Disney’s Live-Action Remakes Flop Or Fly Based on One Shocking Decade-Old Secret Revealed!

by

For the past decade, Disney has been churning out live-action adaptations of their classic films, with some receiving rave reviews while others have sparked controversy. Interestingly, the movies that have garnered the most attention share a common trait. Although Disney started dabbling in live-action remakes as early as the late ’90s, it wasn’t until 2015, with the successful launch of Cinderella, that this trend truly gained momentum. Since then, Disney has given modern spins to beloved tales like The Little Mermaid, Aladdin, The Jungle Book, and Mulan, earning varying levels of acclaim, but without following any discernible pattern.

It seems that Disney’s live-action remakes often face criticism, regardless of their cinematic quality. This backlash is amplified whenever a Disney movie underperforms. The latest instance is the contentious Snow White film, which was embroiled in off-screen turmoil even before its release. Now that it’s received poor reviews, people are curious about other factors influencing the success of Disney’s live-action movies.

Disney’s Most Successful Live-Action Remakes Adapt 90s Animated Movies

Disney’s 90s Remakes Are Big Box Office Earners (Regardless Of Critical Reception)

An intriguing detail about Disney’s live-action reboots is that the movies initially released in the 1990s have generally outperformed those that are significantly older at the box office. For instance, in 2019, Disney launched the live-action versions of both The Lion King and Aladdin, which originally premiered in the 1990s. Remarkably, both reboots raked in a colossal sum: over $1 billion for Aladdin and nearly $1 billion for The Lion King. This is significantly more than other Disney live-action remakes from earlier periods, such as Snow White, which didn’t even gross $200 million.

It’s worth mentioning that the ’90s live-action reboots have been commercially successful, but they haven’t always received positive reviews from critics. For instance, Aladdin made over $1 billion, yet its Rotten Tomatoes score stands at a modest 57%. Similarly, The Lion King managed to pull in $1.6 billion with a rating of 51%. However, these scores suggest that Disney may be missing something, as even their best efforts haven’t quite hit the mark. In contrast, The Little Mermaid stands out as the only ’90s live-action remake that has managed to make an impact both at the box office and with critics, earning a revenue of $569 million and a score of 67% on Rotten Tomatoes.

Disney’s Live-Action Remakes Of Older Animated Movies, Like Snow White, Are Tougher Sells

What Disney Has Done Wrong & Right With Its Older Remakes

Disney’s 1990s live-action remakes have generally been successful, but their earlier remakes have had mixed results. While there have been undeniably successful films like “Alice in Wonderland” (2010) and “The Jungle Book” (2016), more recent adaptations such as “Dumbo,” “Pinocchio,” and “Snow White” have left audiences not just dissatisfied, but aggravated with Disney. These movies have garnered Rotten Tomatoes scores below 50%, with “Pinocchio” and “Snow White” being criticized as some of Disney’s worst live-action films to date. It is worth noting that all three of these films were originally released before 1940.

When Disney reimagines its classic animated films into live-action, they face a tough challenge, especially with movies like Dumbo or Snow White. Disney must decide how much of the original story to preserve and how much to modernize. This process often leads to controversy since many changes don’t sit well with audiences. Furthermore, all three remakes heavily rely on computer-generated imagery (CGI), which has not been met with favorable reactions by viewers. The excessive use of hyperrealistic CGI has taken away the charm from movies like Dumbo, making them less appealing to many people.

Why Disney’s Live-Action Remakes Of 90s Movies Are Better Set Up To Succeed

Disney’s 90s Movies Already Have A Modern Flair

The 1990s Disney films hold a special appeal compared to older ones because they were produced recently and therefore feel more contemporary. Movies such as The Little Mermaid and The Lion King, which emerged just a few decades ago, still resonate deeply with those who grew up watching them, making them eager to share these stories with their own children. In contrast, while Snow White is undeniably a Disney classic, it may not seem as engaging or relatable to modern audiences as the more recent productions, thus limiting its potential audience compared to the 90s films. Consequently, Disney benefits from having a broader range of viewers for their 1990s movies in comparison to those from the 1940s.

In addition, Disney’s ’90s films don’t require significant updates to seem contemporary. Characters like Ariel in “The Little Mermaid” and Jasmine in “Aladdin,” for instance, exhibit strong opinions and independence, frequently acting on their own decisions, even when others expect otherwise. On the other hand, Snow White’s primary desire is to be rescued by a prince, which is a more traditional portrayal. Since Disney faces criticism for altering their original stories, the ’90s films were already leaning towards modern ideas, while Snow White needed substantial updates to resonate with 2025 sensibilities.

Disney Still Has Other 90s Animated Movies They Can Do Live-Action Remakes Of

How Disney Can Improve Their 90s Remakes’ RT Scores

Following the disappointing performance of “Snow White,” Disney might be inclined to revisit their ’90s films that have a proven track record of box office success and critical acclaim. Lucky for them, they possess an abundance of choices such as “Hercules,” “The Hunchback of Notre Dame,” and “Tarzan.” Boasting captivating music, vibrant backdrops, and engaging narratives, any of these films could become a hit with live-action remakes. At present, Disney is working on remaking “Hercules” with Guy Ritchie as the director. Interestingly, “Lilo & Stitch,” though it premiered in 2002, can still be considered a ’90s film for discussion purposes.

Every Upcoming Disney Live-Action Remake Release Date
Lilo & Stitch May 23, 2025
Moana July 10, 2026
Hercules TBA
Robin Hood TBA
The Aristocats TBA
Bambi TBA

In summary, while Disney has achieved impressive box office figures with their live-action remakes, they still need to improve these productions to meet both critical and audience expectations. A well-received movie is more likely to garner substantial earnings. Given the success of “The Little Mermaid,” Disney certainly has the potential to enhance the quality of its strongest live-action adaptations even further.

Disney Is Already Starting To Move Past 90s Live-Action Remakes Too

Lilo & Stitch Could Be A Welcome Change For Disney

Disney has enjoyed considerable success with their 90s remakes; however, they seem to be venturing into even more ambitious projects now. Specifically, Lilo & Stitch is the initial 2000s film that Disney plans to adapt into a live-action version. Furthermore, Moana and Tangled are also on the docket, although Tangled’s premiere has been pushed back due to delays. As Disney embarks on this new phase of live-action remakes, there’s potential for great success or the possibility of repeating past missteps.

With the trailer of Lilo & Stitch appearing quite promising, combining realistic CGI with animation, there’s good reason to feel hopeful. If this film performs well in May 2025, it could mark a step towards Disney recovering from the aftermath of Snow White. To maintain momentum, Moana and future releases will need to be just as impressive. For now, let’s hope that Lilo & Stitch proves to be a success, potentially paving the way for improvement in Disney’s live-action remakes.

Read More

2025-04-27 12:38