Dope Girls: The Bold New Drama That Will Split Audiences!

*This piece is based on the first three episodes of Dope Girls*

During a presentation for the series titled “Dope Girls,” which was described as a follow-up in essence to “Peaky Blinders” by media at its debut, the panel moderator inquired about the team’s expectations regarding audience reception. Specifically, they wondered if their aim was to attract both ardent fans of period dramas and a newer, more contemporary audience who might not typically be drawn to such period pieces?

As an advocate, I echo Jane Tranter’s sentiments. “I strive to create a production that is as diverse and inclusive as possible in its creation,” I say. “My aim is to ensure that the audience reflects this inclusivity. Therefore, I don’t approach it thinking, ‘They might not appreciate it, but it will be for them.’

To be frank, I find it hard to accept that someone might create “Dope Girls” unaware of its unique character. This particular TV show is bound to repel just as many viewers as it appeals to, given its distinct style.

This isn’t like “Peaky Blinders”. Instead, it presents a unique challenge, appearing intentionally provocative and redefining the boundaries of what period dramas, with a focus on crime, could or should encompass.

In this six-episode series, Julianne Nicholson portrays Kate Galloway, a character whose life begins to disintegrate following the conclusion of World War I.

To safeguard her daughter Evie (Eilidh Fisher), she teams up with free-spirited dancer Billie Cassidy (Umi Myers) and establishes a nightclub in the vibrant neighborhood of Soho during the year 1918.

In her adoption of a questionable criminal path, Kate becomes a focus for both shady characters and law enforcement, which comprises Violet Davies (Eliza Scanlen) – a complex woman who is part of the early wave of female police officers.

As a devoted cinephile, the initial impression I get from this series is its distinct aesthetic. It’s a visually, audibly, and emotionally captivating drama that stands out due to its daring costume design and innovative production elements.

The music by experimental vocalists and electronic artists NYX is exceptional, adding an edge of intensity, thrill, and energy to the drama, and the show further experiments with innovative subtitles and visual effects on screen.

As a connoisseur of cinema, I must admit that the visual spectacle, the unconventional sound design, and the eye-catching costumes I’m witnessing aren’t entirely novel. They’ve been seen before in other productions. However, it’s rare to find such elements so effectively used in period dramas as Peaky Blinders does with its iconic flatcap.

Director Shannon Murphy, renowned for her projects like Babyteeth and episodes of Killing Eve, expressed during a Q&A session for the series that she refers to the genre as “period-schmperiod.” She mentioned that she aimed to avoid debates about details such as door handles or clothing choices like whether someone would wear tights at the time. Instead, her focus was on ensuring that if it looked visually appealing, they would go ahead with it.

The team acknowledged the distinction between authenticity and reality, expressing their lack of enthusiasm for pursuing the former, but emphasizing their desire to uncover the genuine experience of being a woman during that specific period, in other words, the “truth” of that existence.

Naturally, this philosophy also impacts the substance of the piece.

The version of 1918 London that the series portrays is likely not one that you have seen before.

What this means is, just because certain aspects weren’t shown, it doesn’t mean they didn’t happen. On the contrary, according to writer Alex Warren and his co-writer Polly Stenham, their research revealed that actual life during that period was more intense than what they portrayed on screen, causing our current world to appear dull and safe by comparison.

However, it’s crucial to note that while the show draws inspiration from a specific historical era, its narrative is purely fictional and set in a modern context. There should be no confusion about this being a contemporary, forward-thinking interpretation of history.

The series primarily explores the societal upheaval of its era, specifically how women managed to liberate themselves from patriarchal and societal norms. This theme holds great potential for dramatic conflict, but surprisingly, the show seems to suggest that most characters were involved in this movement.

In Soho and within a particular group of people, we don’t get a clear picture of the broader world, nor do we see much indication that these women and men were breaking societal norms through their behavior. During street festivities, the women’s bold outfits go unnoticed or unremarked upon. Instead, it appears that the artists focused more on depicting the hedonism of the era rather than highlighting its revolutionary nature.

In terms of how the show portrays patriarchy, it’s accurate to say that many of the male characters are indeed detestable. However, the series appears to focus less on complex explorations and more on overt displays, neglecting subtleties such as how societal attitudes seep insidiously beneath the surface.

Instead, we encounter harshly abusive police officers shouting profanities at their female colleagues, and club owners making threats to maim individuals.

The issue lies in the fact that a strong sense of advancement seems to be diminished, as everything appears to be at maximum intensity. A clear illustration of this could be seen with Kate.

Throughout the initial episode, the production team has emphasized Kate’s significant transformation. However, despite numerous challenging events befalling her and situations that seem to push her into decisions one might not expect from her ordinarily, I struggled to perceive this transformation as a grand or meaningful change when watching it unfold on screen.

In my opinion, Kate wasn’t the shy or timid character as portrayed. From the beginning, she displayed boldness and independence, seeming to disregard social norms and traditions.

Instead of portraying a sudden, dramatic change as in “Breaking Bad,” her evolution is more reminiscent of Walter White’s character, who exhibited an underlying darkness from the beginning. Conversely, the transformation seen in “Better Call Saul” occurs gradually and with hesitation.

In Breaking Bad, Walter continued to maintain his family man persona at home initially, leading a double life. On the other hand, in this scenario, Kate’s family has been reduced to only her daughter Evie, which significantly reduces the underlying tension.

Initially, Kate does not waste a moment on trying to pamper or teach Evie traditional values like humility, respect, obedience, and strict moral standards that were prevalent during their era.

At certain moments, it seems more like a fictional account of a different timeline, closer in spirit to “The Handmaid’s Tale” than the usual historical or period-based series.

It’s alright, and this series isn’t afraid to break away from traditional TV genre boundaries. In truth, television viewers generally prefer something fresh and unique over repetitive programming.

However, it’s no surprise that many viewers, especially those who enjoy period dramas, are often very specific about accuracy, as they tend to recognize historical representations that align with their understanding.

After viewing three out of six episodes, I find myself somewhat confused about my own opinions on the show, as they seem mixed up or jumbled together.

I appreciate its boldness and innovative approach to reexamining history from a unique perspective, and I find it visually and auditorily appealing. However, I believe that at times, its aspirations exceed its actual execution, causing its style to overshadow its content. Additionally, its progressive social message is weakened by an absence of contrast, making it less impactful.

On a deeper level, it’s clear to me how the general audience might react. Some people may embrace it as their latest quirky series, while others could take offense at its bold, provocative style and contemporary twist on traditional history narratives.

Remarkably, the television series will be broadcast every Saturday evening. Initially, Peaky Blinders debuted on Thursday nights, whereas its last two seasons were screened on Sundays, a day that is now synonymous with major dramas for the BBC.

On Saturdays, you’ll often find family-friendly fantasy and science fiction shows, like Doctor Who and the classic series Merlin, being broadcast.

Dope Girls is definitely not suitable for all audiences. It contains extensive graphic content, including intense violence, frequent explicit sexual scenes, and strong language.

It exhibits characteristics reminiscent of a BBC Three program, catering primarily to a younger demographic, yet boasts the financial resources, polish, and celebrity appeal similar to a flagship show on BBC One.

Regarding the stars shining brightly up above, let me tell you this – the power of the performances is something that simply can’t be understated. The actors such as Nicholson, Myers, and Fisher are all captivating in their respective roles. Geraldine James plays Isabella Salucci with a gripping intensity, while Dustin Demri-Burns as Damaso delivers a riveting performance, even though they both seem to embody somewhat one-dimensional villains.

Eliza Scanlen truly shines among the cast, and although the hint of a “redeeming arc” suggested by Scanlen could potentially diminish her character’s intrigue, Violet, so far, is a character brimming with depth and complexity. She stands out as the most compelling central figure to follow.

Based on watching just three episodes, it’s challenging for me to make a final judgment about the overall success of the series. This is because I need more episodes to fully grasp the main theme.

It’s clear that the initial episodes come with a strong impact, an introduction that might not resonate positively with every viewer. I have faith that it will attract its fanbase, regardless of its size, but I’m unsure if I’m part of that group just yet.

2025-02-21 04:05

Read More