Exclusive: MSI Claw 8 AI+ vs AMD Rivals - Why It's Still Unavailable!

As soon as the unveiling of the latest Intel Core Ultra Series 2 Windows gaming handheld, my desire to pen our MSI Claw 8 AI+ review became undeniable.

Previously, I’ve delved into the ASUS ROG Ally, ROG Ally X, Lenovo Legion Go, and other Windows 11 portable gaming devices. So, now I’m eager to compare the MSI Claw 8 AI+ with its competitors in the market.

If you’re well-versed in portable gaming devices, you might recall that when the MSI Claw A1M debuted in March 2024, it struggled to keep pace with its rivals.

The device was the sole popular handheld running on Intel’s Core Ultra Series 1 AI CPUs, but it struggled to match the performance of AMD Ryzen Z1 Extreme gadgets such as the Legion Flow and ROG Flow.

Or simply:

The device was the only mainstream handheld powered by Intel’s Core Ultra Series 1 AI CPUs, but it couldn’t keep up with the performance of devices like the Legion Flow and ROG Flow that use AMD Ryzen Z1 Extreme processors.

For a fortnight, I made the MSI Claw 8 AI+ my primary gaming tool, putting it to the test alongside the ROG Ally and Legion Go in various benchmark trials.

Is this updated version significantly better than the first one? Does that improvement justify the purchase? Additionally, why was there a delay in its release? Let’s explore these aspects further.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Pricing and specifications

The MSI Claw 8 AI+ launches at $899.99 with the Intel Core Ultra 7 258V, 32GB RAM, 1TB SSD, and an 8-inch display.
MSI is also releasing a 7-inch display $799.99 model that offers a lower 512GB SSD.
These devices are more expensive than other handhelds on the market.
Value rating: ⭐⭐⭐ 1/2

The cost of Windows 11 gaming handhelds is quite high, and this is particularly evident with the latest MSI Claw AI portable devices.

MSI actually announced two Intel Core Ultra Series 2 gaming handhelds for this year.

Firstly, you’ll find the larger “Sandstorm” MSI Claw 8 AI+ A2VM, a blend of black and sandy-brown, priced at $899.99 in Best Buy. Secondly, there’s the compact all-black MSI Claw 7 AI+, also available at Best Buy for $799.99.

Compared to the initial MSI Claw A1M from the Intel Core Ultra Series 1, priced at $649.99 at Best Buy, these latest MSI handhelds are significantly costlier.

Among non-MSI portable devices, the ASUS ROG Ally is quite comparable to the Claw 8 AI+. It’s priced $100 lower and features a 7-inch display, an AMD Z1 Extreme processor, 24GB RAM, a 1TB SSD, an 80Whr battery, and retails for $799.99 at Best Buy.

One factor contributing to the high price of the Claw 8 AI+ is its unique use of Intel AI processors and AI-enhanced Neural Processing Units (NPUs), unlike most Windows handheld devices that opt for AMD’s Z-Series chips designed primarily for handheld devices.

Furthermore, the MSI Claw 8 AI+ boasts impressive next-generation portable specifications that outshine many competitors with less sophisticated configurations, contributing to its higher price tag. Notably, Intel processors are typically pricier than their AMD counterparts.

As an analyst, I find myself intrigued by the unique positioning of this handheld device. It’s not like other portable gaming systems such as ROG Ally and Legion Go, due to its Intel AI chip that essentially makes it an AI-powered personal computer. MSI has even coined it a Copilot+ PC, although it lacks a dedicated Copilot button to fully meet this classification.

At present, the primary issue with the MSI Claw 8 AI+ lies in its accessibility. Regrettably, despite initial plans for its release, it remains unavailable for purchase as of now.

It’s uncertain when this portable device will hit the market for general sale, as there haven’t been any updates on a Best Buy listing for several months.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Design and build quality

The MSI Claw 8 AI+ is a major improvement over the original Claw A1M.
It’s well-balanced and offers ergonomic grips, but the indentations on the back feel unpleasant on my fingertips.
Design rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ 1/2

Although the “Sandstorm” hue sets this gadget apart among the predominantly white and black handhelds, its design may spark differing opinions.

Among some members of the Windows Central team, there’s a fondness for the color scheme, viewing it as reminiscent of an ’80s futuristic vibe. However, other team members aren’t as enamored with its appearance. Ultimately, your personal preference will guide your decision.

From a design perspective, I must say that the new MSI Claw 8 AI+ has noticeably enhanced features compared to its predecessor, the MSI Claw A1M. One significant improvement is the flattening of the back buttons, which reduces their intrusion into the gripping area, making gameplay more comfortable and efficient.

In essence, while the device boasts a well-balanced and comfortable design overall, I find the rigid indents on its back rather uncomfortable for my fingertips compared to the smoother, less textured backs found on the Steam Deck, ROG Ally, and Legion Go devices.

Regarding connectivity, the latest Claw model comes equipped with two Thunderbolt 4 ports. This allows simultaneous charging of the device through one port while keeping another free for connecting an accessory at the same time.

As a devoted enthusiast, I’m thrilled to share that this marvelous device is equipped with cutting-edge connectivity options, including Bluetooth 5.4 and the upcoming Wi-Fi 7 technology. Plus, it comes with a microSD card slot, allowing me to swiftly extend my storage whenever needed.

Although I find the texture on the back of the Claw somewhat uncomfortable, it still boasts a good balance, offers secure grips, and features numerous useful attachment points for additional accessories.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Display quality

The MSI Claw 8 AI+ has an 8-inch IPS touchscreen with VRR and 120Hz.
This screen size is larger than ROG Ally but smaller than Legion Go.
Colors, contrast, details, and motion clarity aren’t top-tier, but they’re good for an IPS gaming handheld.
Display rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

As an observer, I find that while the MSI Claw 8 AI+’s 8-inch IPS touchscreen may not be the top-tier handheld screen available, it certainly stands out with its size, responsiveness, and sharp details. It delivers a good range of colors and provides a satisfying viewing experience overall.

Following some hours of gameplay, I attached a color measuring device and conducted a color gamut assessment. The touchscreen managed to display 99% of sRGB, 76% of AdobeRGB, and 77% of P3. This performance was slightly superior to the impressive outcomes delivered by the ROG Ally X IPS screen (for further information, refer to our ROG Ally X review).

As an analyst, it’s evident that the performance of this device doesn’t quite match up to what you’d experience on a handheld device equipped with an OLED display (refer to our Legion Go S review for more insights). However, opting for an IPS screen instead of OLED significantly reduces the overall cost of this device.

This device offers Variable Refresh Rate (VRR) up to 120 times per second, which generally provides good motion clarity in games on the Claw 8 AI+ screen. However, it’s important to note that perfect motion clarity isn’t always achievable with VRR-equipped handheld devices; this is a common characteristic of such devices.

In the upcoming segment, we’ll delve deeper into gaming and its impact on performance. Meanwhile, let’s keep our discussion focused on the display for now.

I also conducted a brightness and contrast test while the colorimeter was in use.

As a tech enthusiast, I found that the display’s peak brightness clocks in at 469 nits, which is fairly good but doesn’t quite match the brilliance of ROG Ally X’s maximum brightness of 536 nits. On the flip side, the contrast on my MSI device is slightly superior to that of ASUS’ handheld counterpart.

Ultimately, the Claw 8 AI+’s screen delivers impressive visuals for handheld gaming, boasting sharp details, vibrant colors, and a swift touch response. However, it could use a tad more brightness to enhance its overall appeal.

How does the MSI Claw screen compare to ROG Ally X and Legion Go?

As an analyst, I strategically organized these three portable gaming devices – the Legion Go with its 8.8-inch display, the MSI Claw 8 AI+ boasting an 8-inch screen, and the ROG Ally X sporting a 7-inch display – on my table according to their screen sizes, for a side-by-side visual evaluation.

Aside from size differences, each of these handheld screens offers tradeoffs.

Among the three models, the Legion Go offers the most comprehensive color range, demonstrated by significantly superior Adobe RGB and DCI-P3 scores.

On the contrary, I observed that the glass employed on the smaller ROG Ally X did not reflect as intensely compared to the MSI Claw and Legion Go glasses. This means that contrast and dark details are more distinct on the ASUS handheld, while areas that appear gray on other devices are visible with greater clarity on the smaller ROG Ally X.

Overall, the MSI Claw 8 AI+’s display is not top-tier, but it’s plenty good for handheld gaming.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Performance and thermals

MSI Claw 8 AI+ and its Intel Core Ultra 7 258V processor provide much better performance than AMD Z1 Extreme handhelds like ROG Ally and Legion Go.
The MSI Claw was able to more than double the average frame rate that the ROG Ally earned in the same game benchmarks.
Performance rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

For the past two years, I’ve consistently endorsed the AMD Z1 Extreme ROG Ally as the top Windows handheld device in terms of performance and motion clarity. However, my recent tests have revealed that the Intel Core Ultra Series 2 MSI Claw 8 AI+ provides a noticeably smoother gaming experience compared to it.

For approximately 12 hours, I put the Claw 8 AI+ to the test by running graphically demanding video games such as Baldur’s Gate 3, Ashes of the Singularity, Shadow of the Tomb Raider, Cyberpunk 2077, and others that are known for pushing CPU and GPU limits.

In comparison, it functioned noticeably better than both ROG Ally and Legion Go, showing fewer instances of lag and offering considerably faster frame rates.

For even clearer understanding, I’ve added a graph displaying side-by-side Cyberpunk 2077 benchmark results for the Claw 8 AI+, Legion Go, Ally X, and Ally. All devices are operating at maximum power consumption (TDP) with identical graphic settings.

While conducting tests, I pushed the Claw handheld device to its maximum 30W Thermal Design Power (TDP) and subjected it to numerous benchmark assessments. In general usage, the Claw 8 AI+ delivered an exceptional gaming experience.

Ashes of the Singularity — 66 FPS (Normal preset, 1080p resolution, 120Hz refresh rate, V-sync enabled)
Shadow of the Tomb Raider — 76 FPS (Lowest preset, 1080p resolution, V-sync enabled)
Cyberpunk 2077 — 59 FPS (Low preset, 1080p resolution, 120Hz, V-sync disabled, Intel Xe Super Sampling 1.3 set to “Auto,” frame generation disabled)

From the benchmark data, it’s clear that the Claw system consistently delivered frame rates of approximately 60 or more while running demanding games, outperforming both the ROG Ally and Legion Go by a substantial margin.

Fantastic performance to rival a laptop

Instead of treating the MSI Claw 8 AI+ like an ordinary laptop due to its controller attachments rather than a keyboard, I subjected it to the identical battery of benchmark tests that I’d usually administer to a standard laptop.

From my vantage point, I’ve noted that during a CPU analysis, this handheld device showcased a multi-core score of 10,446 and a single-core score of 2,718 on Geekbench 6. While these numbers may not be the highest for an Intel Core Ultra 7 258V, they are remarkably consistent with other devices sporting the same processor.

It’s important to mention that the ASUS ROG Ally X, ROG Ally, and Lenovo Legion Go outperformed the Claw 8 AI+ in multi-core Geekbench 6 tests. However, it was the Claw 8 AI+ that took the lead with the highest single-core score.

Additionally, I conducted a Cinebench R24 test to evaluate the CPU rendering capabilities. The MSI Claw 8 AI+ managed a single-core score of 120 and a multi-core score of 483 in this test. Unfortunately, these scores are slightly lower than we anticipated for this processor’s performance.

Compared to other devices, the ROG Ally X with its AMD Z1 Extreme chip boasts the best handheld multi-core Cinebench score at 724. However, it lags slightly behind the Claw 8 AI+ in single-core performance, with a score of only 100.

Given that the Claw 8 AI+ sports a powerful AI-enhanced Intel Core Ultra 7 258V processor, complete with an inbuilt Neural Processing Unit (NPU), I decided to conduct further AI-focused performance tests on this machine as well.

In the Procyon’s Windows ML Float 32 CPU test, the handheld received a relatively low score of 60. Yet, it showed improvement in the Procyon’s Intel OpenVINO float 16 NPU test, where it achieved a higher score of 837.

In simpler terms, my past testing revealed that this gadget delivers superior gaming performance compared to other portable devices. Although the Claw doesn’t quite measure up to other AI-focused computer devices in terms of performance, it doesn’t matter much because its design is aimed at a different objective and we’ve found it distinctive from the AI PCs we’ve evaluated previously.

Next, I shifted my focus towards testing the MSI Claw 8 AI+’s built-in Intel Arc 140V graphics card by using 3DMark.

In this instance, the handheld device achieved a score of 3,882 using Time Spy, which currently ranks as the lowest Intel Arc 140V score we’ve encountered thus far. However, it outperformed the ROG Ally X with a score of 3,506 and the Legion Go with 3,247.

Additionally, I conducted the 3DMark Night Raid integrated graphics test with the handheld device. It managed to achieve an impressive score of 28,499, however, this falls slightly short compared to the typical average of 34,451 for this specific processor.

After obtaining those results, I employed CrystalDiskMark to evaluate the SSD’s performance for The Claw. The SSD in The Claw achieved a read speed of 6,068 megabytes per second (MB/s) and a write speed of 5,324 MB/s. In comparison, The Legion Go’s SSD had a read speed of 5,016 MB/s and a write speed of 1,620 MB/s, while the ROG Ally’s SSD delivered a read speed of 4,337 MB/s and a write speed of 1,812 MB/s. The Claw’s SSD outperformed both The Legion Go and the ROG Ally in terms of read and write speeds.

This implies that the Claw outperforms other handheld devices when it comes to crucial gaming tasks such as quickly accessing, loading, and saving data.

As your analyst, I’ve put the new MSI Claw 8 AI+ through its paces using CrossMark for a comprehensive system performance evaluation. To my delight, it registered an impressive score of 1,665, outperforming the Legion Go (1,588) and ROG Ally (1,508) in this area.

In a nutshell: Although it didn’t consistently earn the highest marks in all tests, the MSI Claw 8 AI+ with its Intel processors generally outperformed the ROG Ally and Legion Go when put side by side. Essentially, this handheld AI-enhanced computer delivers a smoother gaming experience compared to its competitors.

Thermals and fan noise

This device doesn’t produce much volume while playing games or using specific software. In fact, when I placed a decibel meter directly beside the vents, it never exceeded 52.9 decibels, even during a CPU stress test.

Since it wouldn’t be comfortable for you to rest your head on the device, I also measured the noise level with a decibel meter near my ear while holding the Claw at an average distance from me. The reading showed a maximum of 38.0 dB, which isn’t particularly loud.

Approaching the conclusion of a 20-minute CPU stress test, I retrieved my heat-detecting camera and snapped some photos of the Claw 8 AI+ unit.

It’s not surprising that the primary heat sources on a handheld device are the main vents, reaching up to 140 degrees Fahrenheit (60 degrees Celsius). The second-hottest spot is found in the bottom center of the screen, maxing out at around 99 degrees Fahrenheit (37 degrees Celsius).

In the heart of the Claw, temperatures soared up to 98 degrees Fahrenheit (around 36 degrees Celsius), yet the parts where you typically grasp and handle remain cool to the touch, never getting excessively warm.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Battery experience

It has the same-sized 80Whr battery capacity as the ROG Ally X.
When playing intensive games, it gets about 2 of battery life.
Battery rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Gaming handhelds all have one major weakness, and that is battery life.

In their current state, Windows handheld devices can typically last around two hours while running at full power and playing demanding games. This particular device doesn’t push boundaries in terms of extended playtime for such high-performance tasks.

In simple terms, when running Cyberpunk 2077 at maximum power usage (TDP) and around 200 nit screen brightness, the MSI Claw’s battery, like the one in the ROG Ally X (80Whr), lasted about 2 hours and 10 minutes.

During my testing sessions, the handheld device typically ran for approximately an hour and a quarter, though this duration varied based on the specific games being played.

To get the most out of your gaming experience, especially during extended sessions, it’s advisable to utilize the Claw 8 AI+ when it’s charging or connected to a TV docking station, unless your games are primarily quick rounds.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Software experience

It comes with Windows 11 and the MSI Center M software.
Windows can be divisive on handhelds, but it can also give a lot of freedom.
MSI Center M doesn’t have as many customization options as some other handheld software.
Software rating: ⭐⭐⭐½

On a Windows 11 device, you’ll find an experience akin to using a laptop equipped with integrated controllers rather than a conventional keyboard. This setup allows for web browsing, gaming, and running software just as you would on a standard PC.

Indeed, this implies that you’re free to access various game platforms like Steam, Ubisoft Connect, the Xbox app, Epic Games, Battle.net, and many others.

Clearly, this gives you the liberty to open multiple gaming platforms such as Steam, Ubisoft Connect, the Xbox application, Epic Games, Battle.net, and more for your gaming needs.

The model Claw 8 AI+ arrives pre-installed with MSI Center M, a versatile tool that serves as a gaming platform, connects you to customer support, and offers various settings customizations, just to name a few of its features.

Similar to its predecessor, the Claw 8 AI+, lacks the extensive customization options found in competing devices such as the ASUS ROG Ally. Specifically, it doesn’t support VRAM adjustment, which may disappoint users seeking a more personalized system setup experience.

Instead, using manual mode grants you the ability to switch the TDP (Thermal Design Power) among 8W, 17W, and 30W. Furthermore, it provides an option to either automatically regulate fan speed or adjust it manually through sliders.

With this AI-powered gadget, you can switch to AI Optimization mode effortlessly. This intelligent setting adapts automatically according to your device usage, making it a convenient choice for those who prefer not to manually adjust settings themselves.

One of the other main functions MSI Center M provides is RGB lighting adjustment.

With the “Mystic Light” option, you can select among five unique visual effects and also customize colors using a built-in color picker. You have the ability to save up to three different profiles or settings as convenient presets for easy switching.

I enjoy the lively hues surrounding the joysticks, yet I also value the option offered by MSI Center M to fully dim the RGB lights when I prefer a less colorful environment for my workspace.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Controls and other hardware

The MSI Claw 8 AI+ buttons and joysticks offer great responsiveness.
This handheld also offers a really good mic and Hi-Res speakers.
Other hardware rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

When it comes to the design of the Claw 8 AI’s controls compared to the original Claw A1M, they appear quite alike, if not identical. However, there seems to be a notable distinction in the texture of the joystick tips, which is intended to provide improved grip control.

Previously, I noted that the back buttons on this gadget have a more streamlined design than the original model. However, they still provide a satisfying click when pressed, just like all other functionalities do.

Similar to certain other devices, the power button on this handheld also functions as a fingerprint scanner. However, it may not always recognize your fingerprint immediately, but it significantly speeds up the login procedure when it does.

As this handheld doesn’t have a built-in camera, it can’t utilize the facial recognition login feature provided by Windows Hello.

It’s pleasing to share that the two high-resolution 2W speakers, equipped with a built-in microphone, perform exceptionally well beyond what’s typically required in a handheld device.

In the thrilling world of Baldur’s Gate 3, I found myself engaged in a captivating co-op adventure with my comrades. Unexpectedly, my trusty headset malfunctioned, leaving me momentarily disconnected from the game. However, the built-in microphone proved to be a lifeline, enabling me to keep the communication channels open with my team for several vital minutes. It wasn’t until I managed to fix the issue that I was fully back in the game, ready to conquer new challenges together.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Alternative handhelds

As a dedicated enthusiast, I’ve repeatedly praised the ROG Ally X and Legion Go in this critique, so it won’t be unexpected when I suggest the MSI Claw 8 AI+ as a fitting alternative.

MSI Claw 8 AI+ review: Final thoughts

You should buy this if …

✅ You want a handheld with longer battery life

Among the gaming handhelds available today, I must say that the MSI Claw 8 AI+ boasts one of the most impressive battery capacities, capable of enduring up to 2 hours and 10 minutes when pushing it to its limits during intense gameplay sessions at maximum TDP. Frankly, I wish it could last even longer, but considering the current state of Windows handheld technology, this is about as good as it gets for now.

✅ You want a handheld that offers great gaming performance

When it comes to portable gaming devices, the MSI Claw 8 AI+ delivers impressive performance that ranks among the best in its class. Although it may not match the top-tier performance of gaming laptops or desktops, it typically achieves a frame rate of 60 FPS or higher even in demanding games. Moreover, its VRR (Variable Refresh Rate) technology and 120Hz refresh rate collaboration ensure smooth motion clarity.

You should not buy this if …

❌ You want the best value handheld for your money

At present, the MSI Claw 8 AI+ is among the priciest gaming handheld devices available. Nonetheless, you can discover other options with comparable gaming performance at more affordable prices.

❌ You’d prefer a handheld that offers more setting customizations

As an enthusiastic gamer, if you’re all about fine-tuning your gaming handheld to perfection, with options like adjusting VRAM settings, there might be other devices on the market that cater better to your needs. The MSI Claw 8 AI+, while a fantastic device in many aspects, may not offer the level of customization you’re seeking for an optimized gaming experience.

The MSI Claw 8 AI+ comes with a higher price tag, yet delivers top-tier gaming performance among handheld devices currently on the market, if you’re prepared to make that investment.

Absolutely, it’d be great if this gadget had more options for user customization. However, the built-in AI mode operates efficiently on its own, eliminating the need for manual adjustments.

2025-03-22 16:22

Exclusive: MSI Claw 8 AI+ vs AMD Rivals – Why It’s Still Unavailable!