From Box Office Flop to Cult Classic: The Dark Legacy of Heathers

by

Winona Ryder is famously known for her roles in movies like ‘Heathers’ from the 80s, a chilling portrayal of intense clique dynamics, and ‘Beetlejuice’, which she reprised in the 2024 sequel. She also starred in other dark-themed films such as ‘Edward Scissorhands’, ‘Bram Stoker’s Dracula’, and received an Oscar nomination for the heartfelt ‘Little Women’. More recently, she has been recognized for her role as Joyce in ‘Stranger Things’.

During this time, Christian Slater, who starred alongside Winona Ryder in Heathers, became well-known primarily due to that film. He went on to appear in projects like Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves and Interview with the Vampire in the 1990s, and is currently part of the cast for Dexter: Original Sin. Famous for their roles as the rebellious girl and the troublemaking boy, which were partly shaped by Heathers, Ryder and Slater created a thrilling and mesmerizing dynamic in the classic slasher. However, Heathers was not well-received when it first came out, but eventually gained cult status.

Heathers Wasn’t A Hit In 1988, But Has Slowly Become A Cult Classic

Heathers’ Dark Tone Didn’t Originally Land With Audiences

The movie titled “Heathers” revolves around Veronica Sawyer, a shy teenager who joins the school’s elite group of mean girls, all named Heather. However, instead of finding friendship, she endures their bullying. A new student, Jason “J.D.” Dean (Slater), enters the scene and captivates Veronica with his rebellious charm. The two start a relationship, but J.D., to her reluctance, starts killing students he deems undeserving, enlisting Veronica’s indirect assistance in these acts. At its release, “Heathers” garnered positive reviews but only managed to earn around $1 million at the box office against a budget of approximately $2-3 million (according to Box Office Mojo).

Although some aspects of the movie “Heathers” may not resonate as strongly today due to its handling of sensitive topics like teen violence, suicide, drug abuse, and cynicism, it was a film ahead of its time in the 1980s, a decade characterized by feel-good movies. While many critics understood the film’s dark essence, audiences might have found it challenging to embrace this unique perspective. For example, Desson Thompson from “The Washington Post” pointed out that the movie’s bleak tone was intentional, even if it went over some viewers’ heads back then.

“Heathers might just be the most wickedly entertaining movie experience you can get without needing to study law or craft leather goods. To put it another way, if films were types of food, Heathers would be like a dark-humored indulgence in rich chocolates.

It’s plausible that the film Heathers gained cult status thanks to Winona Ryder’s increasing fame in films with a darker atmosphere, making it intriguing for audiences. However, the movie didn’t completely escape its controversial content, which partly led to the cancellation of a potential TV series adaptation. Over time, Heathers was perceived as more of a ’90s film than an ’80s one, despite the prominent fashion trends of the era. People grew fond of its bleak outlook, particularly in portraying high school life.

Why Heathers Is THE Quintessential ’80s Cult Classic

Heathers Goes Against The Grain Of The 1980s

Heathers could be seen as a twisted spin on the popular teen movies of the 1980s, which were often produced by John Hughes and the Brat Pack. Unlike these films where teenagers faced serious issues but their relationships with each other were generally positive and supportive in both personal and school life, Heathers combines a high school setting with the violence that characterized the horror movies of the 1980s. Even Stand by Me, which centers around a child’s death, emphasizes the strength of friendships. However, unlike these films, Heathers is considered an ’80s cult classic for its dark portrayal of high school life and violence.

Heathers has an ’80s vibe, yet it smashes the idea that high school is a time of unforgettable fun and lifelong friendships or romantic relationships blossoming. Despite its cynicism, it subtly advocates for kindness and connection, similar to Mean Girls, while still portraying high school as devoid of meaning. Initially, it might have been difficult to market this during the brief window of a theatrical run amidst the Breakfast Club era, but once viewers had time to reflect on it, they realized that Heathers resonated with them deeply.

Read More

2025-05-26 23:18