I Think Batman and Catwoman’s Failed Wedding Is The Best Thing That’s Ever Happened to the Dark Knight

by

In comic book lore, the unsuccessful marriage between Batman and Catwoman is legendary, serving as the turning point in Tom King’s 85-issue tenure on Batman, causing a divide among fans. This event was anticipated for 25 issues and a series of special issues highlighting each of Batman’s sons preparing for the wedding uniquely.

King’s run was expected to bring a groundbreaking change to the Batman universe, with fans eagerly awaiting this significant shift in Bruce Wayne’s storyline. Although there had been whispers online about the wedding being a clever ruse, given DC’s extensive marketing and the numerous arcs focusing on Batman and Catwoman’s interdependence, most people, including myself, dismissed these skeptical theories as unfounded. It wasn’t until the truth was revealed that these doubts were validated.

The cancelled wedding wasn’t merely a disappointing moment for Batman; it was the most profound betrayal he could experience from his fans. It seemed like a heavy blow to the stomach, as all the months of preparation and anticipation were squandered on a twist that didn’t fit neatly into the narrative. Yet, despite its negative effect on fan trust and the storyline not quite reaching its previous potential, the unsuccessful marriage between Batman and Catwoman may turn out to be the most beneficial event for the Dark Knight.

Breaking Up Batman and Catwoman Is Actually the Better Story

First, let’s delve into the story’s viewpoint, as I find it particularly intriguing. From a tale-spinning angle, the scenario where Batman envisions a future with Catwoman, filled with genuine joy, yet finds that joy snatched away, provides an excellent platform for character analysis. The events following this betrayal of trust plunge Batman into an emotional abyss never before witnessed or thoroughly examined. In this state, Batman experiences anger, sadness, and pain in equal proportions, but is at a loss as to how to cope with these intense feelings.

I immerse myself fully in my work, striving to keep my mind occupied, but it seems the more I push away my feelings, the less effective I become as Gotham’s protector with a heavy heart. Moreover, I’m compelled to face the reason Selina walked away from our union at the altar; she argues that I cannot be both Batman and truly content. This notion has always been a significant aspect of Batman’s character, dating back to his near resignation in the animated film “Batman: Mask of the Phantasm,” where he found true happiness with Andrea Beaumont before her departure. Similarly, I have considered retirement when deeply involved romantically, such as during my engagement to Silver St. Cloud, in the comics.

In a raw and unyielding manner, the storyline implies that for Bruce Wayne to truly aid his city as it requires, he might have to endure persistent misery. The origin of Batman stems from sorrow, so perhaps the character can only persist while Bruce holds onto grief. This concept is repeatedly presented to Batman, setting up an opportunity for him to disprove it and thereby shatter a harmful cycle. A significant theme in this series is that Bruce Wayne is not Batman because he’s trying to appease his parents, but rather because people depend on him and he is a compassionate individual who wishes to assist them. Through this narrative, Batman reinforces the purpose of his vow, which is to embody hope instead of pain, thus strengthening his commitment as Batman.

In a similar manner, keeping Batman and Catwoman apart only served to make their bond more resilient when they reconnected later on. Despite the frequent fights and disagreements, their love for each other became stronger as they were forced to address their conflicts and understand the impact of their relationship on every aspect of their complex lives. This challenging period brought them closer than ever before, a depth that has been further explored in subsequent stories.

Keeping Batman Single is Better for Comics

From a storytelling perspective, it’s often beneficial that the couple doesn’t marry, as comic book narratives frequently thrive on unstable relationships. Take Superman and Lois Lane, for example, they are one of the most iconic couples in fiction but remain exceptional due to their rarity. Many other beloved comic couples don’t fare as well. For instance, Barry Allen and Iris West, who have been together since DC Comics’ early days, are only engaged in the current universe, even though Barry isn’t the Flash yet. The same goes for Spider-Man and Mary Jane, a relationship that remains unmarried even after all these years.

Given Batman’s high profile and his reputation as a solitary figure despite having one of the largest superhero families, it’s unlikely that DC Comics would have allowed a long-term marriage between Batman and Catwoman. They would have found some intricate or implausible reason to separate them, such as during the “Gotham War” storyline when Catwoman pretended to die for three weeks. Although fans might have preferred to see them get married, they seem to appreciate the characters’ status quo more. It may be better that they chose to part ways on their own terms, without resentment in their hearts and no unnecessary reasons to push Selina out of Bruce’s life. It would have been disastrous if DC had ended their marriage by killing off Catwoman, which would have been unforgivable. By using the failed wedding plot, DC managed to preserve Batman as we know him while still developing his character and leaving room for romance when necessary.

The botched wedding between Catwoman and Batman remains an indelible mark on comic book lore, symbolizing betrayal not only within the DC Universe but also in our collective fandom. Although I may never forgive this event, it ultimately proved to be beneficial. Instead of witnessing their relationship deteriorate or Catwoman’s prolonged presence becoming tiresome in a Batman comic, we were granted a fleeting moment where they came together before parting ways as fate had always intended. Additionally, there are alternate realities and stories where Bruce Wayne could potentially find his ‘happily ever after,’ while still maintaining the iconic Batman we’ve grown accustomed to in our primary universe.

Read More

2025-05-09 15:52