Moon #3

Author Rodney Barnes showcases his exceptional understanding of character interactions within the DC Universe, skillfully navigating a plot that could effortlessly veer off course. The intricacy of Barnes’ storytelling is captivating on its own, but when coupled with Stevan Subic’s artwork, it creates an indomitable duo. Subic masterfully stages werewolf battles, colossal monsters, enchanting magic, and melancholic gothic landscapes with a sense of effortless elegance. If you’re seeking a comic that blends horror elements with capes, this is the one to check out.

Rating: 5 out of 5

In issue #17 of Birds of Prey, the thrilling conclusion to “Bird Undercover” unfolds, brimming with the series’ signature humor and warmth amidst a high-octane battle. Kelly Thompson masterfully incorporates poignant character moments even during intense action sequences, and it’s gratifying to see characters like Black Canary, Barda, Batgirl, as well as Grace, Onyx, and Sin, each getting their moment in the spotlight. Rest assured, if you’re here just for Black Canary to unleash her power, artists Sami Basri, Adriano Lucas, Vicente Cifuentes, and Clayton Cowles will not disappoint. This issue doesn’t tease a major plot twist for the next installment, but rest assured, Birds of Prey has consistently delivered quality storytelling no matter what lies ahead. – Matthew Aguilar

Rating: 4 out of 5

In a perfect casting choice, Dastmalchian seamlessly slots into the Creature Commandos. His work on Count Crowley serves as an excellent lead-up to this series, illuminating the blurred boundaries between morality and societal norms while unveiling the chilling truth about monsters lurking in unexpected places. This series also harmoniously complements its upcoming screen adaptation. – Charlie Ridgely

Rating: 4 out of 5

As a lifelong fan of DC Comics and the Justice Society of America, I’ve witnessed many ups and downs throughout the years. But with “JSA #3,” it feels like Jeff Lemire is breathing new life into this team of heroes. The series has been on shaky ground since its inception, but slowly but surely, the tide seems to be turning.

Lemire’s exploration of the JSA from various perspectives has shed light on the cracks within the group, and I must say, it’s refreshing to see them portrayed as a family with all their dysfunctional glory. The interactions between Doctor Fate and Wildcat, as well as Jade and Sand, have been some of the best moments in the series so far. While I could have used a bit less Hawkman, it looks like his storyline is heading towards something intriguing, making the investment worthwhile.

Artistically speaking, Diego Olortegui, Luis Guerrero, and Steve Wands are all at the top of their game. The action-packed battle scenes are nothing short of spectacular, and they’ve managed to make me a fan of Doctor Fate in the process.

Overall, “JSA #3” seems to be building towards something epic, and I have a feeling that the wait will pay off handsomely. As someone who has been following DC Comics for decades, I can say with confidence that this series is worth checking out for both new and longtime fans alike. 4 out of 5 stars.

Justice League: The Atom Project #1 – A New, Ambitious Player in Town

The concept of a powerful newcomer joining the ranks of the Justice League is unsettling for those who have something to protect. The creators, Parrot and Ridley, have hit upon an intriguing thematic thread here. Although the narrative in this initial issue could be more polished, the premise of Justice League: The Atom Project is captivating enough to allow the creators some leeway to refine their work. Hopefully, future installments will deliver with greater clarity and assurance.

– Rating: 3 out of 5 (For a comprehensive review, click here)

In issue #29 of Poison Ivy, Pam uncovers the identity of the person orchestrating the eco-terrorist cult that has made her their deity, and it’s a figure with surprising ties to her past. Although the revelation is somewhat underwhelming, it sparks Pam to delve deeper into her own history and consider her next steps in her reborn life at the hands of the Green. The most intriguing part of this issue lies in witnessing Pam confront her self-doubt and insecurities. While it seems we’re treading familiar ground with repeated introspective moments, it also underscores that healing isn’t a straightforward process — and now the stakes have never been higher. – Nicole Drum
Rating: 3 out of 5

In simple, conversational terms:

I’m really enjoying the new Two-Face comic series! It’s off to a great start with its entertaining and well-crafted storylines, which is impressive given that we’ve only seen two episodes so far. The creators, Ward and Veras, are doing an outstanding job with Harvey Dent. This series stands out as one of DC’s best comics currently, and it’s definitely among the top supervillain-focused books I’ve read in a while.

Even though Two-Face might not be as popular as characters like The Joker or The Penguin (with the latter enjoying success from his MAX series), this series could change that if more people give it a chance. It’s really good! – Evan Valentine

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Marvel

Cable: Love and Chrome #1 – A Fresh Take on a Complex Character

Nathan Christopher Dayspring Askani’son Summers, the enigmatic Cable, returns in the first issue of the new limited series, “Cable: Love and Chrome.” This series is penned by David Pepose, illustrated by Mike Henderson, colored by Arif Prianto, and lettered by Joe Sabino.

Cable, a character with a complex backstory that Marvel often revisits, is presented here without any such retelling. Instead, the opening sequence showcases Cable in action, effectively capturing the essence of the character without delving into his extensive history. The fast-paced artwork and engaging action sequences add to this brisk introduction.

The rest of the issue finds Cable in an uncommon situation, one where he is accepted and even bonded with, despite his unusual life and condition. While many Cable comics have focused on him as a soldier, time traveler, or hero, fewer have explored him as a person living with a chronic disease. This unique perspective lends a fresh feel to the series.

However, there are questions about whether the series will fully deliver on its premise. For instance, will the new villain introduced in the opening scenes contribute significantly to the overall narrative? Can the comic sustain this thematic portrayal of Cable effectively throughout the series? Nonetheless, the debut issue is promising and full of potential.

Review: 3.5 out of 5 stars – Jamie Lovett

In issue #17, Ahmed and Kuder bring back the Guardian Devil of Hell’s Kitchen, as Matt grapples with a supernatural peril that aligns more closely with his growing connection to the Catholic Church. Saladin skillfully portrays Murdock’s thoughts, with Daredevil patrolling the city to fight crime. Aaron Kuder’s artwork shines in this narrative, masterfully depicting both the earthly and supernatural elements of the current storyline. The series remains strong, a hallmark of any Daredevil arc due to Murdock’s uncanny ability to avoid danger that other Marvel characters often can’t. This comic series remains one of Marvel’s finest. – Evan Valentine

Rating: 4 out of 5

As a long-time fan of Marvel Comics, I can confidently say that the pairing of Deadpool and Wolverine is one of my all-time favorites. Over the years, I’ve read countless stories featuring these two iconic characters, and I have to admit that I always look forward to seeing what fresh chaos they will stir up next.

With Marvel Studios successfully bringing their unique brand of mayhem to the big screen in Deadpool & Wolverine, I couldn’t help but feel excited about the prospect of diving back into a new comic book adventure starring these two titans. And let me tell you, Deadpool/Wolverine #1 did not disappoint!

While the storyline follows a classic formula, the dynamic between Deadpool and Wolverine is anything but ordinary. The writers have managed to breathe new life into their relationship, creating moments that are both humorous and poignant in equal measure. Moreover, the artwork throughout this issue is simply stunning, with every panel brimming with energy and detail.

All things considered, I wholeheartedly recommend Deadpool/Wolverine #1 to any fan of these characters. It’s a must-read for anyone who appreciates well-crafted comic book storytelling, and I can’t wait to see where this series goes from here!

In the comic book series “Miles Morales: Spider-Man #28,” it’s been delightful to see Miles spending time in Wakanda, unlike some forced and frustrating character team-ups in other solo series. The interaction with Bast and the ancient gods offers an exciting twist, presenting situations we don’t usually encounter. This adventure has been quite enjoyable, according to Charlie Ridgely (who gave it a rating of 4 out of 5).

Exploring the Adventures of Ghost Spider (Issue #9)

In this latest installment of Ghost Spider’s escapades within the Marvel 616 universe, Black Tarantula dominates the spotlight as he squares off against Mr. Fear. While Gwen Stacy, aka Ghost Spider, isn’t absent from the storyline entirely, she grapples with the harmful toxin in her system. This issue may not surpass its predecessor significantly, but it effectively showcases the fresh surroundings that Spider-Gwen has created for herself and hints at the perils lurking in her original reality. Although there are a few flaws in Ghost Spider’s character development, overall, there is more positive content to be appreciated.

Rating: 3 out of 5

Occasionally, a shift in tone is beneficial, even within the realm of superheroes, and The Avengers #22 seems like a refreshing change of scenery. Despite the grandeur that comes with a team this powerful, Jed MacKay manages to maintain the sense of magnitude while zeroing in on something universally appealing – a heist. This setup provides ample room for engaging conversations among team members, and MacKay makes the most of it with some exceptional interactions between characters such as Scarlet Witch and Storm, Iron Man and Captain Marvel, and others. The Oceans 11 atmosphere is expertly conveyed by Farid Karami, Federico Blee, and Cory Petit, emphasizing the disguises and underhanded tactics at play in the casino setting. The intrigue of the game within a game concept is intriguing as well, though it could potentially be the weakest aspect of the storyline. Only time will tell, but any opportunity to include Black Cat is a plus, especially with MacKay at the helm. – Matthew Aguilar
Rating: 4 out of 5

As a movie critic, I’d say, “Diving into The Spectacular Spider-Men #11 is like stepping into a whirlwind of fun! In this team-up issue featuring Peter and Miles, the Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Men find themselves in quite a pickle. Weisman masterfully crafts a miniature escapade for our web-slinging duo while introducing a fresh Spider-person to the mix. It’s jam-packed with action, but it never loses its charm.

However, Genolet and Randal’s artwork, while vibrant, can occasionally feel a bit uneven compared to previous issues. But that’s just a minor hiccup on this thrilling ride. If not for Ultimate Spider-Man, The Spectacular Spider-Men would undoubtedly be the standout Spidey comic out there.

Overall, I’d rate it 4 out of 5.”

– Evan Valentine

In issue #8 of The Ultimates, Deniz Camp portrays America Chavez as the embodiment of the American dream, a dream that was corrupted and manipulated to support a far more sinister reality. This comic book unfolds America’s origin story in a heartfelt manner, revealing that her lost utopian future, filled with vibrant and diverse heroes, was stolen by the same oppressive forces she sought to defeat. Artists Juan Frigeri and Federico Blee bring this forgotten utopia to life through their vivid illustrations. America’s unwavering determination to protect those who didn’t benefit from her lost utopia showcases her character’s resilience and dedication to the Ultimates’ mission. Camp also hints at ominous events looming over The Ultimates, suggesting their cause may ultimately fail and that one of their own could be responsible for their downfall and that of many others. This issue poses thought-provoking questions about whether it’s worth continuing the fight in the face of certain failure, loss, and betrayal, setting the stage for an exciting second year in the Marvel Ultimate Universe.
Rating: 4 out of 5

As a long-time Marvel comic enthusiast who has been following the Werewolf By Night series since its inception, I must admit that my expectations were somewhat higher for this issue #6. I have always found the unique blend of horror and supernatural elements in the Werewolf By Night comics to be quite intriguing, but unfortunately, this installment fell short for me.

The writing by Jason Loo seemed to focus more on gruesome spectacle than on a compelling narrative. While it’s true that the artwork by Ton Lima and Alex Sinclair is visually stunning, with their depictions of wild monsters and bizarre blood adding an extra layer of creepiness to each panel, I found myself struggling to connect with the story itself. The plot seemed to meander aimlessly, lacking a cohesive structure that would tie everything together for all the characters present.

Despite its shortcomings, it’s nice to see Marvel acknowledging and continuing to explore this lesser-known corner of their pantheon. It’s just a shame that the execution didn’t quite meet the mark in this instance. I’m hoping future issues will offer a more satisfying reading experience for both new and long-time fans alike.

In terms of rating, I would give Werewolf By Night #6 a 2.5 out of 5 stars.

As a longtime fan of Marvel comics, I found myself picking up “What If…? Galactus Transformed Hulk #1” with a mix of excitement and curiosity. Having followed Bruce Banner’s character development over the years, I was eager to see how this unique spin on the “what if” concept would unfold.

The storyline delves into exploring Bruce’s vulnerability and insecurity, something that has always been a central part of his character. It was refreshing to see these aspects of his personality brought to the forefront and manipulated in an intriguing way. The issue served as a thought-provoking read, raising questions about the nature of power, identity, and loyalty.

However, I must admit that the resolution felt a bit too simplistic and rushed, glossing over the complexities of the Avengers’ treatment of Hulk. As a single issue, it never delved too deeply into these themes, but it certainly left room for further exploration in future installments.

The design of Herald Bruce was also intriguing, adding an extra layer of interest to the story. All in all, I would give “What If…? Galactus Transformed Hulk #1” a rating of 3 out of 5. It’s not perfect, but it offers a fresh take on a classic character and leaves fans with plenty to ponder.

As a long-time comic book reader and collector, I found myself both intrigued and somewhat disappointed with X-Factor #6. On one hand, it feels like the series is finding its footing as the first arc draws to a close, with sharp artwork by Bob Quinn and some genuinely funny moments in the dialogue. However, something about the tone just didn’t sit right with me – perhaps it’s due to the current state of the world, but Mark Russell’s usually satirical approach comes off as nihilistically cynical here, making the characters seem either morally compromised or utterly foolish.

The character scene involving Pyro and Cecilia Reyes was a nice touch, but overall the series has been playing fast and loose with its characters and direction in a way that leaves me feeling a bit unmoored. I’m hopeful that the upcoming changes and revelations at the end of this issue will lead to a more cohesive and assured direction going forward, but with multiple tie-in issues on the horizon, it’s hard to say for sure.

In short, X-Factor is enjoyable enough to read, but I can’t shake the feeling that something is missing and off in the story. As someone who has been following this series for a while now, I’m eager to see where it goes next, but I can’t help but feel a bit let down by this latest installment.

In this issue of X-Force #7, the spotlight moves from Forge, Sage, and shifts to Askani and Captain Britain as they work diligently within the tranquil surroundings of Askani’s mind to preserve her hastily reconstructed physical form. This shift in focus brings a refreshing change, stepping away from complex sci-fi jargon towards a more emotional narrative that artist Jim Towe excels in portraying. The dramatic turn of events later on has even greater impact, despite the new villain from the previous issue still lacking clarity within the X-Force universe. All in all, it’s the strongest X-Force issue so far, although the series continues to seek a more defined identity. – Jamie Lovett

Rating: 3 out of 5

OTHER PUBLISHERS

As a sports enthusiast with a background in various athletic activities but little to no knowledge or personal interest in fencing, I found “Fence Challengers: Sweet Sixteen #1” to be a rather dry and lengthy read. While it’s great that the author attempts to humanize the athletes by including some of their personal stories, the repetitive nature of the fencing bouts made the narrative feel monotonous and lost much of the drama and tension for me. If you’re an avid fencing fan, this book might be right up your alley, but for those like myself who seek a more engaging and varied reading experience, it might not quite hit the mark. Rating: 2.5 out of 5.

As a devoted fan of Rick and Morty, I found the “New Year, New Rick Special #1” to be a faithful representation of the series from start to finish. Each character was given a captivating storyline that truly resonated with the show’s spirit. However, the dialogue in this comic didn’t quite reach the heights set by the TV series. If the witty banter and clever exchanges were as sharp and engaging as usual, this book would have been even more exceptional. All things considered, I’d rate it a solid 3 out of 5. – Charlie Ridgely

Hey there fellow comic enthusiasts! Over the past week, I’ve been diving deep into the world of comics once again, and let me tell you, it’s been a real treat. There were several titles that really stood out to me this week, each one offering a unique blend of storytelling, artistry, and character development. If you’re keen on discussing all things comics, I’d love to chat with you over at Bluesky @KnightofOA! Here are my top picks from the week:

1. “The Walking Dead” – Issue #193 was a heart-pounding installment that left me on the edge of my seat. The tension between our favorite characters and new threats is palpable, and Robert Kirkman never fails to keep me guessing.

2. “Saga” – I can’t get enough of this space opera! Brian K. Vaughan’s storytelling and Fiona Staples’ artistry combine to create a rich, imaginative world that I can’t wait to explore more of.

3. “Spider-Man” – Nick Spencer has been knocking it out of the park with his run on this title. The latest issue had me laughing out loud and rooting for our friendly neighborhood Spider-Man all at once.

4. “Batman: White Knight” – Sean Murphy’s take on Batman is unlike anything I’ve ever seen before, and it’s a must-read for any comic fan. The latest issue was a masterclass in storytelling and character development.

5. “Invincible” – This series has been a favorite of mine for years now, and the latest arc is no exception. Robert Kirkman never disappoints with his epic storylines and unforgettable characters.

So, what were your favorite comics this week? Let’s geek out together on Bluesky @KnightofOA! See you there!

Read More

2025-01-02 04:12