Comic Book Reviews for This Week: 12/26/2024

As a seasoned comic book enthusiast and connoisseur of all things pop culture, I find myself utterly captivated by the diverse and dynamic offerings we have this week. From the gritty action-packed G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero #312 to the chilling suspense of Redcoat #8, it’s clear that these creators are pouring their hearts into every panel they draw.

Enjoy the arrival of a fresh batch of comics! This week is packed with significant comic book titles, and our team at ComicBook has put their heads together to dissect and evaluate as many of the prominent comics hitting the shelves today as we can. While we won’t be covering every single comic being published, we’re diving deep into new issues from Marvel, DC, Image Comics, BOOM! Studios, Dark Horse, Dynamite, Oni Press, IDW, Mad Cave Studios, DSTLRY, and other notable publishers!

This week, we’ve set aside extra room to delve deeper into two highly anticipated comic books – Dust to Dust #1 and Hellhunters #1. If the brief reviews below catch your eye, be sure to explore our full reviews for a more thorough analysis of these issues. We rate each book using a whole or half number out of five, and you can find some examples of our past reviews here. Now, let’s dive into this week’s new comic releases!

DC

A New Peak in Absolute Wonder Woman #3

In this review by Nicole Drum, she discusses Action Comics #1081. The storyline resolves the Phantom Zone conflict, but Drum suggests it feels a bit too neat and tidy in its resolution. After establishing Xa-Du and the Zoners as significant threats, the story concludes with some deception on Superman’s part, followed by hope for their redemption due to his actions. Mon-El’s tale also wraps up nicely, but Drum hopes they revisit his storyline in the future. As for the Supergirl story, it too ends, but leaves many questions unanswered, making its purpose a bit murky, although it appears to be a lesson about Krypton for Kara. Overall, she enjoyed the 12-week run of these stories, but felt that their conclusions were not as epic as they could have been. She rates it 3 out of 5.

In Batman: Brave and the Bold #20, there are four captivating tales unfolding. Two of these, Man’s Underworld Part 2 and Hive Mind Part 2, continue previous narratives. However, The Price and The Tattoo could be the highlights. The Price combines Bat-Mite, Zatanna, humor, charm, and intrigue in a delightful way, while The Tattoo, skillfully crafted by Simone Di Meo, delves deeply into Bruce’s anxiety. Overall, this issue is well-executed with these engaging stories, making it a pleasure to read. – Nicole Drum
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

In a slight deviation from the preceding tales, Batman The Long Halloween: The Last Halloween #4 delves deeper into Robin’s narrative, exploring his emotional turmoil and the extremes he’s willing to reach to safeguard Batman, his adopted father, following a series of tragedies. Set during the festive Christmas season, this issue offers a heartwarming tale that combines action with affection, all while maintaining the enigma surrounding Gotham City’s events and emphasizing family values. It’s also rewarding to witness Robin in his element. – Nicole Drum
Rating: 4 out of 5

In Detective Comics #1092, Bruce Wayne encounters an old acquaintance offering him a potential elixir for immortality, but with a twist as suspicions arise about the true intentions behind Sangraal. The narrative straddles the balance between this character potentially being a recurring villain and a profound exploration of how Bruce and Scarlett dealt with their past traumas. Mikel Janin employs varying line weights to give his rugged, loosely muscled figures a prominent presence on the page, while his colors create an atmospheric feel for each location visited, from the sterile brightness of Scarlett’s lab to the tense, dramatic scenes illuminated by police lights. This issue doesn’t feature the major plot twists seen in the first two installments, but it excels through strong artwork, engaging dialogue, and overall top-notch storytelling, making it the best chapter yet of “Mercy of the Father.” – Jamie Lovett

In the following review, I’ll discuss Green Arrow #19, a remarkable comic that showcases one of the most impactful opening scenes I’ve come across recently. The story begins with a flashback, where time seems to slow as groceries cascade down panel tiers, mirroring a frantic mother rushing to her fallen child’s side – these are moments that irrevocably alter a woman’s life. This page, masterfully crafted by the entire creative team, evokes a cinematic feel with Hassan Otsmane-Elhaou’s lettering standing out particularly well. His innovative approach to word balloons, such as making the sick child’s fading breath appear to emerge from his mouth rather than project forth, adds emotional depth to the scene.

Review of Harley Quinn #46

“Justice League Unlimited #2 Review

Metamorpho: The Element Man #1

Power Girl Issue 16 showcases an intriguing dynamic between Power Girl and Ejecta, where their interactions oscillate between sharp and confounding. The narrative never lags in speed or intensity. This ongoing rivalry has a lot more to unfold, leaving me eager for their next encounter. – Charlie Ridgely

Marvel

In the Amazing Spider-Man #64, written by Justina Ireland, the ongoing issues of “The 8 Deaths of Spider-Man” exhibit a deeper emotional tone compared to the lighter, more playful stories penned by Joe Kelly. This issue delves into Peter Parker’s escalating superhero responsibilities causing him anxiety, which is particularly relevant when dealing with adversaries symbolizing life’s inevitable hardships, such as pain and death. The artwork in this issue leans towards a somber tone, with its blurred coloring resembling a soft camera filter, subtly dampening the vibrancy of the illustrations. However, the narrative structure could use improvement. The story concludes with Spider-Man fighting another of Cytorrak’s scions, following the usual episodic pattern. Yet, the simplicity with which Spider-Man emerges victorious, accentuated by a growing panel size into a hazy, unclear two-page spread, suggests more about the scion than it does about Spidey. This would be acceptable if the scion had demonstrated any depth or lasting impact beyond being a disposable monthly villain. Unfortunately, this has not been the case, leaving the issue with some compelling moments but ultimately feeling underwhelming.

In the third installment of Blade’s ongoing saga, we delve deeper into the antagonist Eric Brooks is currently battling following the Blood Hunt. The latest vampire menace presents an intriguing twist to its methods, but it fails to address some concerns I had with the first two issues. Namely, there’s not enough exploration of Blade’s character, despite recent comic book crossovers that could have provided more depth. Red Band doesn’t quite live up to its potential in terms of intensity and intimacy. – Evan Valentine

I’ve grown particularly fond of the exceptional X-Men series, and issue #4 solidifies its position among my favorites. Writer Eve L. Ewing infuses fresh energy and a unique perspective into new recruits like Melee, Axo, and Bronze, which sets this series apart from many continuity barriers. In issue #4, the spotlight is on Bronze, creating an intriguing contrast with the larger-than-life characters of White Queen and Iceman. Meanwhile, the enigma surrounding Kate’s choice to separate herself from everyone deepens, adding a captivating layer of mystery to an already engaging narrative. Artists Carmen Carnero and Nolan Woodard breathe life into Bronze and the entire cast with their intricate characterizations, delivering both epic action sequences and poignant emotional moments that leave me eagerly awaiting the next installment. This team may be newcomers in the X-Men universe, but they’re quickly establishing themselves as one of the best. – Matthew Aguilar
Rating: 4.5 out of 5

In a fresh take on World War II’s historical backdrop, Marvel Comics introduces a unique battalion called the Hellhunters, a group of superheroes unlike any previously seen. This new team, still in its infancy as depicted in the debut issue, is poised to make an impact similar to iconic squads like the Invaders and Howling Commandos, who were instrumental in the fight against Nazi forces. As we delve into the early stages of this new Marvel ensemble, one can’t help but wonder if it will live up to the legacy set by its predecessors – Evan Valentine
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 (Read the full review here)

In this third installment of Spencer Ackerman’s reimagining of Iron Man, we find an intriguing blend of the exhilarating chaos typical of the Marvel Universe, alongside some unexpected twists. The tale weaves together a thrilling Iron Man battle and Tony Stark’s unconventional boardroom brawl, creating a comical and captivating narrative. Artist Julius Ohta expertly portrays the dynamic settings and action that accompany Tony Stark’s current rollercoaster journey. Though it is slightly disappointing to see the Stark-Roxxon War seemingly concluded in this issue, the storyline remains an engaging ride through Tony’s latest escapades. – Evan Valentine

As a cinephile, I must admit that while Mystique #3 isn’t always razor-sharp in its focus, the core narrative still keeps me hooked from start to finish. The interplay between Fury and Mystique is a match made in storytelling heaven for a thrilling game of cat-and-mouse. It would be quite the challenge to concoct an uninteresting tale around these two characters! – Charlie Ridgely

In Rogue Sun #24, the comic masterfully combines the intrigue of past events with the thrill of current happenings, making both aspects crucial to the overall narrative. The past shapes the present and lays the groundwork for future developments, all within a single standard-sized issue. This is a perfect demonstration of storytelling craftsmanship. – Charlie Ridgely

Title Slot 1:

Title Review: Ultimate Black Panther #11

Gerry Duggan’s writing style is light-hearted, humorous, but risks making all characters too similar, which may dilute their individual personalities.

Review of X-Men #9

Image Comics

Dust to Dust #1 Review

Geiger #9 is predominantly action-packed, as Geiger engages in a perilous confrontation with the new King that potentially endangers not only the town he’s discovered but also has profound effects on Geiger personally. The action is engaging, and there’s a touching near-sacrifice by a friend, but what truly shines is Geiger’s message to the adults in the town. Pivotal moments of empathy make this an intriguing read, with a poignant moment from a grieving father offering advice about how their protective measures might unintentionally harm others really resonating. – Reviewer’s Name

In the 312th issue of G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero, Larry Hama skillfully crafts two contrasting sequences with distinctive endings, both stemming from the conflict between contemporary and archaic warfare tactics. Destro’s technological superiority overcomes the Cobra forces he encounters, while the G.I. Joe ninja team triumphs against overwhelming odds, despite their apparent disadvantage in firepower. This issue is essentially Destro’s story, as he wreaks havoc through Springfield like a tempest. Chris Mooneyham and Francesco Segala brilliantly capture this turbulent atmosphere using dynamic visuals, expressive lighting, intricate panel arrangements, and a rich color palette. G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero #312 is an exhilarating read that races by due to its gripping content, particularly as the primary character in this intricate web of high-stakes deception finally succumbs. If you’re after gritty, adrenaline-fueled comics, G.I. Joe: A Real American Hero should be at the top of your list. Larry Hama and his team have consistently delivered quality for years and show no signs of slowing down. – Rating: 4.5 out of 5

In the recent installment of Redcoat, character #8 Simon Pure finds himself entangled in a predicament reminiscent of Texas Chainsaw Massacre’s antagonists. Geoff Johns and Bryan Hitch continue to excel in their storytelling, presenting the protagonist locked in combat with this family-like group. This standalone issue offers an entertaining and relaxed reading experience, but it falls short compared to the series’ established themes of time travel and mysticism, except for the concluding pages. Although Redcoat has been operating independently within the Ghost Machine series, it appears that this may soon change. While there is much to appreciate in this individual issue, it might not be essential reading for the broader narrative arc. – Rating: 3.5 out of 5 (Evan Valentine)

In the thrilling world of Void Rivals #15, there’s no shortage of action! However, with so many characters and plotlines moving simultaneously, it can be challenging to fully appreciate this series within the Energon Universe. Don’t get me wrong, following a motley crew of beloved Transformers and GI Joe characters is enjoyable, but the cosmic adventure doesn’t seem to coalesce as smoothly as one might expect. Robert Kirkman’s world creation and Lorenzo De Felici’s artwork do their jobs well, yet they don’t quite reach the heights that have made this new Skybound universe so captivating. If you’re a die-hard Energon fan, you’ll find enough to keep you engaged, but newcomers might find themselves bewildered. – Evan Valentine

Read More

2024-12-27 02:11