Every Disney Live-Action Remake Ranked From Best to Worst

Over the last several decades, Disney has adopted an unexpected approach compared to its past: transforming cherished animated tales into live-action films. Initially, this strategy resonated with both seasoned fans and new audiences. However, over time, the studio’s approach evolved, but it didn’t adapt quickly enough to shifts in audience preferences. Not all remakes recaptured the enchantment of the originals, nor did the prequels. The studio has oscillated between innovative concepts and conservative choices. Some films have offered original perspectives, while others failed to meet expectations.

It can be quite challenging to evaluate and rank all these live-action films, as some are visually stunning yet lack strong scriptwriting. However, it’s definitely achievable! Here is a list of every Disney live-action remake ranked according to their quality.

In this way, the sentence is more engaging, easier to read, and maintains the original meaning while using simpler language.

19) Peter Pan & Wendy

As a devoted cinephile, I must say that Disney’s classic tale, Peter Pan, received a fresh perspective with Peter Pan & Wendy, but unfortunately, it fell flat for me. The visual direction was competent, and there were attempts to update certain aspects of the original narrative, but the end product felt rather lackluster. The script failed to introduce anything new, the characters lacked charm, and the tone was overly serious, which didn’t align with the whimsical nature of the story.

The effort to intensify the rivalry between Peter and Captain Hook seemed forced, which weakened the emotional bond with the audience. In the end, it’s a film that doesn’t leave much of an impression compared to more impactful interpretations of the same narrative – such as the 2003 version of Peter Pan, which continues to be far more captivating and cherished in my memory.

18) Pinocchio

In a different voice:

The real-life adaptation of Pinocchio, led by director Robert Zemeckis, Disney’s time-honored tale, and Tom Hanks portraying Geppetto, seemed destined for success. However, it missed the mark in capturing the essence of the original story. Though the narrative follows similar steps, it lacked the magic that made the original so endearing. The combination of CGI and real environments felt disjointed, and the digital characters, particularly Pinocchio, appeared unconvincing. Moreover, the script failed to offer a unique take, leaving viewers with the feeling that the remake was merely a repetition without any new ideas. Consequently, it turned out as a safe yet dull reinterpretation that largely flew under the radar.

17) Mulan

One notable aspect of the animated film Mulan is its memorable music score. Therefore, creating a live-action adaptation without it was quite a daring decision. The creators opted to veer away from the original by adopting a more somber, authentic, and grandiose atmosphere. This approach could potentially work effectively, but the challenge lay in achieving a harmonious balance.

The film reduces the comedic elements, eliminates Mushu, and concentrates heavily on Chinese customs and the protagonist’s internal conflict. The end product is visually breathtaking, yet it seems emotionally detached. The screenplay lacks originality, character growth occurs rapidly, and the heroine’s journey loses much of its emotional resonance without the familiar elements. In the end, the live-action adaptation is more commendable for its ambition than for its achievements.

16) Dumbo

Dumbo’s stunning visuals are unquestionable highlights, but they underscore the fact that breathtaking aesthetics aren’t enough to create an enduring film. The live-action remake attempts to enrich the heartfelt narrative of the original by introducing fresh characters and subplots, yet these additions often detract from what made the animated classic so moving. By prioritizing underdeveloped human characters over Dumbo himself, the emotional heart of the story becomes weaker. Although visually stunning, the film falters due to an inconsistent tone and sluggish pacing in parts. The narrative lacks clarity and warmth as it unfolds, ultimately failing to strike a harmonious balance between preserving the original’s essence and introducing fresh elements, leaving the tale feeling incomplete.

15) Alice in Wonderland

The film adaptation of “Alice in Wonderland,” directed by Tim Burton, was one of Disney’s initial forays into live-action remakes and enjoyed considerable box office success. Upon closer examination, however, the artistic merit of this film is open to debate. Transforming the story into a war-like adventure seems discordant with the absurd and dreamlike nature of the original tale. Despite being visually stunning, the movie is marred by an excessive use of computer-generated imagery and a predictable narrative that diminishes the eccentric allure of the source material. Johnny Depp’s portrayal of the Mad Hatter stands out, yet his character seems misplaced in a narrative striving to impose meaning and order on a world that thrives in chaos. In essence, this adaptation is ambitious but fails to capture the true spirit of the original story – a shortcoming that its sequel only serves to reinforce.

14) 101 Dalmatians

101 Dalmatians is a strong film that could use a bit more polish, serving as one of Disney’s early attempts at live-action remakes. Despite being older than some recent adaptations, it remains entertaining and straightforward. Unlike its modern counterparts, it doesn’t aim to redefine the story – instead, it brings the classic animated version to life in a simple yet effective manner. Glenn Close delivers an over-the-top, captivating performance as Cruella de Vil, stealing every scene and elevating the entire production. Without music or talking animals (a point of contention for some viewers), the movie relies on physical comedy, the puppies’ expressive faces, and Cruella’s allure. Although not particularly groundbreaking, its cheerful tone and adherence to the original’s essence make it a pleasant viewing experience. In summary, it’s a good film overall.

13) Lady and the Tramp

Over time, the appeal of Disney’s remakes seemed to wane as viewers yearned for something more. Surprisingly, the reimagined version of Lady and the Tramp fared better than anticipated, yet fell short of greatness. The decision to incorporate real dogs with gentle digital alterations instead of fully computer-generated characters lends a genuine appeal to the movie, even though the visuals aren’t always perfect. The narrative remains true to the original, with minor adjustments to the cast and messages to give it a contemporary twist without losing its timeless charm. It’s not groundbreaking, but it manages to deliver. Essentially, it’s one of the rare live-action remakes that understands its limitations and stays within its capabilities rather than aiming too high. While it’s good, it could have pushed itself further.

12) Snow White

Prior to its premiere, the live-action version of Snow White generated a lot of debate. People had high hopes for the film since it claimed to bring a fresh take on Disney’s first princess’ story, although this update was generally perceived as falling short. One advantage was the effort to make the classic tale more relevant with a modernized setting and an assertive heroine pursuing justice. Rachel Zegler delivers an impressive performance in her role, despite the controversy surrounding her casting. However, the use of CGI to create the seven dwarfs received significant criticism for appearing unrealistic, and Gal Gadot’s portrayal as the Evil Queen was met with mixed reactions. In the end, the film didn’t perform as well as expected at the box office, leaving many viewers feeling underwhelmed despite the catchy songs and appealing visuals.

11) The Lion King

When “The Lion King” made its debut, it captivated everyone’s interest right away. The visual presentation was remarkably striking for its era, leveraging state-of-the-art technology to create the African savannah and its animal inhabitants with stunning realism. However, this relentless pursuit of visual accuracy proved to be the film’s major drawback – a factor that carries significant weight in a Disney live-action adaptation. By focusing on realism, the movie compromised the expressiveness of its characters, a key aspect for conveying an emotionally intense narrative. Moreover, the storyline closely mirrors the original, resulting in a rather predictable viewing experience. This production might have been the first evident instance showcasing the difficulties inherent in striking a balance between maintaining authenticity and meeting audience expectations when remaking a live-action film.

10) Maleficent

In the 2010s, Disney chose to innovate with the movie “Maleficent,” setting it apart through a fresh perspective on an old tale. Instead of telling the story of “Sleeping Beauty” as we know it, this film gave us the villain’s side, humanizing one of Disney’s most famous bad guys. Angelina Jolie delivered a captivating performance that carried the movie despite occasional script issues. Despite some tonal inconsistencies between dark and playful moments, “Maleficent” was praised for its daring approach – flipping classic fairy tale morals and presenting a complex, morally ambiguous lead character. Although it wasn’t flawless (compared to its sequel), this film paved the way for more daring reinterpretations within the Disney universe.

9) Christopher Robin

Christopher Robin, in a more understated fashion, is one of Disney’s most genuine and heartfelt live-action films. Unlike typical adaptations of Winnie the Pooh stories, it explores the life of Christopher Robin as an adult, grappling with responsibilities and losing touch with his childhood. This unique angle sets it apart. The film exhibits a poignant balance, resonating with feelings audiences can identify with. Ewan McGregor delivers a moving portrayal, and the designs maintain a nostalgic, wistful allure. Despite occasional uneven pacing and predictable plot points, it shuns flashy visual effects in favor of emotion and warmth – qualities that define Disney’s enchantment at its core.

8) Lilo & Stitch

As a cinephile, I must say that the long-awaited live-action adaptation of “Lilo & Stitch” was an intricate balancing act between preserving the original’s essence and modernizing its aesthetic appeal for today’s audience. It wasn’t an easy task, but Disney only partially succeeded in this endeavor. Initially, I had reservations about the CGI design of Stitch, but the film excels in numerous aspects – from the harmonious camaraderie between the cast members to its authentic representation of Hawaii and the enduring theme of “ohana.”

However, alterations to the narrative diminished the emotional resonance compared to the animated version. In summary, it’s a blend of daring decisions and adherence to the source material, but with room for more imaginative reinterpretation. Nonetheless, it surpasses many remakes by evoking nostalgia and creating lasting memories.

7) Beauty and the Beast

In terms of remaining true to the original story, the film version of “Beauty and the Beast” leaves no stone unturned, offering a visually stunning reinterpretation. The movie painstakingly reproduces each scene from the classic animated film, adding exquisitely composed musical sequences along the way. This remake isn’t about reinventing the wheel but rather celebrating the timeless story. Although some viewers have expressed reservations about Emma Watson’s portrayal of Belle and felt the special effects were less than perfect (especially during interactions with the enchanted objects), the movie still manages to evoke the charm of the original. In essence, it’s a visually stunning reimagining that does justice to one of Disney’s most beloved fairy tales.

6) The Little Mermaid

In a surprising twist for many, the much-discussed live-action version of The Little Mermaid, proved to be quite a hit. Halle Bailey, in her role as Ariel, captivates viewers not only with her enchanting persona but also through her powerful singing voice, adding emotional depth to the film. The remake adds layers to the original narrative by providing more character development for Prince Eric and introducing new songs – risks that ultimately prove beneficial. However, some underwater visuals fall short of the enchanting standards set by Disney, a minor blemish. Yet, it’s the heartfelt and thoughtful reinterpretation that stands out, striking a balance between modernizing the story while preserving its essence.

5) Aladdin

Initially, there was some doubt about Aladdin when it was first announced, but it ended up being a lively and spirited reimagining that’s tough not to appreciate. The film boasts a talented cast, with Will Smith stepping into the role of Genie, who, despite having big shoes to fill after Robin Williams, creates an original and memorable portrayal. One of the film’s greatest strengths is giving Princess Jasmine a powerful new theme song that enhances her character and was a smart move by the studio. Although the direction occasionally veers into stylistic extravagance and some visual effects come up short, the movie keeps things fun with a fast-paced narrative. By skillfully balancing homage to the original with fresh ideas, Disney delivers an entertaining and audience-pleasing remake that’s definitely one of the best adaptations worth watching.

4) Cruella

In an unexpected twist, the prequel “Cruella” has proven to be successful. This live-action reimagining of a classic Disney tale strays far from the traditional fairy tale format, instead focusing on the gritty origins of fashion and fierce competition. Emma Stone delivers a stellar performance that breathes life into this complex character. The film thrives in its punkish, edgy environment, offering a compelling backstory for the notorious villain. Despite its departure from typical Disney aesthetics, its swift pace and bold style set it apart. The decision to humanize such a ruthless character ignited debate, but it offers a refreshing perspective that many have longed for in Disney’s remake lineup. We find ourselves fully invested in the story of Cruella de Vil, leaving little room for criticism or skepticism.

3) Pete’s Dragon

Pete’s Dragon is one of Disney’s lesser-known remakes, but its understated charm makes it a delightful surprise. Unlike other adaptations that rely on flashy visuals or nostalgia, this one takes a subtler approach, focusing more on emotional depth and intimacy. The story centers around an orphaned boy and an invisible dragon named Elliot, with the bond between them serving as the foundation for a narrative that explores themes of loss, family, and belonging in a way that’s not often seen in Disney films. The CGI used for Elliot is well-executed without overshadowing the story, and the cast delivers sincere, grounded performances throughout. Despite its somewhat melancholic tone, it stands out as one of Disney’s most thoughtfully made movies.

2) Cinderella

Back in the day when Disney’s Cinderella graced our screens, it was a smashing hit that still stands tall among its contemporaries today. Frankly, I can’t fathom why they haven’t managed to recapture this magic since. Instead of rehashing the plot, this film chooses to embellish it, adding depth and nuance to every character with an artful, subtle finesse. Lily James truly shines in her portrayal of Cinderella, embodying the character authentically, while Cate Blanchett breathes new life into the wicked stepmother, offering a layer of complexity rarely seen in Disney’s villains. The costumes and set design are nothing short of exquisite, striking a perfect balance between opulence and artistic vision. Unlike some modern adaptations that aim to surprise, this live-action rendition doesn’t seek to overturn expectations but rather refines them, making it one of Disney’s most enduring successes.

1) The Jungle Book

Known to some as a forgotten gem by others, The Jungle Book builds upon the charm of Cinderella and takes it a step further. With state-of-the-art technology and reverence for its roots, this live-action film is not only visually captivating but also emotionally resonant. Neel Sethi, portraying Mowgli, stands out among a cast of voice legends and a completely computer-generated environment, yet he holds the story together with undeniable charm and authenticity. The narrative sticks close to the original story’s core while adding dramatic elements skillfully throughout. There’s humor, suspense, and an exquisite aesthetic that collectively make this movie a classic. In this unique instance, a live-action reboot not only pays homage to its origins but also enhances it with finesse and dedication.

2025-06-05 20:16