DCU’s Risky Superman Move: DCEU Mistakes Loom?

by

Recently, there’s been a surge of optimism surrounding the DC Universe (DCU). The upcoming unveiling of the new Superman production has put the DCU at the forefront of everyone’s thoughts, which is definitely a good sign. The forthcoming Superman project by DC Studios head James Gunn holds much promise and seems to be setting the DCU on a course for an exciting future. Frankly, this wasn’t something that we ever thought would become reality for fans of DC. The previous attempt at DC superhero movies, the DCEU, was marked by numerous flops and failed to resonate with anyone except the most dedicated followers of director Zack Snyder, who largely distanced himself from it following Snyder’s departure. The DCEU was a qualified failure, and the fact that the DCU is now bathed in positivity represents a significant shift.

The setbacks experienced by the DCEU weren’t solely due to one cause, but a significant contributor was the lackluster world-building. Instead of capitalizing on the strengths of DC Comics, the DCEU often disappointed fans. Despite the excitement surrounding the DCU, it could still falter if it repeats the same errors as the DCEU. World-building is crucial for a franchise as expansive as the DCU, and it must learn from past mistakes to succeed.

The DCU Needs to Remember the Key to Worldbuilding Is Storytelling

In a less hurried approach, the DCEU’s major oversight – a mistake that even seems evident in films like Superman – was rushing through their storylines. Man of Steel may not have been a blockbuster hit, but it performed decently at the box office and garnered positive reviews from critics. However, Warner Bros., eager to reap some of the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s financial success, decided to condense the work done by Marvel Studios in Phase One into a single film – Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice.

In simpler terms, the problem with the DCEU’s world-building lies in their attempt to cram too many new characters into a single movie, such as Batman v Superman. Instead of gradually introducing these characters, they were all introduced in a crowded scene, alongside established characters like Batman, Lex Luthor, and Wonder Woman. This approach was ambitious, but it may have been more effective to focus on a fewer number of characters, such as Batman, Superman, and perhaps Wonder Woman, rather than trying to introduce lesser-known characters like the Flash, Cyborg, and Aquaman all at once. Warner Bros., in their eagerness to reach the ensemble style of The Avengers movies, may have rushed the process of character development for these new DC Universe members.

Initially, it’s clear that there are numerous parallels between the film Superman and Batman v Superman. Notably, several DC characters debut in Superman, and it might seem like a blunder to introduce these characters without prior knowledge. However, the main issue with the introduction of characters such as Flash, Cyborg, and Aquaman in Batman v Superman wasn’t their presence itself, but rather that their appearance had no significant impact on the plot. To effectively incorporate new characters, they need to be integral to the storyline. This is why Batman worked well within Batman v Superman, as he played a crucial role in the narrative.

As a passionate cinephile, I’d like to emphasize that when it comes to crafting a universe as expansive as Superman and the DCU, it’s crucial to remember that world-building is essentially storytelling in disguise. It’s not just about populating the screen with an array of characters; it’s about integrating them into the narrative in a meaningful way.

Characters like Mister Terrific, Hawkgirl, Guy Gardner, and Metamorpho appear to be playing significant roles in Superman’s story, which is precisely how it should be. Their presence isn’t merely to confirm the existence of this universe; it’s to enrich the narrative and make it more immersive.

Unfortunately, the DCEU didn’t always grasp this concept, and I believe they could learn from this approach. By weaving these characters into the story, they become integral parts of the universe rather than mere cameos that leave audiences scratching their heads.

The DCU Needs to Embrace the Strengths of DC Comics

One issue with the world-building of the DCEU is that it failed to fully capture the essence of DC Comics. Initially, the DCEU presented itself as a darker counterpart to the MCU, but this overlooked the fact that DC Comics aren’t inherently dark. Characters like Superman and Batman are defined by ideals such as hope and justice, respectively. Superman often saves cats from trees for children, not because he finds it amusing, but because it embodies his spirit of compassion. Similarly, Batman’s crusade against crime stems from a desire to prevent loss of life, rather than a thirst for vengeance. DC stories are usually light-hearted adventures featuring characters who bring joy and have dedicated fanbases. The DCEU struggled to find the right balance in its tone, which significantly impacted its success.

The DC Universe faces a challenging task ahead. Up until recently, DC hasn’t enjoyed the best reputation in the realm of superhero entertainment, with many fans still hesitant about their favorites from DC. To achieve the same level of success as the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the DCU must avoid repeating the world-building blunders made by the DCEU and instead learn from them. Constructing a universe is as much about storytelling as it is about introducing characters, and if the DCU manages to get it right, success should naturally follow.

Superman will premiere in theaters on July 11th.

Read More

2025-05-19 06:10