I thought I was reviewing an ASUS gaming laptop, but this monster is more desktop than anything

As a seasoned gamer who’s seen his fair share of gaming laptops, I can confidently say that the ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) is a beast when it comes to raw power. But, let me tell you, if you’re after a balanced laptop with good quality-of-life features, this isn’t your cup of tea.

Among the gaming laptops I’ve assessed, the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 17 X3D stands out as one of the most extravagant, and it appears that ASUS continues to push boundaries. The transition to a modern 16:10 screen ratio brings about a larger display, increased weight, and enhanced performance. The upcoming ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) is an incredibly wild gaming laptop that I find myself questioning whether to label it a laptop or a desktop PC with a built-in monitor. It’s bulky and heavy, yet its power is such that you’re unlikely to witness it faltering in any tasks.

Boasting top-tier components by Intel and NVIDIA, an enhanced MiniLED screen, and a mission to leave a lasting impact, the ROG Strix SCAR 18 steps into the spotlight. However, it faces tough rivalry from manufacturers like Lenovo, who deliver comparable performance in sleeker, lighter, and more sophisticated laptops. The decision of whether the ROG Strix SCAR 18 is your ideal gaming laptop hinges on your personal preferences.

Of course, I’m here as usual to provide clear information and correct any misconceptions. Let’s dive right in!

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Pricing and specifications

I thought I was reviewing an ASUS gaming laptop, but this monster is more desktop than anything

Pricing highlights

The ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) retails from $2,999.99 with an Intel Core i9, RTX 4080, 32GB of RAM, and 1TB of SSD storage.
You can upgrade to an RTX 4090 and double the SSD storage for $3,899.99, which is the configuration that I reviewed.
This is undeniably a premium gaming laptop near the top of ASUS’ lineup, although it achieves that mostly through its high price tag and sheer amount of power, not the quality of its design or features.
Value rating: ⭐⭐⭐½

The ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) doesn’t compromise on quality; instead, it prioritizes packing high-end and costly PC gaming hardware without worrying about thickness or weight. In other words, you won’t have many options to choose from with this device, as there are only two primary configurations available.

The ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) is priced at $2,999.99 on Best Buy, featuring a 14th Gen Intel Core i9 processor, an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 graphics card, 32GB of interchangeable DDR5 memory, 1TB of upgradable PCIe Gen 4×4 SSD storage, and an impressive 18-inch, 240Hz QHD+ MiniLED display. This configuration aligns well with offerings from competitors like Acer and MSI, but for those seeking top-tier performance, additional funds can be invested.

The high-end version of the ROG Strix SCAR 18 is priced at $3,899.99 in Best Buy, and it offers an upgraded NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4090 GPU and 2TB of PCIe 4×4 SSD storage. Although it’s quite expensive, this price is relatively similar to other PCs with comparable specs, excluding exceptions like the Razer Blade 18 (2024), which costs noticeably more.

As an analyst, I’d describe it this way: Upon opening the box, I find myself in possession of the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) gaming laptop, a powerful 330W DC power adapter for continuous use, and a three-month subscription to Xbox Game Pass Ultimate – an exciting addition that promises a wealth of gaming experiences right at my fingertips.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Design and build quality

Design highlights

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 is supposed to represent the height of ASUS’ gaming laptops, but this design didn’t get the memo.
It’s big and heavy, sure, but more than that it’s a confusing morass of metal, opaque and translucent plastic, and average RGB lighting.
This is the kind of design we were used to seeing in gaming laptops 8 years ago, and it’s no more refined in 2024.
Design rating: ⭐⭐⭐

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 isn’t exactly compact or lightweight; it boasts a thickness of more than an inch and weighs close to 7 pounds. Although it might not be the thickest or heaviest gaming laptop available, it certainly ranks high in these categories. In reality, this laptop can only be considered portable in a technical sense, as its battery life (which I’ll discuss later) leaves much to be desired. Moving this laptop from one spot to another is more like engaging in physical activity than simply transporting a device with a battery and screen.

Although I can largely pardon most of it, there’s one aspect that’s hard to overlook: the unattractive design of the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18. Despite my fondness for the current trend of transparent and translucent tech, I wouldn’t group this laptop in the same category.

Among all components, the sleek matte black aluminum cover stands out as the most polished aspect of this laptop. However, ASUS seems to have opted for less elegant choices elsewhere, such as using transparent plastic extensively, which is found covering the entire body of the device, offering little intrigue beneath it. To add to that, there are numerous sharp lines and angular edges, creating a gaming laptop design that resembles something dreamt up by an ordinary “edgy teenage gamer.”

Additionally, the excessive RGB lighting doesn’t seem to enhance the aesthetic appeal either. Despite the option for customization, it appears that manufacturers like Razer, Alienware, Lenovo, and even ASUS (in other devices) have demonstrated a more refined and premium look with their RGB lighting, free from uneven and blotchy brightness issues.

The port selection doesn’t help redeem the ROG Strix SCAR 18 in this department much, as it’s among the modest side of the market. The 18-inch version has the same meager selection as its 16-inch sibling, seemingly restricted by the endless vents around the sides of this laptop. On the left side you have a USB Type-C Thunderbolt 4 port with DisplayPort 1.4, a USB Type-C 3.2 Gen 2 port with DisplayPort 1.4 and 100W Power Delivery, an HDMI 2.1 port, an Ethernet jack, and a 3.5mm audio jack. On the right side you have two USB Type-A 3.2 Gen 2 ports.

The ASUS ROG Zephyrus G14 (2024) is similar in terms of port selection, with a notable exception: instead of an Ethernet jack, it features a microSD card slot. Additionally, this model is significantly lighter and thinner compared to the original. On the other hand, the Lenovo Legion Pro 7i (Gen 9) boasts two extra USB Type-A ports in addition to its other features.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Display quality

Display highlights

The display is one of two areas where the ROG Strix SCAR 18 truly stands out, as ASUS opted for a quality MiniLED panel.
This display is sharp, responsive, and beautifully bright, with actually great support for HDR content.
It still lacks the punchiness of a premium OLED panel, but over 2,000 local dimming zones means contrast levels are almost on par.
Display rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐½

ASUS didn’t skimp when it came to the display on the ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024), equipping this gaming behemoth with an expansive, 18-inch MiniLED display. It’s the same kind of tech we’ve seen in laptops like the Lenovo Legion 9i (Gen 8) and some Razer laptops, and bridges the gap between IPS LCD and OLED displays. That means you get the durability and brightness of the former with the contrast ratios of the latter.

This screen performs exceptionally well overall, but it doesn’t quite match the top-tier OLED screens in certain aspects. For instance, it has a 3 millisecond response time, which is decent for competitive gaming, yet significantly slower than the sub-1 millisecond response times found on some other OLED screens. However, its fast 240Hz refresh rate and NVIDIA G-Sync compatibility make gaming feel incredibly responsive, with no screen tearing or trailing effects.

It’s not a 4K screen, but the QHD+ (2,560 x 1,600) resolution is still sharp enough for the screen size, and the tradeoff is that lovely aforementioned refresh rate.

As an onlooker, I find that the benchmarks reveal a vibrant, color-accurate screen, covering 100% of both sRGB and DCI-P3 color gamuts. The white balance leans slightly towards cool tones, but it’s consistently maintained across varying brightness levels, ensuring colors remain true and the display retains its natural aesthetic in various settings. On a brighter note, this screen is more than capable of lighting up your surroundings, effortlessly exceeding its claimed 500nits maximum brightness level.

Utilize Dolby Vision or VESA DisplayHDR 1000 technology for enjoying HDR content, as the laptop’s screen can reach an impressive brightness of 1,100 nits in specific areas. This results in a screen that’s not just suitable but delightful for HDR viewing. Moreover, with an astounding 2,304 local dimming zones in its backlight, the ROG Strix SCAR 18 offers contrast levels and blacks nearly as deep as a high-quality OLED panel, all without the concerns of potential burn-in or ghosting issues.

Although the display on the ROG Strix SCAR 18 is very impressive, it doesn’t quite match up to the best laptop screens I’ve encountered. It seems as if a delicate veil or faint haze covers the entire screen, diminishing its full potential. It comes close to perfection but ultimately falls slightly short.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Performance and thermals

Performance highlights

It should come as no surprise, but the ROG Strix SCAR 18 is a monster performer with the best Intel and NVIDIA have to offer under the hood.
This laptop tears through absolutely everything, including the most intense video games and benchmarks.
The ROG Strix SCAR 18 is also a consistent performer thanks to massive vents and unapologetically loud fans keeping everything cool.
Performance rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Equipped with an Intel Core i9-14900HX and a powerful NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4090, it’s no surprise that the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) stands as one of the top performing Windows PCs tested by Windows Central. ASUS didn’t skimp on any aspects when it comes to performance, building a gaming powerhouse that can handle virtually any task… However, keep in mind that this machine may not be ideal if you require silent operation or portability due to its power requirements.

This laptop generally operates swiftly and smoothly across various functions. It starts up quickly, wakes up promptly, opens applications rapidly, and overall performs tasks efficiently due to its speed. The use of Windows 11 on a 240Hz MiniLED display enhances this sense of smoothness as well. ASUS has also prioritized upgradeability by providing easy access to two SODIMM RAM slots and two M.2 PCIe 4.0 SSD slots, allowing users to swap out the default components if desired.

The ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) consistently shines in benchmarks, often leading or matching top performances among Windows Central’s tested laptops. In most cases, it delivers slightly better average performance from its Intel Core i9 compared to similar models, though the differences are so minor that they hardly matter.

Despite being relatively noisy due to its robust cooling system, one of the key benefits of the ROG Strix SCAR 18 is its exceptional thermal management. The laptop’s large number of vents and fans allow it to handle heavy workloads better than many other comparable models, but at the cost of generating a noticeable noise level whenever it needs to operate at full capacity.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Gaming performance

Gaming highlights

The ROG Strix SCAR 18’s phenomenal performance carries over into gaming, where it handles everything with aplomb.
You can comfortably play all the latest and greatest PC games at high to max settings with little fuss, and can do so for hours at a time.
However, this laptop is another reminder that you probably don’t need to spend all that extra cash for the RTX 4090 configuration.

When discussing a gaming laptop, key elements that lead to success include a display that adapts well, outstanding performance, and exceptional heat management – features the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) boasts. This powerhouse of a gaming device can handle even the most demanding PC games at maximum settings without any fuss or lagging behind. Whether you prioritize stunning graphics or smooth gameplay, this laptop minimizes the need for significant sacrifices.

Forza Horizon 5 — 137 FPS average on the Extreme preset with QHD+ (2,560 x 1,600) resolution, 240Hz refresh rate, display v-sync enabled, NVIDIA DLSS SR/DLAA/Reflex Low Latency disabled | 192 FPS average with all settings maxed, NVIDIA DLSS SR enabled and set to “Auto,” NVIDIA DLSS Frame Generation/Reflex Low Latency enabled, NVIDIA DLAA disabled
Gears 5 — 131 FPS average on the Recommended/Ultra preset with QHD+ (2,560 x 1,600) resolution, uncapped framerate, v-sync enabled
Cyberpunk 2077 — 81 FPS average on the Ray Tracing: Ultra preset with QHD+ (2,560 x 1,600) resolution, 240Hz refresh rate, display v-sync enabled, NVIDIA DLSS SR enabled and set to “Auto,” NVIDIA Reflex Low Latency enabled, NVIDIA DLSS Frame Generation/Ray Reconstruction disabled | 118 FPS average on the Ultra preset
Counter-Strike 2 — 180-217 FPS average on the Very High preset with QHD+ (2,560 x 1,600) resolution, 240Hz refresh rate, display v-sync enabled, NVIDIA Reflex Low Latency enabled, AMD FidelityFX SR disabled

Instead of this laptop, it seems like another instance emphasizing that you might not require the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4090. The pricier model offers fewer storage options than its cheaper counterpart (which you can easily upgrade), and it also comes with an RTX 4080 GPU. However, the performance difference is not significantly greater compared to the less expensive option.

In Forza Horizon 5 and Cyberpunk 2077 at maximum settings, the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 performs only slightly better than the Lenovo Legion Pro 7i (Gen 9) with an RTX-4080 GPU, averaging approximately 6 and 4 more frames per second respectively. However, in Counter-Strike 2, it runs more stably, while in Gears 5 and Cyberpunk 2077 on the Ultra preset, it shows a greater increase of 12 and 10 FPS respectively. Despite this, the laptop isn’t underperforming; the difference between a laptop-grade RTX 4080 and an RTX 4090 is not as significant as their price disparity might suggest.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Battery experience

Battery highlights

I never expected the ASUS ROG Strix Scar 18 to have even passable battery life, but it’s just bad.
Off the charger, you’ll be lucky to see even an hour and a half of battery life, even when reducing the display refresh rate to 60Hz.
The 330W charging adapter is certainly powerful enough, but the cable from the brick is far too short.
Battery rating: ⭐⭐

No gaming laptop is expected to have good battery life, but there is a difference between “acceptably bad” and “just plain bad.” The ROG Strix Scar 18 falls on the wrong side of that fence. I ran the laptop through Procyon, a benchmark suite, and its two hour-long Battery Consumption tests. In the first, which simulates a varied workload using Office applications, the ROG Strix Scar 18 burned through 63% of its 90Whr battery cell in just one hour. In the second, which loops an HD video with audio, the laptop dropped 44% of its charge in an hour.

In its standard configuration, the ROG Strix SCAR 18 was operating under the Balanced/Quiet performance mode, keeping its RGB illumination active but lowering the screen refresh rate to 60Hz. Unfortunately, even with these adjustments, you’d struggle to get more than two hours of operation on battery, as indicated by the Windows Battery Report. The standby time was also dismal, losing an average of 37% over a span of 16 hours and completely draining in less than two days.

The final nail is that the massive 330W barrel-plug charging adapter is annoyingly designed. The detachable cable that plugs into your outlet is long enough, but the permanently attached cable that plugs into your laptop is barely three feet from the humungous brick, so it barely reaches even when the brick is sitting on the floor directly below the laptop. I’m also not sure why the 18-inch version of the ROG Strix SCAR shares the same 90Whr cell with the 16-inch version, although I’m not sure the extra 10% legally allowed on airplanes in the US would’ve made much of a difference.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Keyboard and touchpad

Keyboard highlights

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 has a decent keyboard with a responsive feel and solid layout, but it’s nothing special.
The same can be said of its touchpad, which is glass and uses Microsoft Precision drivers, but is on the small side.
Annoyingly, there’s still no option to enable to function key row’s special actions as default.
Other features rating: ⭐⭐⭐½

For the majority of laptops, it’s essential to strike a good balance between the keyboard and touchpad. However, when it comes to gaming laptops, the preference clearly leans towards the keyboard. The ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) might not revolutionize the industry with its keyboard, but it does offer a satisfactory experience. The layout is robust, the key action is prompt and tactile, and you’ll find a number pad on the side to maximize the benefits of its large size.

Indeed, there isn’t a method yet available within MyASUS or Armoury Crate (neither does it have a keyboard shortcut) for toggling the function key row. As a result, you’ll need to keep pressing “Fn” whenever you wish to mute your speakers or capture a quick screenshot.

This touchpad offers an average performance, featuring a glass surface and Microsoft Precision software for gesture recognition. It’s not particularly large in comparison to the laptop, yet it manages to accomplish its tasks effectively. I can’t find much to criticize about it.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Other features

Other highlights

Rounding out the experience, the ROG Strix SCAR 18 doesn’t exceed expectations in any department, with a lack of focus on quality-of-life features.
The webcam is poor quality with no Windows Hello facial recognition, nor is there any other biometric authentication.
The speakers are loud but suffer in quality, especially at high volumes where you lose clarity and gain a lot of tinniness.

To complete the overall package, the ROG Strix SCAR 18 unfortunately maintains its quirks. Its 720p webcam performs passably at best, and its microphones match this performance well. This is not a laptop that suits frequent video conferencing or live streaming. Additionally, it lacks Windows Hello biometric authentication, which can be a letdown considering the price tag of $3,000.

Surprisingly, this large gaming laptop doesn’t deliver an exceptional sound system as you might anticipate. Instead, it features a typical quad-speaker arrangement, complete with dual 2W woofers, Dolby Atmos compatibility, and ASUS’ Smart Amp technology. However, the audio output is more about volume than quality. The speakers can get quite loud to overpower the fans, but at higher volumes, they lose clarity and detail. Overall, it’s not a particularly impressive audio experience, even at lower volumes.

The wireless functionality appears strong based on Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3 compatibility, though I must admit that I would have preferred the advanced Wi-Fi 7 and Bluetooth 5.4 for a more forward-looking approach. Regardless, the performance is satisfactory.

In terms of software, the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) operates on either Windows 11 Home or Pro, accompanied by a set of typical applications from ASUS, Intel, and NVIDIA. McAfee Antivirus remains slightly bothersome, while the preinstalled ASUS Virtual Pet is an unexpected feature. However, overall, the software performance is reliable. Armoury Crate still ranks among the better gaming hubs, despite its somewhat extravagant and awkward user interface.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Competition

Directly stated: This laptop isn’t the best choice if you’re content with a 16-inch screen. The Lenovo Legion Pro 7i (Gen 9) offers better refinement overall and similar performance, yet it costs less. If you require an 18-inch screen, this laptop also isn’t necessary. Instead, consider the Alienware m18 R2, which boasts impressive power and construction, but its IPS LCD display could use a bit more brightness.

If you’re seeking gaming laptops that offer an excessive amount of power, I suggest considering either of these two models. They are superior in terms of polish and affordability compared to the ROG Strix SCAR 18. For those who prioritize luxury, the Razer Blade 18 (2024) could be a choice, as it’s visually stunning and equipped with future-proof Thunderbolt 5 technology. However, you should be prepared to pay a higher price for this model, whereas the other laptops I mentioned will likely provide more consistent performance.

ROG Strix SCAR 18 review: Final thoughts

You should buy this if …

✅Your biggest (and only) priority is performance

The ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2022) prioritizes top-notch gaming laptop performance, featuring an advanced cooling system capable of handling intense power outputs. It’s ideal for individuals who refuse to settle on performance, putting it at the forefront.

✅You want a true portable desktop

If you require a portable gaming machine that performs like a desktop, consider the ROG Strix SCAR 18. Its size and battery life might not be ideal for constant travel, but since it’ll primarily stay on your desk, these aspects aren’t as crucial. Moreover, its spacious chassis ensures ample cooling for long-term heavy usage, preserving the components from overheating.

You should not buy this if …

❌You want a balanced gaming laptop with good quality-of-life features

In my analysis as a tech analyst, the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) boasts a top-tier CPU, GPU, and display, yet falls short in areas such as design, I/O, camera, audio quality, and more. While its performance is impressive, the laptop itself feels somewhat outdated compared to its powerful components, giving it an aged feel.

Regarding gaming, the ASUS ROG Strix SCAR 18 (2024) doesn’t skimp on power. A collaboration between Intel and NVIDIA ensures exceptional performance that rivals few others, making it a premium choice for smooth gameplay without sacrificing frame rate or graphics. This impressive power and the vibrant, high-definition MiniLED screen are what make the ROG Strix SCAR 18 stand out. However, some of the hardware features beyond performance and display quality seem to have been given less attention.

It also flies in the face of all the design improvements ASUS has made in its Zephyrus and Zenbook laptop lines, with an over-the-top, garish design that mashes together metal, transparent plastic, and RPG lighting with a mesh of aggressive lines. The ROG Strix SCAR 18 feels pulled straight out of 2017, and all the power in the world and an excellent MiniLED display can’t totally save it from the lack of refinement that comes with that.

2024-09-01 16:10